Tula Pahate Re thread - 14 - Page 24

Originally posted by: Hetp

@dipali

If Paranjpe can look different in current scene and flashback scene..

Then guy bringing post mortem reports kya cheez hai 🙈🤣😜

Btw for me

Guy giving reports to Rn and precap scene guy looks same as per posture.

Very true Hetal. 🤣

Now that you have posted photo, he possibly looks same. I had always thought that guy giving report to RN was different than who gave report to Gaja.

Let's see if the person gets alarmed or shocked. If he tries to contact Z, then we have to assume it's the same person.

Very interesting episode tonight but really missing Vikrant.

We got lot of hints. Ti Marathi mhan aahe na? Mani vase te swapni dise - tase zale aahe Ishache presumably.

So whatever Isha has remembered of the past, first flashbacks were after she fainted in her dreams. Then after Isha saw RN get TPR book as birthday gift, she searched and again miraculously found the book in her cupboard. We saw she had given it to Aaisaheb so how did the book again come back in her cupboard? Anyways so after that Isha was reading the book and whatever she saw/dreamt or imagined is based on what she has read.

That psychiatrist clearly said a person sometimes dreams about things he/she has seen or read about. So the mhan is apt here.

So everything comes to rest on that book. Strangely after reading that book RN had loved it and clearly said Vikrant and Sunayana lived happily. So either Isha hasn’t read the full book OR the book is changed.

Only Aaisaheb knew where the book was but Vikrant could have found the book also sometime later. The thing is it was Aaisaheb who mentioned the book to Isha, asked her to search for it and Isha after finding it in Vikrant’s cupboard gave it to Aaisaheb. So how did it again come to be in her cupboard?

As we saw today, it is quite possible for anyone to keep that book in that cupboard.

The book that makes Vikrant a murderer and Aaisaheb the saccharine sweet loving stepmother.

Problem is Vikrant wouldn’t want Isha to doubt him because her trust is most important fo him, so if he has read the book he wouldn’t want Isha to find it. He has kept all RN stuff in secret room.

Aaisaheb was the only one who was supposed know this “secret “ between her and RN. She was told to hide the book.

So is this the original version of book RN read? Or is this “edited” version? Has Isha read the book fully or just part of it?

All bookish confusion!

Originally posted by: dipalimanish

Very true Hetal. 🤣

Now that you have posted photo, he possibly looks same. I had always thought that guy giving report to RN was different than who gave report to Gaja.

Let's see if the person gets alarmed or shocked. If he tries to contact Z, then we have to assume it's the same person.

If Zende is told what Isha said to that man, he will readily believe the reincarnation stuff. Because he is the kind who believes all this.

He might try to kill Isha.

Agree Medha. They are trying to create confusion in viewers minds also if Isha is really RN reincarnation or not. Or is this just mind game of her ? From the time that book has entered serial, it has become important part of this past n present game.

Maybe like you said, Isha's visions till RN birthday were correct. But post that she started reading book. We don't know if she read it completely or not. Or whether book Isha got is same one or not. What if Isha's visions post RN's birthday are all wrong and based on this book which Isha is reading. In that case is it possible that DS's killer also can be someone else.

True what you said about yesterday's kaul. Isha got kaul that she is RN reincarnation and not Vikrant being killer.

Also too much stress was given on RN death on ashtami and Isha got visions of RN died on full moon.

Like you said Gaja married RN only for property but he might not be the killer. Possibly all this will continue till the time Vikrant realises value of relations, trust n love and falls for Isha. Then maybe her visions will change.

According to me Isha has not completed reading the book.

Because when Isha woke up after visualising VS killing RN... book was lying next to her where she was sleeping.

If Isha would have completely read the book then she would have closed the book.

According to Rajnandini..

She was happy while reading the book and the book had happy ending.😊

RN and AS knew about the book as it was 'secret' between them.

But what we are shown is...

when Isha fainted she recollected good memories of RN.

But the moment Isha started reading the book she recollected all bad memories of RN.

Who is behind this and why all this is happening the moment Isha started reading the book? Is book being tampered by AS after RN death also made it sure Isha finds the book and reads it?

Isha gets dreams about she running to save her life on Ashtami night.

SO is that related to RN or about Isha only?

If its related to RN...

then whatever dreams Isha has seen are not true.

Because Isha is scared about Coloured faces and dreams about running to save her life.

That should have happened with Rajnandini too...also the building which we see in title song.

So building,coloured face and running to save her life should be linked about RN death which isha has not visualised at all.

But if its related to Isha

Then may be its her six sense that it might happen with her in future about someone trying to kill her....someone with coloured face,running to save her life and that building.

One more thing

We didnt get RN wearing that pink sari also that shawl in flashback scenes.

It was because of AS we got to know pink sari and shawl belongs to RN.

So again should we say AS is creating situation in such a way to purposely prove Isha is RN.

And as per promo-

Shawl was in Visha room.

Isha is shown with shawl,pink sari and Tula Pahate Re book.

Shawl was kept in AS cupboard... so how come Shawl will come in Visha room?

Originally posted by: dipalimanish

Agree Medha. They are trying to create confusion in viewers minds also if Isha is really RN reincarnation or not. Or is this just mind game of her ? From the time that book has entered serial, it has become important part of this past n present game.

Maybe like you said, Isha's visions till RN birthday were correct. But post that she started reading book. We don't know if she read it completely or not. Or whether book Isha got is same one or not. What if Isha's visions post RN's birthday are all wrong and based on this book which Isha is reading. In that case is it possible that DS's killer also can be someone else.

True what you said about yesterday's kaul. Isha got kaul that she is RN reincarnation and not Vikrant being killer.

Also too much stress was given on RN death on ashtami and Isha got visions of RN died on full moon.

Like you said Gaja married RN only for property but he might not be the killer. Possibly all this will continue till the time Vikrant realises value of relations, trust n love and falls for Isha. Then maybe her visions will change.

We don’t know anything at all. Is it possible to get visions without being reincarnation? What Isha sees in promo RN as her mirror image can also be her imagination.

Also Isha is readily believing all this because systematically she has received information which made her scared of Vikrant. First his hiding his real name, then Paranjape telling Isha raktache paat, Isha getting hint from Aaisaheb about Gaja Patil, about she thinks Isha is RN and shawl mention. Like Hetal wrote, we never saw RN using that shawl, or that pink saree, or play Holi. Let’s think they wanted to show short track so cut out Holi but it was easily possible to show RN using that shawl. Is is amnesia from Guru’s part or it that deliberate?

At this point Isha will far more easily believe bad stuff about Vikrant than good. If the book has wrong information her dreams are also wrong.

Isha mentioned RN death was on Ashtami and Isha getting dreams from childhood also on Ashtami. So maybe her dream showing full moon night is a way for her to realise that dream was wrong?Because it has to be Ashtami.

That last telephone call Dadasaheb made to Advocate scene is really suspicious or hint scene. Why was it shown if he had already changed his will? So it was for someone most likely Aaisaheb to hear and think he is going to give all property to RN. Aaisaheb had motive and opportunity.

Agree with your last para in bold. Vikrant has to realise and value his love and relationship. Like Isha had told him, till he has secrets from her she cannot trust him. When he learns she knows about Gaja Patil he might reveal all to her and win her trust.

Why has Vikrant kept RN’s asthi kalash?

Originally posted by: Hetp

According to me Isha has not completed reading the book.

Because when Isha woke up after visualising VS killing RN... book was lying next to her where she was sleeping.

If Isha would have completely read the book then she would have closed the book.

According to Rajnandini..

She was happy while reading the book and the book had happy ending.😊

RN and AS knew about the book as it was 'secret' between them.

But what we are shown is...

when Isha fainted she recollected good memories of RN.

But the moment Isha started reading the book she recollected all bad memories of RN.

Who is behind this and why all this is happening the moment Isha started reading the book? Is book being tampered by AS after RN death also made it sure Isha finds the book and reads it?

Agree with you Hetal. Clearly shows Isha hasn’t finished reading the book. Who knows the book further story might be all these were deliberate misunderstandings or the book itself is changed? Isha might read it fully later and think different.

Originally posted by: Hetp

Isha gets dreams about she running to save her life on Ashtami night.

SO is that related to RN or about Isha only?

If its related to RN...

then whatever dreams Isha has seen are not true.

Because Isha is scared about Coloured faces and dreams about running to save her life.

That should have happened with Rajnandini too...also the building which we see in title song.

So building,coloured face and running to save her life should be linked about RN death which isha has not visualised at all.

But if its related to Isha

Then may be its her six sense that it might happen with her in future about someone trying to kill her....someone with coloured face,running to save her life and that building.

One more thing

We didnt get RN wearing that pink sari also that shawl in flashback scenes.

It was because of AS we got to know pink sari and shawl belongs to RN.

So again should we say AS is creating situation in such a way to purposely prove Isha is RN.

And as per promo-

Shawl was in Visha room.

Isha is shown with shawl,pink sari and Tula Pahate Re book.

Shawl was kept in AS cupboard... so how come Shawl will come in Visha room?

Agree with all your points. I think Isha’s dreams from childhood hint at this happened to RN. Because it is more possible to be about RN what had happened than get dreams of something that might happen to Isha 12-13 years in future.

It is quite possible for anyone to keep that book in that cupboard. It was supposed to be a secret between RN and Aaisaheb. Also Vikrant has kept all RN stuff in that room not outside.

Aaisaheb mentioned the book and it came back in Isha room when she had given it to Aaisaheb. Shawl was with Aaisaheb.

Originally posted by: dipalimanish

Not sure about that Mishkil. She was just shown reading it only once. Next time Isha was shown in RN track she got up from sleep saying vachva mala, that was when RN was killed.