I think the appreciation she has gotten is in proportion to all the good work she has done.
Yes, I find Vidya better, but then , it isn't as if Tapsee has gotten some sort of excess praise or opportunities,( or awards like Vidya), has she? Yes, she might need to bring in more variations in her acting but, if she is completely out of her elements in a role, she will get caught and criticized (e.g.: Alia in Kalank) . Till then, she will get her due for job well done in the roles that she is doing.
We have so many actors who get awards despite playing portraying same kind of roles or playing roles the same way. We have so many actors who have the entire industry behind them to magnify one good performance as career defining, and propel that narrative over and over again till the award season comes.
People like Tapsee just have their work. No link up rumours to make herself more "interesting" . It took her years to get a solo interview with Anupama Chopra. She still won't have more airtime in award shows. Jitesh Pillai will give a Boney Kapoor the front row seats but not her.
Actors like her have to hustle all the time to be seen, heard and stay relevant, because they don't have a ready-made ecosystem waiting for them to make things easy.
21