Why I feel the gang is not selfish reagrding swamun - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.5k

Users

13

Likes

50

Frequent Posters

MOH29 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#11
Yes I also agree that in swamun case no gang is at fault they are the one who is responsible. I already mentioned in one of my earlier post that swati always wanted to see sameer in munna. She never accept him as it is. From starting she always tries to suppress naina against sameer. I doubt whether she play best friends role proper . In navratri track when sunaina tries to defame naina she kept quite . Which friends does that even if you have controversy you can't tolerate that action. I found preeti more supportive than swati.
In her love life also I think she accept it wholeheartedly because she recognized munna's love when sameer and naina make them understand. After her roka also sameer tells munna to make elopment but munna refuse because somewhere he knows they can't fight . May be munna took step but he knows swati never . So at the end their love was lacking trust and faith in each other. May be it is a one-sided love. I really felt bad for munna
becool97 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#12
I agree with you.It is very easy to blame someone but hard to imagine us in their shoes.The gang is not at all at fault.They also asked him if the helped him to elope with her,They would have helped him in every way.If he would have cried they would have lend him shoulders.But munna is poignant and yet happy.He had understood that the relationship had failed but doesn't blame swati because he knows that they were equally at fault.And naina being selfish is okay.She prioritizes sameer a little bit over others and she wouid have listened to swati if she wouid not have called in wrong time.I agree that during the election track it is gang's fault but i did not like when swati went overboard and said that she has been a shadow of her.she has inferiority complex deeply rooted within her.She herself taunted naina as padhaku and pyar na samajhne wali.And Naina is not a bad friend.If she had been a bad friend she wouid have take revenge but she let her free as she understood that she is having a hard time and issues to sort out.She still considered her as friend.she trusted her blindly.So it is nobody's fault.Sometimes life puts you in such situations that we cannot segregate good and bad.We all are grey right?
And swati had always jump to conclusion.How easily she trusted sunaina.If they had such a long friendship she shouid have tried harder to talk to her.Such a long friendship and still she has insecurities.Insecurities is not good in any relationship.Agree that it was gang's fault to ignore her worth.But she still couid have stood for herself and present her concerns more openly.She always hides things and doesnot speak her heart out so she is at fault too.So is munna.She always compares munna with sameer and their relationship with samaina.But the truth is every relationship is different and needs equal commitment.She sees love with rose tinted glasses but love is not all about beauty its about tears too.As naina said wo toh kaanton ka taaz bhi hota hai.Couid swati love munna with his flaws?😕I think not.Will she will be able to bear the brunt of sameer as naina does?
She dreams of a perfect relationship with a perfect guy.But is life perfect always?
So she never escaped the shadow of sameer and never saw munna in his own merit.Had seen seen munna differently she wouid have tried with her life to go any lengths for him.And munna was also blinded by the friendship to little notice her merits.And she also did not understood the dimensions of their friendship.Naina knows that she can never take the place of mundit and accepts that.But swati wants her guy to give all attention to her.These are the key cause for fail of their relationship
And even if they wouid have eloped and married with the help of the gang,still they wouid have been unhappy because of each others contrasting nature.
But i am not a swati hater.I too sympathize with her.But saying that munna and naina are totally at fault will be blasphemy.I certainly dislike the way CVs rushed things but still happy that they showed it realistically.Its not about faults but it is about perspectives.I am happy that munna has realised his fault.Hope the give proper closure to this track with swatina"s emotional convo.
Laalchi_Reader thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#13
I agree to each and every bit of your post
Swamun are themselves responsible for their separation
Their friends are nowhere in picture for their condition
I always found their relationship mere a one sided crush
Its not like only one person is at falt ..
Neither munna was right in ignoring swati's words nor Swati was right in comparing munna with sameer
Due to her this insecure and complex nature in ever connected to her character ..
She always desired to have a guy like sameer in her life who will be romantic just like a filmy hero
For me they had a breakup when she complained about naina snatching sameer from her to sunaina ...
I just knew they are not ment to be
I do think we will get Swati' s POV too and this track will get a proper closure
Itsflora thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: becool97

I agree with you.It is very easy to blame someone but hard to imagine us in their shoes.The gang is not at all at fault.They also asked him if the helped him to elope with her,They would have helped him in every way.If he would have cried they would have lend him shoulders.But munna is poignant and yet happy.He had understood that the relationship had failed but doesn't blame swati because he knows that they were equally at fault.And naina being selfish is okay.She prioritizes sameer a little bit over others and she wouid have listened to swati if she wouid not have called in wrong time.I agree that during the election track it is gang's fault but i did not like when swati went overboard and said that she has been a shadow of her.she has inferiority complex deeply rooted within her.She herself taunted naina as padhaku and pyar na samajhne wali.And Naina is not a bad friend.If she had been a bad friend she wouid have take revenge but she let her free as she understood that she is having a hard time and issues to sort out.She still considered her as friend.she trusted her blindly.So it is nobody's fault.Sometimes life puts you in such situations that we cannot segregate good and bad.We all are grey right?
And swati had always jump to conclusion.How easily she trusted sunaina.If they had such a long friendship she shouid have tried harder to talk to her.Such a long friendship and still she has insecurities.Insecurities is not good in any relationship.Agree that it was gang's fault to ignore her worth.But she still couid have stood for herself and present her concerns more openly.She always hides things and doesnot speak her heart out so she is at fault too.So is munna.She always compares munna with sameer and their relationship with samaina.But the truth is every relationship is different and needs equal commitment.She sees love with rose tinted glasses but love is not all about beauty its about tears too.As naina said wo toh kaanton ka taaz bhi hota hai.Couid swati love munna with his flaws? 😕I think not.Will she will be able to bear the brunt of sameer as naina does?
She dreams of a perfect relationship with a perfect guy.But is life perfect always?
So she never escaped the shadow of sameer and never saw munna in his own merit.Had seen seen munna differently she wouid have tried with her life to go any lengths for him.And munna was also blinded by the friendship to little notice her merits.And she also did not understood the dimensions of their friendship.Naina knows that she can never take the place of mundit and accepts that.But swati wants her guy to give all attention to her.These are the key cause for fail of their relationship
And even if they wouid have eloped and married with the help of the gang,still they wouid have been unhappy because of each others contrasting nature.
But i am not a swati hater.I too sympathize with her.But saying that munna and naina are totally at fault will be blasphemy.I certainly dislike the way CVs rushed things but still happy that they showed it realistically.Its not about faults but it is about perspectives.I am happy that munna has realised his fault.Hope the give proper closure to this track with swatina"s emotional convo.


100% agreed.I'm blaming no one.Not a single character out of the 7 of them.
See,Swati is a real girl with lots of insecurities & dreams but never exprese those.so can't blame her for all the decisions she took.her character was developed this way only.
Naina?selfish?seriously?
Remember sameer did all the job but naina made swati assistant GS?
She told about sameer to swati before even priti.
Naina never said a word against her after swati left for the kartik gang.NoT A Word!
Naina even was ready to jump off the roof to get Munna's approval for their relation.
Sameer's house have been literally mundit's home too.
Samaina gave mundit utmost importance.So,Why wont they care for samaina's love life then?
But swati was never so considerate about those frndship like naina.
Again,that's how patient Naina's character has been since the beginning.
Munna?My heart broke for him coz he knew his /their limitations and lackings.
Their relation was never a two way road.He knew he can't make swati happy so he let her go.I loved that sense of reality in him just as I loved him when he hit sameer in delhi track.This funny guy knows the difference b&w Right and wrong.So,he is not trying to salvage a relation which he cant save.He saved sameer coz he had that power over sameer.But his fwp never granted him that much right.
As a viewer mayb the only thing we feel missing is some conversation which may come up during exam track.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".