Ashwarya stunned her critics today…. - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

66

Views

5.6k

Users

14

Frequent Posters

Bhaskar.T thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#61
Sorry tpam as the Dev team here I don't agree to what you are saying. This is a forum. Everyone has a right to post in any thread. They can criticise too. But stick to music while criticising. And not resort to mudslinging on any contestants family and other factors like conspiracy stuff.

This is exactly what few did in the thread. Everyone was praising the Friday's rendition of Aishwarya when a post is made on 100% non musical issues. And that resulted int such a situation. To wish for anyone's elimination, to criticise any performance is all part of discussion and will carry on as long as it does not break any forum rules. But if any personal attacks are made on anyone be it any contestant or fellow member action will be taken though in this particular thread few of such acts have been ignored.

Hope things are clear now for everyone.

advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#62

My comments in blue below :😳

Originally posted by: diya sen

Acceptable or not, that's how things are. Whether you close your eyes to it or not shows your own stand on whether things should be fair or unfair. So if you have decided to close your eyes to it shows that you favour unfair things taking place.

Achcha. So anyone else who thinks there can be another talented performer besides Anvesha or who feels Ashwarya should not be be made a scapegoat in this as she may also have her side of the story to tell , becomes the unfair one supporting unfair things.Now how fair is that ...🤣🤣🤣

Everyone knows the way things are running on this show lack transparency.

The lack of transparency or backstage nuisance -this was known from long time back. We have time and again brought that point forward. But then we got branded again for being unfair to the most clean show.If this action was fair then why does it suddenly became unfair now...🤔

Ash being given a gold necklace for a so-so performance proves it further.

Why can't Ash be given the necklace? had she not performed well that day? Doesn't Alka have a right to make her choice. Its her necklace, her wish, who are we to object ? Badde log badde badde baat.

Incidentally, Anvesha had given quite an ordinary perfromance for the Black song(acid test) and Shreya had given her 100/100. Now what was that?

Mukesh Bhatt another gujarati was celled again.

Whats wrong if Mukesh Bhatt is a Gujarati ? Why cant he be called ? He is one of those who can actually give someone a break. There should be more like him who should be called.

Actually the way those Star TV actors campaigned for Anvesha, that stood out of place. All they went on doing was speaking in bengali and telling the bengal crowd to wake up. Why? Anvesha should get votes from all the regions then why try this angle to get sympathy or votes from only bengal? was that fair ?

Otherwise apart from Alka, guests have always praised ANVESHA more. Be it SHAAN , ILA ARUN, EMRAAN AND SHONAL, VIDYA or anyone else.

But mind you- the voting janata has not. Shouldn't they be the one praising by giving more votes. No has has tied up their hands. Why are they not voting?

Also one supporter of hers has himself acknowledged parents of contestants in another show protested against Ash and her family. Everybody is not fools na!!

Just because someone says something we believe it? 😆 I dont believe so.

Edited by advil - 18 years ago
ambika_thatti thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: diya sen

Hi Even Abhijit, praised Aishwarya last saturday. He even compared her to Maa Saraswathi. And other celebrity judge Adnan Sami, too praised Aishwarya (compared her to Asha Bhosle) more compared to Anwesha. And these are not Gujarathis..

I am South Indian..so I guess I am fairly neutral. I like Anwesha as she is a gifted child and sings flawlessly , but to prove that one need not have to bring down another gifted child Aishwarya as she too is a fab singer and the judges rated her no. 2 only next to Anwesha..

advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: diya sen

I am not saying anything about any other supporter. Everyone is free to like whom they like, be it SONIYA or PRAKRITI.

By the way, if people are free to like Soniya or Prakriti, why aren't they free to like Ashwarya ?😉Ha ha .... Ashwarya must be definitely a good competition to make Anvesha's fan to react thus..

But with regards to ash, def. things are unfair. She has never been outstanding, and the day she got the necklace anvesha was FAR better.

Is that your opinion? then you are welcome to have it. But most like me believe that Ashwariya is OUSTANDING and is the only one who can give Anvesha a run for the money .Acually she has every potential to walk away with the prize money too.😛 Ashwarya was given a necklace- she did not ask for it, she did not hold a gun on Alka's head either that alka had to give it to her. Alka gave her because she wanted to. Please go to the Ashwarya - the gifted child thread and hear her songs again. Or else, simply go and hear her Last friday's performance. That was one of the best performances till date - and yes- it was outstanding !

in fact, alka refused to even satnd up for anvesha but went all the way to the stage to give that necklace!! so watch that episode again to refresh your memory.

May be Alka did not like Anvesha's performance as much. May be she does not think like a Anvesha fan... she has a right to choose, right?

And so what if bengali vote appeals were made? that was gajji,not anvesha's planning. And that was only because a talented singer was not getting votes!!

WOw ! This is interesting! when something is done to gain Anvesha sympathy, it is acceptable but having even a reputed producer in the show who happens to be from Gujarat, is a conspiracy to push ashwariya forward ... ha ha ha ha I need the ROFL's now..🤣

The same happened with the other Bengali contestant, GEETASRI. she was as good as ASH--mind you, she is not trained and she comes from a poor family-- still she gave very good performances. Unlike ash, she never forgot her lyrics but beacuse of KUNAL who gave her less rankings then even MANSI(what a joke!!) she had to leave the show. isn't that unfair???

Anvesha also stopped once midway-remember?😆

Ashwariya is a great singer and connects well with audience. Why else do you think they vote her so much and that too when she never had to have a voting campaign done for her benefit ? guess that answers it..😛

And just for your kind information, anvesha was excellent in the Black song. All judges said that,not just shreya. Shreya is full justified to give her 100%.

As per your logic,if judges saying is the biggest proof of talent, then Abhijeet compared Ash her with Maa Saraswati. Alka gave her the chain. Now doesn't that also make her something 😳

I think Areeb and soniya had sung far better than her on that song. She may have been good technically but she did not touch the heart.It was definitely not worth a 100. All the 3 judges have always been partial towards Anvesha - they have campaigned the most for her and this Black song is a classic case of that

Do you think you can sing that song better? So think beofre you write. That was one of the best performances in this show.

Edited by advil - 18 years ago
Bhaskar.T thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: ambika_thatti



Where does region comes when supporting talent. Here I am from Himachal. There's one supporting her from Bengal. Please lets keep this regional part away. Because fact is Aishwarya is getting votes from around the nation and not from a single region.

I fully support you on the bolded part. Its so unfortunate that one thread was there praising a contestant's fab performance and here few come to make all non musical statements to pull her down. Thus ending into the thread turning ugly.

avijee thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#66
Bahskar, I think better close this topic before this talent debate gets into a lethal war of words. 😭
I agree to post all Ashwarya's comments on Ashwarya's Appreciation Thread.
Bhaskar.T thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: avijee

Bahskar, I think better close this topic before this talent debate gets into a lethal war of words. 😭
I agree to post all Ashwarya's comments on Ashwarya's Appreciation Thread.



Thanks a lot Avijee. Topic is being closed on the request of the author.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".