How would you have shown K,M n N's Silsila?

NoFace thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
EMA is sensitive and bold topic but living in 21st cen we are now more open about these issues.

Yet Silsila is bashed left n right bcoz of EMA...although it is not bcoz of the theme but due to its poor execution and character development😆


Kunal came out as a characterless lusty loser

Nandini as an ungrateful,selfish,obsessive woman

Mauli as a helpless victim( mahan in some extent bcoz she still cares about them)

but if you have the chance to re-write the story and characters...how would you do it?😉

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.3k

Users

11

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

nimitha12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
If i can rewrite story.. i would have made nandini turning to a independant woman with the help of both mauli and kunal. Starting a catering service may be? The 3 sharing a good friendship bond
For silsila element.. nandini can fall in love with kunal looking at how amazing hubby he is. But she will control herself.
And kunal will never cheat mauli. At some point he get emotional support from nandini and he may feel something for nandini too. But again wont cross limit. I dont believe that a man who is deeply in love with a woman for 7+ years can fall out of her. So he too may develope some feeling for nandini after long time but wont turn to lust
And mouli.. she is still good in show.. but yeah she wont push kunal and nandini much?
Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: nimitha12

If i can rewrite story.. i would have made nandini turning to a independant woman with the help of both mauli and kunal. Starting a catering service may be? The 3 sharing a good friendship bond

For silsila element.. nandini can fall in love with kunal looking at how amazing hubby he is. But she will control herself.
And kunal will never cheat mauli. At some point he get emotional support from nandini and he may feel something for nandini too. But again wont cross limit. I dont believe that a man who is deeply in love with a woman for 7+ years can fall out of her. So he too may develope some feeling for nandini after long time but wont turn to lust
And mouli.. she is still good in show.. but yeah she wont push kunal and nandini much?



THIS _/\_

When I initially saw the promo I assumed tat its only Nandini who ll fall for Kunal. Kunal ll feel bad for her, may b ve some care/affection but not love. Nandini suppresses her love. But 1 day somehow Kunal finds out. So its more like unrequited love on Nandini's side & sympathy from Kunal.
sherma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#4
When I had heard about this show I actually thought it might b tat nandini n kunal were college lovers cause of circumstances separated n now life got them together in front of each other but they don't wanna hurt mauli
Saw few episodes n then I realized it could b annadini fall for kunal seeing maunal together or how cute the Jodi was.
N kunal just feeling emotionally attached.
As a viewer I can't understand when n how kuanl fell for nandini.in the initial episodes maunal were very happy ekdum perfect couple. N how can ny1 fall for a chrcter nandini. Her chrcter is quite boring n always crying.such a turn off.
I hope the cvs should have made nandin n kunal chrcter little real n appealing. I can still get mauli mom or rajdeep revenge but can't understand kunan

NoFace thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: nimitha12

If i can rewrite story.. i would have made nandini turning to a independant woman with the help of both mauli and kunal. Starting a catering service may be? The 3 sharing a good friendship bond

For silsila element.. nandini can fall in love with kunal looking at how amazing hubby he is. But she will control herself.
And kunal will never cheat mauli. At some point he get emotional support from nandini and he may feel something for nandini too. But again wont cross limit. I dont believe that a man who is deeply in love with a woman for 7+ years can fall out of her. So he too may develope some feeling for nandini after long time but wont turn to lust
And mouli.. she is still good in show.. but yeah she wont push kunal and nandini much?



It would have been much more realistic and acceptable 😊

NoFace thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Angels11



THIS _/\_

When I initially saw the promo I assumed tat its only Nandini who ll fall for Kunal. Kunal ll feel bad for her, may b ve some care/affection but not love. Nandini suppresses her love. But 1 day somehow Kunal finds out. So its more like unrequited love on Nandini's side & sympathy from Kunal.



Exactly kunal falling for her 1st was unexpected 😕
It looked more like lust then love
Mishfan thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Angels11



THIS _/\_

When I initially saw the promo I assumed tat its only Nandini who ll fall for Kunal. Kunal ll feel bad for her, may b ve some care/affection but not love. Nandini suppresses her love. But 1 day somehow Kunal finds out. So its more like unrequited love on Nandini's side & sympathy from Kunal.



I always assumed the opposite. Kunal falling for N..(some men will be men, you see )
while N being a victim of severe abuse & the kind of friendship she shared with M,
forget entertaining such thoughts, but would
not even be mentally strong to think about men , love, reln.ships etc...

And as the show progressed, & they showed her feelings, I was still hoping she would suppress
them since her bond with M would be stronger than any other feelings.
But All we got was this stupid immature story


looseseal thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#8
oh if the past could be undone...

I'd start with establishing good friendship between the three leads. And gradually show Nandini fall for Kunal, the husband. Yes, the husband part is very important. She sees Kunal as the perfect husband ( just like N said in one of the episodes, i think) and lets just say she likes what she sees. But of course nothing happens because in my version N isn't self-pitying selfish prick. Also she is very aware of her growing feelings and she works to keep that in check without being too dramatic about it. to add bit of grey in her character I would give her scenes where she fantasizes about K and her being married or being close with him. She also doesnt completely dissapear drom K and M's life, but thats mostly because M wouldnt let her. And of course keeping in mind that this is an indian soap I'd definately allow them one refuge in a candle lit appartement or a stable or candle lit stable in a stormy night but they arent allowed to touch one another 😆
And on the other side K too is getting closer to N but not in lovey dovey way but just in general. He realizes that maybe be they are getting little too close. So again he too is very aware of his feelings but he also cant just say "lets not talk to N anymore" because of M. So, we see K who is quite happy in his marriage and yet is also very aware of his growing fondness for N. We see his confusion, more than struggling with feelings i'd like him be confused because he thought he was in a happy marriage with a wife he adores and yet N makes him weirdly very happy. (So, yeah even in my version K is very confused. But atleast he isn't shameless prick who apparently doesnt care about the society.) To add bit negative in him i'd show him getting little overprotective and thinking little too much about N (not in a sleezy way but like calling her to ask simple things, wearing sth N likes even though M doesnt like it or sth) and maybe even prioritizing N over M but then also quickly realizing his mistakes and making up to M.
And then dear Mouli, i think M would stay more or less same. I would however add few scenes where she senses that K is bit distant (because he is having one of his confusion sessions). M&K have conversations and once K knows that M is worried about them he too makes effort in his marriage which doesnt always work.
All this while the three maintain her friendship. For few months of the show I'd show N working on her emotional and mental health, N and K fighting their feelings and K and M are in good place but they have their own problems too. I'd show N making new friends and meeting a guy. And M teasing her about the guy and ultimately the guy being the catalyst for N and K where they both acknowledge their for the other to themselves but never tell the other.
So slowly N starts building her own life. And she is quite happy, is being wooed by some guy who is also a decent character. And N sees that there are nice guys other than K, but she cant completely get over him. She tells the new guy about her love for K and M overhears her. This is where M gets to be bit grey and be upset with N for even thinking about K in that way. She is mad at N and she explodes and tells K everything. When K doesnt react the way she expects him to, she starts getting bit suspicious. they start having more fights. Then K calls N but N doesnt want to talk to K behind M's back. But K insists that N cant just go out of their lives and M will eventually understand. But in soap opera fashion M comes to know that K and N are talking (maybe even meeting) behind her back. She confronts K and he finally confesses his love for N. And M and N are both shocked with confession and both mad at K. ( I definately would have added a scene where N tell K how she thought K was a perfect husband but he too turn out to be a cheater). With this comes an end to the friendship saga of these three. the story will focus more on K not knowing whether to work on his marriage with M as he was quite happy with M but on the other hand he knows he loves N and isn't sure if he can make the marriage work. Also this now stops N from moving forward with the new guy as she knows that K is also in love with her (she tells the guy "Mouli ki ghar toot rahe waqt mein main apne ghar nahi basa sakti" or sth like that). Last but not the least M is very mad obviously but she sees K making effort. She comes to know nth happened between K and N, ever. Despite all the emotions involved only relations they ever had was that of friendship. They all try and make the K and M marriage work (N cuts contact from them and moves to some other city) but ultimately K and M realize that the love and trust that is basis of any relationship is already lost in their marriage and that its never going to be same as before. So, they both agree to part ways, both very sad but not angry.

Last episode would be M and N bumping into one another after years and M ask N if she wants to go for coffee . and they talk about the past where N is still very guilty but M tells N that the divorce wasnt on N or even on K. most likey if not N it would have been someone else and the other woman might not even had the courtesy to stay away. She tells that she is very happy in her life. They wonder where K would be right now (as they havent seen him in years) and finally we see K who is in a happy relationship with a woman who dresses and acts like N ( idk why i thought about this. i guess it just shows that N was really his type and M was kind of an exception. i am myself not very convinced with this. Kunal in my head- and on screen- is a very confused character which makes it very difficult to give him one definitive ending).
anmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Angels11



THIS _/\_

When I initially saw the promo I assumed tat its only Nandini who ll fall for Kunal. Kunal ll feel bad for her, may b ve some care/affection but not love. Nandini suppresses her love. But 1 day somehow Kunal finds out. So its more like unrequited love on Nandini's side & sympathy from Kunal.


This would've been ideal and that's what most people deduced from the promos!
I would've definitely worked on Nandini's character! Firstly she was shown to be in trauma but was always decked up! I don't think anyone would wanna concentrate on their looks while they're going through so much (after coming to Kunal and Mauli's house). Why would one dress up like a seductress at their friend's house unless their intentions aren't good to begin with!
Secondly even if you keep the storyline the same, I would wanna show Nandini as a greyish/negative character because makers hell bent on showing her to be an angel is what ruined it altogether! She keeps on doing everything wrong yet never feels that she could be wrong! Like seriously??? 😕
Even if they had mutual attraction or whatever they should've been shown to display some character and not slept together! What absolutely ruined the show for me was their sex scene border lining soft po*n! Just grossed me out 🤢 Intimate scenes shot aesthetically between the leads who happen to be in a genuine relationship are ok but them trying to portray the show as "bold with this kinda crap just killed it so yea I definitely wouldn't have gone for something as explicit as that!
Edited by anmirza - 6 years ago
rhondasa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#10
Interesting...I would basically swap Kunal with Mauli...Nandini Kunal were close childhood friends (Kunal secretly had a soft corner for her nandini was unaware of it)...Nandini marraige fixed to RD...Kunal warns her bout him...she choses to believe RD...Kunal is hurt and leaves...years later they meet again...he is happily married to Mauli...he saves Nandini from RD and gives shelter in his house...old feeling reemerge...this time Nandini also responds...leading to ema...both are guilty and aware its wrong...Mauli finds out and leaves Kunal...K & N decides to not pursue d relationship...and part ways...Kunal works on his relationship with Mauli nd for her forgiveness...dey get back together after a lot of convincing by Kunal(lot of drama der)...Nandini moves on in her life to become an independent person...years later they meet at an event...dey share a moment ver dey both connect...both are genuinely happy to see each other happily settled in life.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".