Was Suwarna wrong in blaming Naira for Shubhams death ?

Page

Next Last

abhilasha_dream

@abhilasha_dream

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

Till date we all thought that Naira got to know about Shubhams addiction only 1 day prior and so she hiding it from the family and getting to know of the drugs which Shubham was taking would not be possible.

But by making the doctor say that Naira had brought Shubham for numerous sessions makes her guilty.

Doctors statement proves that Suvarna blaming her was not wrong. Forget telling the family, she did not tell it to Karthik also which she could have done easily by taking hin under confidence in their room.

Naira was not handling a drug addict for the first time, she has had a first hand brush up with her cousin Nannu on this. So she not telling her husband also was wrong.

The only good thing about today's episode was that Karthik had apologized for his mistakes before this doctor popped up to reveal a few facts coz apologizing after knowing things makes no sense as then it means that you don't trust your partner.

Quote

Frequent Posters

AnyaRSingh

@AnyaRSingh

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

That one day before kartik's birthday dragged on for ages...🤣

Hence naira was able to take shubham multiple times to the hospital for treatment

they should have said that i remember her coming once with shubham and how stubborn shubham was or even that resort could have called with some thing the goenkas left and it could have been a tape of kartik's party where in naira is saying shel tell everyone and shubham begged her not to

today's episode along with naira's apology have been the biggest goofs in the entire track

+_+

Look naira can be mahaan but ma made alot of galtis

so ma should apologize +_+

I am sorry but just giving us the lame excuse her son died is not enough!

She destroyed her living son's life

+_+ she treated naira like a worm when she once called naira her own child

she treated keerti like dirt...

prayed numerous times for naira to be separated from kartik

As a die hard fan i feel cheated by the way this track is wrapping up😭

the only thing that keeps held on like glue is shivin and how meant for each other they are😆

other wise i would run away

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ArtisiaR

@ArtisiaR

Beginner

Posted: 7 years ago

CV Kaira's evidence of Naira's innocence is super faulty. Suwarna is not blaming Naira because she didn't help Shubham- She hates Naira bc Naira didn't share a serious issue abt her son- which according to the evidence video is still true.

Nothing is changed for Suwarna except Karthik no longer on her side

Quote

Fireiswithinus

@Fireiswithinus

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

if u listen and see clearly the episode u will find that naira in first case didn't tell the familiy members because she came to know about it a day before...just a day n she was about to call when shubham begged he even tried to stop doing drugs...if u remember the twist in the bed in night
now in second case which was shown today...the doctor said if naira will tell the family shubham will stop the treatment hence coming harm to him...he almost emotionally blackmailed him in his mother's name
In both the cases naira was to be blamed . no matter what she did she would be thrown out ...think if she told everyone ,...the family that goenkas are would have said something n other to shubham which will cause emotional breakdown leading him to do drugs,...

in every aspect naira would be blamed...if u r seeing this serial u would know how swrna declared him dead many years ago for god's sake she was doing shrad...when at that time manish could forgive her...
why is that in the name of maa ka dard kartik couldn't do the same...
naira is not the mother here...swrna is...she was so blind... that she fought with naira on that girl which was a gold digger...naira has always supported her always ...not even once i have seen her going against swrna...
she is not guilty...but yes they have given her a scene where they r showing respect by begging in front of her...

and btw if u talk about hiding things swrna did it years back also that doesn't give her a right to separate a husband and wife... u do not have the right to say to ur son " tum jao apni naira ke pass "
And when she taunted her every chance she got... she shows that she is not caring for her living son but getting revenge on her dead son !!!1

Quote

rose2015

@rose2015

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

By changing the storyline from Naira knowing about Shubnam's drug habit on Karthik's birthday to now knowing for some time and taking him for treatment makes it look worse for her. That means she kept this secret not just for one day but a long time.

Writers theory is now Naira brought him for multiple appts with the doctor and there is even video tape of it. (who videotapes - no logic) Before it was she was holding off to tell Karthik the next day after his birthday celebration when Shubnam then dies.

I know nothing makes sense but we are talking about indian tv serials where anything goes.

Edited by rose2015 - 7 years ago

Quote

cooldreams

@cooldreams

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

I agree, today's goof up portrays Naira to be the bigger culprit than she's actually been accused of. If she had taken Shubham to doctors & therapy sessions without Goenka's knowledge, I would without a doubt agree Naira is withholding critical info and sharing it with Swarna could've saved him. But "NO, we all know that Naira came to know just the day before Karthik's Birthday and Shubham himself begged her NOT to reveal & he himself would confess the next day. So there was no possibility, of Naira accompanying Shubham to therapy sessions multiple times. That's the most pathetic attempt to wrap up the Raita spread by CVs.
Even if Naira had not known about Shubham's drug addiction, she would've still been guilty. As the Bahu of the House, she's expected to know everything about everyone in the household and solve their problems hence maintaining the peace & happiness in GV. She failed big time as a Bahu, bhabhi & patni too. 😡 😡 No wonder she deserves to be slapped & thrown out of GV & Karthik's life. I still don't believe Swarna to be convinced, her like "ma ki khushi bache ki khushi mein doesn't imply she has forgiven. She might still play some tricks to keep them both apart. For that matter, it's Swarna who has to apologize to both Karthik & Naira for ruining their lives and making Naira's life miserable.

Edited by cooldreams - 7 years ago

Quote

abhilasha_dream

@abhilasha_dream

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh
That one day before kartik's birthday dragged on for ages... 🤣
Hence naira was able to take shubham multiple times to the hospital for treatment

they should have said that i remember her coming once with shubham and how stubborn shubham was or even that resort could have called with some thing the goenkas left and it could have been a tape of kartik's party where in naira is saying shel tell everyone and shubham begged her not to

today's episode along with naira's apology have been the biggest goofs in the entire track

+_+

Look naira can be mahaan but ma made alot of galtis
so ma should apologize +_+

I am sorry but just giving us the lame excuse her son died is not enough!
She destroyed her living son's life
+_+ she treated naira like a worm when she once called naira her own child
she treated keerti like dirt...
prayed numerous times for naira to be separated from kartik

As a die hard fan i feel cheated by the way this track is wrapping up😭
the only thing that keeps held on like glue is shivin and how meant for each other they are😆
other wise i would run away

I am not talking about what Suwarna did.

I am only talking about whether Suwarna was right or not in blaming Naira for Shubhams death and hiding stuffs from them. Was she right in being angry with her for these reasons ?

Coz after watching yesterday's episode it was clear that Naira had hidden it for long number of days and not just 1 day. She did not confide the details even with Karthik forget about family.

I remember what Akshara had said Naira once when right before Nairas performance on stage her dupatta tore and she hadn't got an extra dupatta with her. Akshara had then told her that if you think of the situation properly , you will be easily prepared and take cautious steps before hand itself.

This is what Naira lacks, understanding the gravity of a situation and the consequences related to it. CV's have tried defending Naira by illogical scenes and making the other character behave badly with her , otherwise Nairas way of handling things are wrong and very immature and one can cite many examples from the past tracks which has bought this trait of hers in light.

Edited by abhilasha_dream - 7 years ago

Quote

abhilasha_dream

@abhilasha_dream

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: ArtisiaR
CV Kaira's evidence of Naira's innocence is super faulty. Suwarna is not blaming Naira because she didn't help Shubham- She hates Naira bc Naira didn't share a serious issue abt her son- which according to the evidence video is still true.
Nothing is changed for Suwarna except Karthik no longer on her side

Exactly ! The whole anger is about Naira not sharing details about the issue due to which when the time came although everybody were present in the hospital but none were able to help and save Shubhams life. ---- .This is the crux of the hatred

And this is the very reason why even Karthik was angry with Naira that although he kept asking her, she did not trust him enough to share such a big news with him.

The disappointment was never about whether Naira helped Shubham or not, it was always about she not sharing details with the members which led to the fatal loss.

Quote

abhilasha_dream

@abhilasha_dream

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: Fireiswithinus
if u listen and see clearly the episode u will find that naira in first case didn't tell the familiy members because she came to know about it a day before...just a day n she was about to call when shubham begged he even tried to stop doing drugs...if u remember the twist in the bed in night
now in second case which was shown today...the doctor said if naira will tell the family shubham will stop the treatment hence coming harm to him...he almost emotionally blackmailed him in his mother's name
In both the cases naira was to be blamed . no matter what she did she would be thrown out ...think if she told everyone ,...the family that goenkas are would have said something n other to shubham which will cause emotional breakdown leading him to do drugs,...

in every aspect naira would be blamed...if u r seeing this serial u would know how swrna declared him dead many years ago for god's sake she was doing shrad...when at that time manish could forgive her...
why is that in the name of maa ka dard kartik couldn't do the same...
naira is not the mother here...swrna is...she was so blind... that she fought with naira on that girl which was a gold digger...naira has always supported her always ...not even once i have seen her going against swrna...
she is not guilty...but yes they have given her a scene where they r showing respect by begging in front of her...

and btw if u talk about hiding things swrna did it years back also that doesn't give her a right to separate a husband and wife... u do not have the right to say to ur son " tum jao apni naira ke pass "
And when she taunted her every chance she got... she shows that she is not caring for her living son but getting revenge on her dead son !!!1

I am very well aware of the scenes which they had shown that is why I did not blame Naira for hiding the stuff earlier . I was only angry with her for not sharing it with Karthik but today when the doctor said she had got him for numerous sessions with Shubham threatening her not to let the family know and she conceding to his demands was wrong.

She could have confided with Karthik atleast in the privacy of their bedroom. She should have allowed him to take the decision for his family members.

Karthik was unable to forgive Naira as she broke his trust of not hiding things from him. This was not a small issue which she hid , the consequences of it was fatal - a loss which can never be recovered. That shows the confidence which she has in her partner. The very crux of marriage - Trust - was shaken by Naira by hiding this issue.

As far as Suvarna hiding the truth is concerned, she was also wrong and her marriage also shook. Suwarna was thrown out of her own room. A husband and wifes relationship could have gone bitter forever but CV's showed Kaira intervening and the matter getting resolved quickly.

But by pointing out Suwarnas mistakes we cannot take away the mistake which Naira did. Goenkas obviously had complete right to get angry with Naira once they got to know the complete truth.

We can also see that except for Suvarna and Karthik no one else hold grudge against Naira or blame her for Shubham death anymore. They were angry with her then and that too rightfully so and then they became fine with her.

Quote

abhilasha_dream

@abhilasha_dream

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: rose2015
By changing the storyline from Naira knowing about Shubnam's drug habit on Karthik's birthday to now knowing for some time and taking him for treatment makes it look worse for her. That means she kept this secret not just for one day but a long time.

Writers theory is now Naira brought him for multiple appts with the doctor and there is even video tape of it. (who videotapes - no logic) Before it was she was holding off to tell Karthik the next day after his birthday celebration when Shubnam then dies.

I know nothing makes sense but we are talking about indian tv serials where anything goes.

CV's in order to justify Suvarna character, and bring out proofs to support Naira hiding the matter , has done a big goof up.

They have suddenly turned tables and made Naira completely wrong in the audience eye coz hiding such a big issue for a day is pardonable but for many days is wrong.

Cv's and their nonsense logic.

Quote

1 2

Wrong

Was Suwarna wrong in blaming Naira for Shubhams death ?

Related Topics

Explore Topics