Was zoya right or wrong - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.2k

Users

15

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

mans1234 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#21

U know that's what I mentioned in the above post of mine.. has Zoya has changed so much she does not think much about consequences..
But I feel court thing and this spreading was kinda different , I mean in terms of gravity ..
Yes the fact is that time papa hooda intentions was right but method was wrong .. here Zoya's intention was right but method wrong ..
Nice way to put it .. u expressed it well ..
But the question is can both scenarios be compared .. the seriousness n the consequences ..
Just trying to get your perspective.


@mans1234 ~ am not a lawyer but I do understand that even with a murder charge, there are different punishments. there is first degree murder, second degree murder, accidental murder, etc etc and the punishment varies depending on the severity of the crime.

while one could argue that it is not same as mr. hooda lying in court, technically one can also argue that as a defense lawyer, he was just doing his job building a defense with the information he had. so in that sense, wasn't he justified? so maybe her actions and mr. hooda's don't compare on the same scale, but it is still violation of our cyber laws. it is only a drama but still, our laws are there for a reason and should be respected no? frankly i liked the way papa hooda defended his case .. it was nice and intelligent .. that time i guess i felt Zoya overreacted a lil .. though i could understand her perspective but still i was with Harsh .. he was not left with any option so he did what he thought was apt then .. and today i feel Zoya was not left with any option to get aditya back .. though the reason why Aditya came back is still a question ..so got to c and wait
Yes i so agree in ITV laws are like a joke especially the police officer ..i honestly feel its unfair and making them look just plain stupid ..

like @tulips noted, her character has taken a u-turn after the leap and it seems to be intentional that she has lost her sweet idealistic nature. it is also a kind of darkness if she lets it go too far. obviously, she is the heroine and so it won't go further but if she was a grey character like mahi, it is one step closer to the staircase of being a villain...Yes agree her character has changed quite a bit .. i mean its a big turn .. she wont think twice before to do something which old Zoya would not have done .. frankly i dint expect such a huge change in her .. but somewhere she is still innocent .. Yes ofcourse , not like Mahi but yes we can expect that she is capable of crossing a line

also my personal view is coloured by what happened when I was in school. it was april fool's day and one of the ex-students decided it would be funny to spread a fake rumour. somehow the rumour spread that one of my classmates was in an accident on his way to school. now, he was in school when the rumours were going around in circles and finally, the rumour was that he had died!!!! there were so many panic phone calls from his family and friends all because of one stupid kid. while they didn't figure out who exactly did, no one in the school found it remotely funny, especially the student who had supposedly died in that accident. so from that perspective, zoya's actions were a bit too much. Hey this is bad and really sad .. I honestly feel bad for the family and the parents .. the stress , shock and trauma they went through is unimaginable .. i truly can understand ..

I understand what u mean ...

I guess we as individuals should have certain sense of responsibility .. our actions have consequences which can be painful and we need to be careful ..
So i get your point with respect to Zoya ...
though this is fictional drama but i get your point ..

Also however nice intention she had i understand why the actions cannot be justified .. i get it was extreme ..


I hope u Dint mind just wanted to get more insight from u so asked ..
Edited by mans1234 - 7 years ago
mango.falooda thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#22

@mans1234 -- I don't mind at all.. :) it is a drama and most of the time, I don't take any of it seriously since I just watch this for time pass but yea, I do wish that indian television won't make our justice system seem like such a joke.

and yea, I agree with you -- actually mr. hooda did a good job when he was arguing and they showed why he was a good lawyer. zoya's reaction seemed less about the truth and more about her feeling like she was a failed wife in some sense... I really do wish that the drama will show Zoya's action cannot be justified but I doubt it. poor Adi -- already the fella is traumatized by Sakshi's words -- imagine sitting on an 8 hour flight (or however long it is from Paris) not knowing what has happened to your family and feeling utterly miserable that you weren't there to prevent whatever has happened... just like he wasn't there for pooja either.. but I doubt they would show that.. and instead Adi will just forgive her magically... 🤔
mans1234 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: mango_pudding1


@mans1234 -- I don't mind at all.. :) it is a drama and most of the time, I don't take any of it seriously since I just watch this for time pass but yea, I do wish that indian television won't make our justice system seem like such a joke.

and yea, I agree with you -- actually mr. hooda did a good job when he was arguing and they showed why he was a good lawyer. zoya's reaction seemed less about the truth and more about her feeling like she was a failed wife in some sense... I really do wish that the drama will show Zoya's action cannot be justified but I doubt it. poor Adi -- already the fella is traumatized by Sakshi's words -- imagine sitting on an 8 hour flight (or however long it is from Paris) not knowing what has happened to your family and feeling utterly miserable that you weren't there to prevent whatever has happened... just like he wasn't there for pooja either.. but I doubt they would show that.. and instead Adi will just forgive her magically... 🤔


Thanks 😊 ..

No they wont focus on Zoya's action which was extreme and a wrong method was used.. it was just for drama 😆 .. In ITV most of the times justice system is taken as a joke , so frankly not to expect much ..😆

Now , lets c why what is the reason of Aditya coming back ...


malarmia thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#24
Zoya was definitely wrong and it's a crime she committed.
Not sure whether Adi will return after seeing the news or based on his own will.
Maybe today we will see him watch the news
Happy_hippy thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: mango_pudding1


@mans1234 -- I don't mind at all.. :) it is a drama and most of the time, I don't take any of it seriously since I just watch this for time pass but yea, I do wish that indian television won't make our justice system seem like such a joke.

and yea, I agree with you -- actually mr. hooda did a good job when he was arguing and they showed why he was a good lawyer. zoya's reaction seemed less about the truth and more about her feeling like she was a failed wife in some sense... I really do wish that the drama will show Zoya's action cannot be justified but I doubt it. poor Adi -- already the fella is traumatized by Sakshi's words -- imagine sitting on an 8 hour flight (or however long it is from Paris) not knowing what has happened to your family and feeling utterly miserable that you weren't there to prevent whatever has happened... just like he wasn't there for pooja either.. but I doubt they would show that.. and instead Adi will just forgive her magically... 🤔


But hasn't all this been taken rather too lightly on this show earlier too?? As in the fake marriage contract, adiya running away from police.. I think what writers are trying to show is that zoya has started to think like Aditya.. Which is actually not necessary!! But frankly this is Indian TV n most of the shows don't care about logic!! I feel even the substandard web series nowadays are much better than ITV... So just chill n enjoy
Posted: 7 years ago
#26
I'd admit a/c to cyber crimes nowadays & specifically with regard to the cyber laws activated in a country be it India or some other, the step Zoya took yesterday was wrong. She totally missed Adi for these 6 months a lot more than she would have even guessed, at the time he left for Paris I agree. I for once never felt she would be rejoicing whatever the memories they shared when she was listening to "Abhi na jao chodh kar", that night through the radio 😆 It was cute & yeah, her instincts were absolutely on point when she said to Arjun that Adi will definitely return if they spread a news of Hooda's being in danger.
But a crime is a crime. Her intentions as you say were exactly pure & harmless but she never thought it might cost even her job at a moment when she had won an entrepreneurs award for her company. All her employees were involved in this matter but I would give it up for her since she said, if something happens she would take the responsibility.
I'd conclude saying her intention was nice but the steps she took to initiate "Bring Aditya Hooda Back To India" were wrong 😊
Edited by SewwiVB - 7 years ago
mango.falooda thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Happy_hippy


But hasn't all this been taken rather too lightly on this show earlier too?? As in the fake marriage contract, adiya running away from police.. I think what writers are trying to show is that zoya has started to think like Aditya.. Which is actually not necessary!! But frankly this is Indian TV n most of the shows don't care about logic!! I feel even the substandard web series nowadays are much better than ITV... So just chill n enjoy



where would our dramas be without fake marriage contracts? hahahhaha... 😆 every drama has lapses in logic and some of them can be funny. every time, I see the servants in the hooda house dressed like they are in a hotel cracks me up -- not sure where servants dress like butlers. hahahaha... but the topic of the post was whether Zoya was right or wrong and so my answer is wrong. the means aren't justified especially if it is breaking a crime. do I expect the drama to address cyber crime seriously? nope! 😆.. but do I wish they would? sure.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#28
Guys sorry due to time constraints I can't reply to each one of you individually. I just want to reiterate I can do a complete analysis only after seeing today episode.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".