Is Yash really needed in the story?

IFLove thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Hello people, I am Anuja, new on this forum and looking forward to have discussions with u all.🤗 To introduce myself, this is the first show I m watching on Colours. I m not a tv addict, have only followed a few star plus shows like yhm, post-leap naamkaran and ishqbaaz for the unique storyline n characters they used to have initially...and of course because they were easily accessible to wach through hotstar, I m not a trp viewer. I haven't even watched Jenny or HC's previous works. Now I have started watching this show on voot since the plot looks intriguing.
And this being my first post on this forum, actually I shouldn't have started with this controversial topic😆 But let me put my thoughts.

I completely agree with u all that we have signed up for AdiYa's story, Yash scenes are at times irritating, Sehban can't act, Sehban gets more screenspace due to nepotism (Idk about this), Pooja should also get equal importance which doesn't happen n all. And I know ya'll are pissed with the reason given by the makers that he is required to push the story of AdiYa forward, but that's not happening either. But honestly, keep ur dislike for Yash and Sehban aside and think, is it is possible for a girl like Zoya who innocently and madly was in love with Yash to forget him within 2 weeks of his death? No it isn't. She isn't seeing Yash in Adi, she is seeing Yash himself. She is hallucinating him no matter if Adi is present or not. During the terrace scene, when she first saw Yash in the rain, Adi was nowhere around and she was in the same thoughts when Adi arrived. Yash was only her imagination who wasn't even moving from the same place in spite of her pleas but when Adi actually came to help her, she believed that her imagination in her sub-conscious was coming true. She thanked Yash himself for saving her, she didn't thank Adi. And most importantly, she was not in her senses...she doesn't even remember now that it was Adi. In the sangeet ceremony, yes she was impressed by Adi's gesture, but she got happy to see Bella and Ro happy, everybody around her dancing happily, the thought of successfully completing her second event made her happy and this happiness made her groove to the tune and obviously when she was happy and dancing, she imagined herself with her love, isn't that very natural? When the final 1 minute AdiYa dance and eye-lock happened, she saw Adi only n didn't see Yash in him. Come on, we too remember our very much alive loved ones when we see anything related to them even when we can actually see them whenever we want, may it be even something as petty as eggs n strawberries, we remember them when we have some special memory associated to it ...imagine what it must be for a girl who is widowed only after 5 years of her marriage. Isn't her love for him her only solace? Its this love only with which she is living her life. Give her some time, please.

I wouldn't comment on those who have signed up for HC-Jenny, but those who have signed up for AdiYa, let's remember we want AdiYa's story right now, not their love-story this soon. Yes, things are dramatic in the daily soaps, but it is very impractical of us to expect her to forget Yash this soon. This is not a web-series that things will unfold in a week. This is a daily soap which at least see a run of an year when they start and they can not rush with the story. The story looks appealing only if it is told gradually. Take any love-story, it has some past baggage of leads, and no matter what it is, initially its a hard nut to crack, later they slowly begin to open up, then they have formal relations, they gradually befriend, then they compare their current life with past life and feel the difference, they find a better version of themselves, they start admiring eachother for bringing out this better version of themselves, then they start liking eachother for the kind of person they are n then they fall in love. Isn't it the way it happens? Just because here we have a marriage and a husband in the name of past baggage, that can't be ignored by the makers just because we want to see the leads together. Idk how many of ya'll here have watched yhm, but their too a broken marriage was a past baggage, there too leads were even married but the focus of the male lead used to remember certain things about his ex-wife every now n then till he built a admiration for his new wife. This is an integral part of the story.
In Bepanah too, now they both are completely blinded by their first marriages, be it for love or hatred, they still have loyalty for their respective spouses and this is a part of their individual story and not their story together, so this is not expected to help to take their story forward. Gradually their hatred will reduce as they themselves are good human beings and they will see this goodness in eachother too. Then there will come a time when they'll start to compare the other person with their spouses n realise the difference. This doesn't mean that they'll fall for eachother because they are not like their ex'es. This will only be a stage which will bring them out of their past baggage which will help to take the story forward and after that they'll start to like eachother for the persons they are. If Zoya immediately starts liking Adi for the person he is just after her husband's demise, it will prove her love for Yash weak, which is not a case...no matter what kind of a person Yash was, her love for him was strong and pure which can not be challenged in a matter of few days. So, let us give the cvs this much time to tell their story. These complains will make sense only if they show her imagining Yash even after falling in love with Adi, this is too early to show this much of hatred for the involvement of a "Character" in a story (I don't mean the actor). Adi n Zoya are leads of a show and only we know this, so we expect them to be together always without any haddi in between, but that can't happen because they are not leads of any show but its their real life in the story. Just remember, once they develop liking for each other, we will miss these scenes of hatred among them which is there only because of Yash and Pooja. So let's enjoy what we have as of now and wait for a beautiful future!😊

I hope this helps u to put up with the ZoSh scenes better. I m neither favouring Sehban nor the cvs, I just tried to explain the need of Yash in the story. N having said this, I expect all this to happen with Adi-Pooja too.

Just my opinion, feel free to share urs.😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.1k

Users

9

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

THEfanOFheartz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
To be fair this show should have been a fortnite series or a web series. It would have been better to watch in my opinion.

This is unique in that sense they are showing how emotional cheating can affect an individual.

I don't mind Yash's flasbacks because he is in fact crucial to the story as you said however their should be more flasbacks on Pooja. Also I agree.

Many people forgot but this show isn't just about AdiYa love story its about how their partners end up together on the same night dead and them finding out the actual truth did they "cheat" according to Adi or did they "not" according to Zoya, whilst face'd against each other due to the Yash's business. After that how they find comfort in one another, how they become friends and how they fall in love.

Don't get me wrong but this how fans will ruin this story. Moaning about Yash this Yash that. I'm already kind on the verge of giving up with this show because its not giving me what I want. More relevations that get me off my seat. This is why this should have been a fornite series (or webseries)

Why do you think webseries In India, TV serials in Pakistan and Korean more successful? Because they are written and told without the pressure of TRPs.

Also why. This will end up as a disappointment if the TRPs aren't good. Or fan's constent moaning.

I agree on the point on about how they cannot get over their ex's easily.

It is what it is

Like for anyone in Zoya's situation when your missing someone you "love" and they pass away you miss them more. You halluncinate them and that's what Zoya is doing and that won't go any time soon.








Flame. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I am not sure about the others, but I do understand why Yash is so much in her thoughts. Hence, I didn't complain when she saw Yash in Aditya's place when he came to save her. She was hallucinating and it did seem natural to my eyes.
My only problem is the unnecessary scenes that are just so long, bland and add absolutely nothing to the story. It was pretty much established in the Mehndi flashback that their near and dear ones were not around for their wedding, which resulted in a lot of incomplete rituals. There was no need for another boring Haldi scene to drive the same point across. Plus, I was really annoyed at the fact that they omitted an important Yash - Ashish scene over the useless one like yesterday's. Add to that, the lack of Pooja scenes.

They either need to work on their Yash - Zoya scenes and make them entertaining, or give equal screen time to Pooja - Adi scenes as well. Heck, I'd like some Yash - Pooja scenes too.
PNalina thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Ya agree I feel they should try and tone down Yash and Zoyas scenes slowly and show more of Adiya...
Also Pooja & Adityas scenes should be shown less ...
THEfanOFheartz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Flame.

I am not sure about the others, but I do understand why Yash is so much in her thoughts. Hence, I didn't complain when she saw Yash in Aditya's place when he came to save her. She was hallucinating and it did seem natural to my eyes.

My only problem is the unnecessary scenes that are just so long, bland and add absolutely nothing to the story. It was pretty much established in the Mehndi flashback that their near and dear ones were not around for their wedding, which resulted in a lot of incomplete rituals. There was no need for another boring Haldi scene to drive the same point across. Plus, I was really annoyed at the fact that they omitted an important Yash - Ashish scene over the useless one like yesterday's. Add to that, the lack of Pooja scenes.

They either need to work on their Yash - Zoya scenes and make them entertaining, or give equal screen time to Pooja - Adi scenes as well. Heck, I'd like some Yash - Pooja scenes too.


I don't understand why they did exclude an important scene out between Yash and Ashish?

I don't think they need to work on the Yash and Zoya scenes they should just give an equal screen time to Pooja and Adi scenes and interactions between Yash and Pooja to find out more.
Edited by THEfanOFheartz - 7 years ago
Flame. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: THEfanOFheartz


I don't understand why they did exclude an important scene out between Yash and Ashish?

I don't think they need to work on the Yash and Zoya scenes they should just give an equal screen time to Pooja and Adi scenes and interactions between Yash and Pooja to find out more.


I thought they would show the Yash - Ashish scene in the coming episodes, but there's no sign of it anywhere.

Yesterday's Yash scene felt so long, that they could have easily fit in a Pooja scene in that time space. Instead of the lovey-dovey scenes, they can also focus on scenes that can give out hints about the future storyline.
THEfanOFheartz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Flame.


I thought they would show the Yash - Ashish scene in the coming episodes, but there's no sign of it anywhere.

Yesterday's Yash scene felt so long, that they could have easily fit in a Pooja scene in that time space. Instead of the lovey-dovey scenes, they can also focus on scenes that can give out hints about the future storyline.


Exactly and they are only doing this because of TRPs and the long lasting of the show. Which for me is a biggg put off.😆 Which is why to me in my opinion the writers should have done this a webseries or a fornite series. Some will disagree with me and that's cool but they will ruin the story telling like this. As seen getting rid of the important crucial scene.

Just to extend the suspenseee

Yeah I agree, with scenes like that they could fit it Pooja scenes with Adi.

And hints but eh isn't AdiYa a big hint for the future storyline?😆😉

suhaaana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
I just want a good interpretation of the show which will only come only if Pooja and adityA will be given equal screen space.

mystique_4008 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: THEfanOFheartz



<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Exactly and they are only doing this because of TRPs and the long lasting of the show. Which for me is a biggg put off.😆Which is why to me in my opinion the writers should have done this a webseries or a fornite series. Some will disagree with me and that's cool but they will ruin the story telling like this. As seen getting rid of the important crucial scene.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Just to extend the suspenseee</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Yeah I agree, with scenes like that they could fit it Pooja scenes with Adi.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">And hints but eh isn't AdiYa a big hint for the future storyline?😆😉</font>



Most Indian shows are only good in the initial 5-6 months after that story turns into something else and looses it charm that's why I have never watched any Indian show from start to finish I give up after a certain period of time
rs-shailu29 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Not bothered Yash keep coming .
obviously he will be part of zo forever .
Why we are irritated because he is given preference than Pooja .
Want her side too

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".