Avni's reasoning is unjustified now

Affinity thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

Avni's decisions were justified until her meeting with Neel.

Avni feels likes she's a bad omen. She lost two mothers in her life. Her father was snatched away from her due her grandmother and his own cowardice. She didn't get to meet her brother until it was too late to completely redeem him. Because of Vidyut's infatuation with her, Neel and his family were going to be in danger.

So in order to keep her only remaining family safe, she gave up herself. She gave up her love, her happiness, her personality and her identity to keep Neel safe. She legit has just become a shell of Avni. Previously Avni had changed herself to become Ananya, to exact revenge. But this time, she removed herself to become Neelanjana,To keep the father and the grandmother she never had safe. Even Shweta had began treating her like a daughter. But most importantly, a doting husband who would do anything for her, safe too. In her eyes, she would have been selfish if she stayed because that meant putting her perfect family in danger just for her benefit.

So her decision was justified, in her mind. I don't agree with her decision, since Neel is such a dreamboat and we saw the pain Neel has gone through but I understand where she's coming from. Plus the fact that Avni apparently kept blank calling the Khanna house, meant that she knew enough to know that her family was safe.

Now we've gotten the holi episode and the aftermath, I think her decision contradicts with the confession Neel made. That Neel puts his life in danger in order to just get a glimpse of her and it's those near-death experiences that make him feel alive. I understand that she was too overwhelmed when she met him to discuss that matter. Tell the drunken him not to endanger his life, otherwise she wont even appear in his dreams, or something along those lines.

Yet she hasn't been shown to worry about this fact at all. I know we'll see her seeing Neel actually be in a risky situation. But I personally believe that confession was heartbreaking, and it should have affected Avni. She should have struggled on what she should do next. She's just remained adamant on hiding from Neel. I know we've seen her feelings for Neel, we know she still loves him. We've seen her reasoning on why has to hide. Vidyut is only behind bars due to her death. Yet I wanted to see her concern for Neel's behavior. I want her to second guess her decision before confronting Neel and not just because of the heat of the moment. I want to see her struggle. Like we saw for less than half a minute when she first saw Neel again after the 10 years. I think Neel's struggle was much better visualised during the jail track, than Avni's struggle has been here. I know we see Avni talking to young Avni. But we need her to have a conversation with herself, expressing her weakness, before the young Avni appears and tells her that she has to keep going.

I know the hit and miss game is nearly over, and although the cinematography has been beyond beautiful, I wish we just saw more of Avni and her reasoning in depth, compared to wasting screenspace with Saesha's KK drama. I don't mind Saesha getting screenspace, but I don't think her dreaming about KK should be seen as much as it is, that it affects the multi-faceted-ness of the two lead characters.

Edited by Affinity - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

3.1k

Users

12

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

AvNeil123 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Very well said.
We should get to see Avni cross question herself. At that point her fake death was the only way out, but did dhe think of the aftermath?

Esp now after Neil confessed to what extent he goes to, just to get a glimpse of her - is she still protecting him?

VR could be charged for other crimes same as RP and be hanged to death. And honestly by now im sure VR has joined Chuhi and his mom!

Mishti/Saesha scenes need to be reduced, she eats half the episode herself!! 😡
Starlight2826 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
The writers are destroying Avnis character ...shes coming out as a cold spineless woman ...shes contradicting herself all the time. .she dreams about how .such she loves Neil...then tells suneri that their love burned out 10 years ago...then when she gets him when's he's high ...shr decides to have some stolen time with him so she can have those memories ...shes actually become selfish there. The writers seem to be doing a bad job with Avni now...shes coming out as someone who really doesn't deserve Neil...but Sunehri also told her to stop her Bagwas. .i.e. nonsense ..so everyone knows she's become foolish and crazy.. .maybe these writers want her this way...very sad.. She's the protagonist and they are destroying her character

Shaiksafia thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Beautifully put together everything echos my thoughts on avni I understood her reasoning before she met Neil but now I just can't find any justification for her cold behavior she only keeps telling she loves Neil but didn't even flinch at the thought of him putting his life in danger to get a glimpse of her and the pain in his eyes when he met her there is no scene where it's shown she remember anything Neil said to her that night , there was no reaction asking know Neil has become a bodyguard like really avni rather she is busy consoling that stupid girl and happily preparing for her birthday party 🤢 really leaving a bad taste in my mouth I have not been speaking much about avni the whole leap because than people will term us as negative and we are spreading negativity but last few episodes I just can't relate to this avni how much ever I try it's wrong cvs always takes shortcuts when it's comes to AvNeil emotions last time it was neil in jail track and now it's avni 😡 is it so hard to give one scene where she is thinking about the change her death has caused on Neil's life just one scene and everything will be fine people might not agree to her decision but at least they know she is thinking about Neil's current situation
Edited by Shaiksafia - 7 years ago
delhigirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
I completely agree. I cannot agree with her reasons anymore and she sounds unreasonable.
Few points
1) based on what Sunehri said today, it seems Avni and Sunehri don't clearly know what the situation with Vidyut is now. because sunehri said - Vidyut shayad ab tak jail men sadh chukka hoga
so they have not kept up as to what happened to Vidyut in last 10 years.

2) Avni is being very stubborn and unreasonable with the children safety. Today i do not blame Saesha being upset since it is not only their house but the children's life is also in jeopardy

3) I applaud sunehri for going to Neil for help. And he did it again thinking that Avni would want him to do just that

4) How is avni saving his life? The more he is seeing her the more life threatening stunts he will do and one of them will take his life or injure him badly. Because he is not caring about his life anymore.
Now he feels it is him coming to Kashid for these stunts is what made him feel her presence.

I am sorry but Avni is playing with several lives now and she will realize only when someone dies or gets badly hurt for her to stop being like this.

If she wanted to save Neil and his perfect life, then she should have lived alone and not taken on all these kids to take care of which she can't even fulfill properly.

Very disappointed with Avni at this stage. She is definitely losing my sympathy card.
I also feel that she will shock neil to the core with her behavior when he realizes that she is alive.
I am sure he will be livid.

Edited by delhigirl - 7 years ago
Kaina.Ain thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Completely Agree.
Is she the same Avni who didn't care to look at Neil's broken face... who is the cause of his pain.
How can she be smiling happily with those kids without looking at the tears in his eyes. She took away his happiness. Is she really Neil's Avni ...who once loved him immensely. ...who couldn't sleep seeing him in pain.
Does Neil Khanna deserves a life like a dead lifeless person without any soul...which left his body when she chose to walk out of his life.

She just concluded to Sunehri that their past memories are just enough to lead their respective lives. What the heck. 🤢
angelanisa22079 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
I dont completely agree -
I understand that she maybe should have rethought abot her decision of going back to him after seeing his pain and struggle.

BUT

She is still in that fear that Vidyut will come back if she goes back and she doesnt want Vidyut to then use that evidence against Prakash for Neela's murder as she knows Neil will not be able to save his dad and she knows the pain of losing parents. She also knows how far Vidyut can go just to get her.. she knows that he will harm Neil.


Secondly, she has lost so many people in her life.. Ayesha, Aladdin, Ashish, Aman (jail lol) , Neela = she knows that they have gone forever.. but with staying away from Neil - she knows he is somewhat alive and is somewhere atleast.. Though she has Sunehri and others along with kids.. she is not getting the love of any family member .. a mothers love.. a fathers love ..ALSO staying away from him knowing he is alive is even harder aswell! We cant ignore how she must feel even if the CVs arent showing it enough.

Neelas death had a huge effect on Avni, she was her strongest support system since Ayesha died. Everyone who had been close to her or helped her during her revenge had got harmed some way or other - whether it was death or close to death. She got all of Neil's family love but can that replace the love Neela gave her? No.

Since the start, Avni has always been hearing taunts and horrible comments about her birth,identity, her upbringing, her parents not being alive.., questioning her character.. her relationship with her best friend Ali, her husband sent her to jail for 6 months (tho he had a deal wih vidyut' but that did hurt her alot.

If she was heartless then she would have not taken Neil to Sukoon House, she would have just left him there drunk.



She left him with his family while she was alone with a kid.. she had no family by her side still. Only for Neil did she kill her own identity as Avni..she killed herself along with her fighting nature. She did her own naamkarann as Neilanjana - She is carrying Neils name with her always, being calm, not taking the law in her hands.


delhigirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: __pohu__

Completely Agree.

Is she the same Avni who didn't care to look at Neil's broken face... who is the cause of his pain.
How can she be smiling happily with those kids without looking at the tears in his eyes. She took away his happiness. Is she really Neil's Avni ...who once loved him immensely. ...who couldn't sleep seeing him in pain.
Does Neil Khanna deserves a life like a dead lifeless person without any soul...which left his body when she chose to walk out of his life.

She just concluded to Sunehri that their past memories are just enough to lead their respective lives. What the heck. 🤢


If she wants to live in his memories, its her choice.
why did she say its enough for both of us.
so she actually wants a life like this for him also.
But it is her choice. he did not make that choice.
she herself is happy with the kids and her friends and he is not happy with anyone.
this is the life that she wants him to lead.
and then she might ask Mitali to come into his life.
That will be so nice and magnaminous of her.

delhigirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Shaiksafia

Beautifully put together everything echos my thoughts on avni I understood her reasoning before she met Neil but now I just can't find any justification for her cold behavior she only keeps telling she loves Neil but didn't even flinch at the thought of him putting his life in danger to get a glimpse of her and the pain in his eyes when he met her there is no scene where it's shown she remember anything Neil said to her that night , there was no reaction asking know Neil has become a bodyguard like really avni rather she is busy consoling that stupid girl and happily preparing for her birthday party 🤢 really leaving a bad taste in my mouth I have not been speaking much about avni the whole leap because than people will term us as negative and we are spreading negativity but last few episodes I just can't relate to this avni how much ever I try it's wrong cvs always takes shortcuts when it's comes to AvNeil emotions last time it was neil in jail track and now it's avni 😡 is it so hard to give one scene where she is thinking about the change her death has caused on Neil's life just one scene and everything will be fine people might not agree to her decision but at least they know she is thinking about Neil's current situation


actually they showed a lot of Neil emotions during the jail track.
they just did not show the khannas
he in fact stayed infront of her in the jail taking her anger at face.
he actually beat himself a lot about what he did to her.
he kept saying that he will bring her back in his life and will ask for forgiveness.

but 10 years is far longer than 6 months to be punished with a life like that.

if avni was planning to hide from him permanently then she should have also left on the video message that she will want him to go ahead in his life.
Not just say that remember me with a smile.


MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Great post! I agree pre meeting Neil again, Avni felt justified in her decision to remove herself from Neil and her family so that they remain safe, and VR goes to jail. Yes he is in jail for killing her and yes if she comes out he may get out! Remember how hard it was to pin anything on VR?

But after seeing how Neil never moved on, how he still
loves her, probably even more than he did before, that he risks his life just to imagine her face, it should have made her struggle more with her choice! I just don't know what to think of Avni just closing her mind to all that!

She loves Neil. That's not in doubt! But how can she not think of all the Daard and Ansoo she gave him by leaving his life? What about that? It's not by being in his life she did that unlike what she said, it was by leaving his life! I hope they show us more of her struggle than showing us that annoying Sayesha!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".