Is It Right For SAMEER To Do So ????? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.5k

Users

11

Likes

62

Frequent Posters

Samaina_1990 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: ATH_KTM_543




That slap was something which brought genuine change in sameer...he started respecting her since then...

Now we will only get to know from when did sameer started loving naina only once he realises himself...we defenetely know he loves her but from when...that is to be answered...and I hope we will get that through his VO...



I just recalled...remember when Sameer told Naina he would meet her at the temple the next morning to wish her good luck for the debate...n after he keeps the phone down, he looks into the mirror n says...why did I say I would meet her at the temple? I've already wished her luck...then why to meet her...n he knew she will come to the temple for sure to get God's blessings...but then he convinced himself that he's doing it for the bet...that was one clear cut sign Sameer was already in love with Naina, even before she saved his Nanu's life...it was in the trip that he started realizing that it is not just friendship or bet...Naina means something special to him...he's just not ready to name it as love as yet. And the way he was bowled over by her on his birthday...that too when she was wearing a dress he didn't like at all!!
Dr.DonnyJohn thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: ATH_KTM_543





That slap was something which brought genuine change in sameer...he started respecting her since then...

Now we will only get to know from when did sameer started loving naina only once he realises himself...we defenetely know he loves her but from when...that is to be answered...and I hope we will get that through his VO...




The problem or the issue bugging many here is the assumption that Sameer is in love with Naina.

However, what we are all viewing in the show is just the guilty feel of Sameer. He wants to get rid of this guilt for hurting a decent girl.

As in the show character of Sameer has not shown any visible signs of underlying love wali feeling for Naina. Most of us are just hoping to see a clear cut sign of Sameer is indeed in love.

However, the entire aspect of this crucial portion is getting stretched which is creating doubts on all his apology efforts. We are inclined to think that Sameer is doing all without any base and again being selfish to seek apology for his mental peace. He is assuming that it will also make Naina relaxed. How ever it is not possible.

The only possible way for Sameer to make sense of all this is to understand that the only way ahead in this scenario with a girl like Naina who loves him to any possible extent is to fall in love with her.

This aspect is not being well presented till now.
Anjali33 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#13
Agreed
She doesn't want his sorry..it's hurting her even more
She loved him n he didn't love her back..he pretended..that's what hurt her
Dr.DonnyJohn thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14
The problem or the issue bugging many here is the assumption that Sameer is in love with Naina.

However, what we are all viewing in the show is just the guilty feeling of Sameer. He wants to get rid of this guilt for hurting a decent girl.

As in the show character of Sameer has not shown any visible signs of underlying love wali feeling for Naina. Most of us are just hoping to see a clear-cut sign of Sameer is indeed in love.

However, the entire aspect of this crucial portion is getting stretched which is creating doubts on all his apology efforts. We are inclined to think that Sameer is doing all without any base and again being selfish to seek apology for his mental peace. He is assuming that it will also make Naina relaxed. However, it is not possible.

The only possible way for Sameer to make sense of all this is to understand that the only way ahead in this scenario with a girl like Naina who loves him to any possible extent is to fall in love with her.

This aspect is not being well presented till now.
ATH_KTM_543 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Anjali33

Agreed

She doesn't want his sorry..it's hurting her even more
She loved him n he didn't love her back..he pretended..that's what hurt her




Sameer is not knowing the same thing...


She is defenetely hurt by bet... but it's not only the bet of which she is hurt the most...she is hurt by the fact that he didn't love her instead was faking love...that too when she loved him soo deeply...it hurts a lot when the person whom we love the most don't love us in the same way...


she can forgive him for bet but her feelings...it can be forgiven by only his true love...that's the reason it was necessary for sameer to fall in love before bet revelation...naina may accept him when she knows he started liking her much before ... but she cannot accept that love which came out of guilt...so that's why here too sameer does love her only realisation is left out...


ATH_KTM_543 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Dr.Don

The problem or the issue bugging many here is the assumption that Sameer is in love with Naina.

However, what we are all viewing in the show is just the guilty feeling of Sameer. He wants to get rid of this guilt for hurting a decent girl.

As in the show character of Sameer has not shown any visible signs of underlying love wali feeling for Naina. Most of us are just hoping to see a clear-cut sign of Sameer is indeed in love.

However, the entire aspect of this crucial portion is getting stretched which is creating doubts on all his apology efforts. We are inclined to think that Sameer is doing all without any base and again being selfish to seek apology for his mental peace. He is assuming that it will also make Naina relaxed. However, it is not possible.

The only possible way for Sameer to make sense of all this is to understand that the only way ahead in this scenario with a girl like Naina who loves him to any possible extent is to fall in love with her.

This aspect is not being well presented till now.





I don't believe so... I am 1000 percent sure that the feelings sameer has for naina is pure love only... he defenetely loves her...there's no argument over that...

But my problem is not that...sameer assumes that all his feelings are for friend...and he is going to apologise to naina as a friend which is not done in this situation...i have only one question how can sameer even think of asking sorry and be friends with naina again when he knows how much she loves him...so this sorry doesn't make sense until sameer realises that he just not want her as his friend but also as his special friend...


I am sure it will be through naina only sameer will know... if he needs to heal her wounds... nothing but his true love would do that...for that he shoukd understand himself...why he actually feels for her...also I am sure this will take little long time too...



samiksha1 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#17
Completely agree with u 😛
SixteenAgain thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#18
I think the fact that Sameer's VO has still not mentioned the L word in connection with Naina is causing the disconnect..

Watching Sameer on the trip with Naina and the way he was looking at her and following her around gave us all the impression that it's finally happening for him too. And if that is the case Sameer's VO should be sharing an inkling of that.. all he has said so far is something changed without any real indication of Sameer feeling any love for Naina. The 17 year Sameer might not have understood at that moment., but the adult Sameer should know.

The VO is not sharing anything very different to what we are already seeing based on Sameer's conversations with friends or his monologues. I suppose it's part of the CVs strategy to not give away anything at this point.. but then what value is Sameer's VO adding to the show?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".