Major editing and screenplay flaws..

KashafZaroon30 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Unfortunately I m not able to keep up with some amazing posts since past few days, busy schedule makes it difficult to watch the show even once. But must say all of us were eagerly waiting for the break-up part(though it is sad) and finally it is here. And all of you are discussing great things on the forum.

But why are makers not taking this part seriously? Why are there so many flaws suddenly happening in the show. From forced scenes, to flawed editing and even not-so-great screenplay. The makers gave us some amazingly dreamy episodes till last Wednesday, but after that I felt as if they have shot some scenes beforehand and now the editor is arranging them like a jigsaw.

I feel the sweater scene should have happened before Safari suit's entry in Mt Abu, that scene required some more depth and better dialogues by Naina when she gifted it to Sameer. But it turned out to be rather plain and oddly placed after the whole drama by Safari suit

And in today's episode, in one Sameer has a camera in his pocket, and within the next shot it's gone, and then again back. Owing to this, Sameer avoiding Naina scene was clumsily written and though they wanted to show that Naina understood that he was not able to explain some confusion of his mind, it somehow I felt didn't come out to be that convincing.

And Swati should now stop with the Timepass wala pyaar thing. Sameer got some really bad beatings from Safari suit for Naina, now what else will convince you?
And Swati-Munna need some new dialogues, Shakal Dekhi hai and Mahaul badal raha is way too many times spoken.

And now the fillers, okay understand they are for extending the break-up part for a week, but place it in such a way that it helps the story somehow, if not Naina-Sameer's then at least other characters. Dhumrapaan se kark rog was lol today.

One thing is for sure, the makers of this show have the potential to show us something amazing, and they have done it aptly since so many months, but suddenly these flaws hope get rectified soon. I don't expect them to show us every time perfect things, but as a viewer my expectations have always risen from the first episode because of its amazing concept and execution.

Anyway enjoy.

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.8k

Users

13

Likes

138

Frequent Posters

dixie123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
The sweater scene was a major letdown. We discussed it at length last week when it was aired.
Naina didn't say one word to him about all the slap fest. More than the slaps, Princi gave Sameer a warning and he might get removed from the school and she had nothing to say about that. She didn't even think about it.

Swati needs better dialogues. Munna doesn't deserve her 'Shakal dekhi hai' dialogue. It was fine earlier but after taking the teddy from him, it is not right. I wish they had a moment too in Nakki lake. Swati and Munna in one boat.

I didn't feel today's was filler. Added more to the wait for tomorrow's breakdown. I hope it comes out good.
n_1234 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Agreed... quite some errors are being noticed now and then...this should improve from the makers...the editing should be slick...it needs improvement here
From the insta stories it looks like the original director jai Sengh has or is coming back to direct the Show again hopefully it will improve then...not that the current director jasbir Bhati is doing a bad job...I loved the current episodes as well except for the errors in editing and continuity flow.


Infofan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
It does seem like something is a bit off for the past couple episodes for sure. Didnt it occur to Swati Sameer said he pulled the chudail prank before she ranted about him and in that case maybe there is more to his explanation of being in their bathroom?😕

The gifting of the sweater was not handled as well is my opinion too.
PrincessAshVik thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
I have been (mostly) a silent member on the forum, but wanted to give my thoughts on today's episode and this topic seemed apt:)
I am so so disappointed by today's episode. I wasn't expecting this at all. A major let down for me. More than half the episode I was confused at what was happening and wondered if the site I was watching at had the full episode or not because nothing was making sense...Serious discontinuity in the episode today...

2 points that I feel were not handled well were:
-The sweater. This should have happened long before. She knitted it for Mt.Abu and the cold, then why give it to him 1 day before they leave? Made no sense whatsoever.

- The jungle scene. I feel that they should have shown a conflict in Sameer when he comes to know Naina is missing/ lost in the jungle. Sameer actually went in to the jungle for Munna and Pandit. I feel showing a small conflict would have shown a continuity in his guilt and his growing feelings towards her, which had started in Ahmedabad... But zero conflict in the jungle scene and a conflict once they got to Mt.Abu seemed disjointed...

The show has been really good otherwise, so I hope today's episode was a one-off thing... Because the above 2 points can even be ignored but discontinuity cannot...

Good post TM:):)
Fatima_Q thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
I've only recently caught up on all the episodes of this wonderful show.


I actually have a problem with the scenes leading up to the sweater scene, including the fact that it should have been given to Sameer earlier. I also still can't get over the fact that Naina made such a huge mistake and let Sameer into her room. I mean give the guy a blanket and the sweater and whatever else he needs and let him sleep in the hotel lounge or something...but no...she insists on him sleeping in her room. Ordinarily this wouldn't be a big deal but Ye Un Dino Ki Baat Hai 😆

Then the entire father showing up drama ensues...after which she shows up randomly with the sweater. If I was Sameer I would have been like girl are you crazy?! Your dad is here...you shouldn't be sharing the same breathing space as me let alone giving me a sweater.

I don't know...I just feel there should have been more of a build up to it from one situation to the next...but perhaps that's just me. Let's see what happens in the upcoming episodes.
SammP thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
As for me, I believe CVs actually forget about sweater and then later they realized that they need to add such an important link. If you see the spoiler you'll realize that sweater episode was shot almost towards the end. They forget story and thought of taking advantage of technolog but forgot that it' human who created this technoloy and can find mistakes easily😳
Samaina_1990 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Agree to all the points here...sweater was knitted for the cold, it should have been given asap...at least the night Sameer had fallen ill...he has no warm clothes, he took the medicine from u, what more confirmation u need that he would wear the sweater...n yes, after all the beating by Safari suit, Swati can't just assume Sameer is doing timepass...Sameer's confession of the bhoot prank...even I was surprised why didn't it ring a bell with Swati...yesterday's episode was a let down for me too...Arjun n shefali scene was completely out of place yesterday...Sameer ignoring Naina did not seem convincing...n Naina has the guts to talk to Sameer while planting trees...an hour or two back, her dad almost killed him...n yes Sameer might get thrown out of school is on no one's mind...why God ..it's a big deal for them...n Naina doesn't say it once? N I agree 100 percent with Swati n Munna scene portrayal n dialogues...they need to give that a thought too.
Coming to the positives, despite the discontinuities, I liked how Sameer desperately wants to tell her the truth, but is not able to do it...somewhere deep inside, he's scared he would lose her. N Sameer getting protective of Naina n thrashing the bet boys felt good...n the scene with his mom...let's hope today's episode makes up for all the flaws!!!😊
Edited by Samaina_1990 - 7 years ago
hanishank thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
agree with all the posts in this thread..
the epi looks bits and pieces to me...
rakesh ji drama and everyone behaving normally ...where the hell munna pandit gona when sameer was planting ...

list goes onnn 😭😕

only 1 dialogue i liked in yest epi ...sameer:ye meri jang hai ...akele ladke wapas avunga 😊
canapoem thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Yes scenes felt disjointed.
Sameer was determined to confess to Naina.
Suddenly he was angry and agitated. Maybe he was confused but they did not show it well.

I am tired of Swati and her pyaar evaluation strategies.
Cut it out Swati. Give the poor couple a break.

And then suddenly the fight with the bet boys.
Over that the parents witnessing it.

Everything just happened and I was confused as a viewer.

I just hope it's one of an episode like this .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".