Sameer a loser or hero of tragedy?

Please vote.
I've added my views regarding the whole incident happened during the head boy selection. If I've missed anything please don't hesitate to add.

Why Sameer fought for the head boy

One day when Sameer went to field to play cricket with his friends. Rakesh came with Arjun and told Sameer that this is not for losers like him. Arjun will play here because he is running for the headboy post. Sameer is not an old student of this school, he was a student from a boarding school. So I guess he didn't know about Rakesh sir much. But Rakesh sir had many other problems regarding Sameer's Aamir family which lead him to believe that it is Sameer for whom he lost his cabin, it was Sameer who stole his parking space etc.

Back at home one day Sameer saw a bike. He thought Nanu bought it for him. Actually that was for Rohan. I guess either that was a plan made by his step father to create a war between the brothers, or war between mother and son or to hatch some money from Dear sasurjee. Although at the beginning I didn't understood why? There was no need for his mom to buy that bike from here with the money of Nanu , she could buy that from where she lives or can get a delivery too. But I guess this was preplanned. Sameer's mom is not a very intelligent woman. I guess her brain was like Pooja di when she was young. So she didn't understood the political demag of her new husband. So she fell in trap.

Nanu who loves Sameer a lot, tried to cover the whole thing and to keep the peace he ordered the same bike for Sameer. But before anything Sameer learned about the truth. His mom challenged him, told Rohan got that bike because he is a winner. So Sameer told he will be the head boy.

How Sameer lost the cricket match

When Bishaka lost his hope for Sameer. Nanu reminded her that Sameer was great in cricket and he used to win every match when Bishaka was there for him. So Bishaka promised Sameer that she will stay with him in this match too. Step dad came in just at the moment mom and son were about to unite and taunt him and made him mad. Bishaka didn't understood her husband's intention so she thought it was Sameer who has problem. Which made Sameer more mad.

In the field Sameer win the toss. But he decided to field. Because his mom was not there yet. He wanted to show her his winning runs. He started to play and they came in. Sameer got major hurt and he had to take medical help. Everyone was wondering can Sameer play with that pain or not? Sameer's step dad kept calling him a loser and told Bishaka he knew Sameer can't.

But with that wound this boy went to the field to make his mom proud. He was playing well and was about to win. He even ran between the wickets desperately so that he can fulfill his mom's dream. At that time step dad got a call from Rohan that he is hurt. I think that was a lie too. He ordered Bishaka to leave the field immediately and she stood. Sameer was at the last ball and he was about to win...he saw his mom leaving the field. He kept seeing and remembering what his mom promised to him,...I will see your winning run. But alas! While Sameer was staring at his mom's back...the ball hit the stand and he lost the game.

By the way Naina was not there. She thought if she doesn't watch Sameer's batting Sameer will win . She was praying in classroom for his victory and alone. I guess she has no idea of these or how and why Sameer lost. Later after the game, step dad told ...Rohan is alright. So this proves the guy intentionally sabotage Sameer's reputation in front of his mom.

How Sameer lost in study

He is not a good student. A boy who lives in boarding school all through his life( according to episodes we saw and read )...usually can't become good student unless very brilliant. Sameer is not a brilliant student. He doesn't understand his studies well. He doesn't have a father like Rakesh at home or a brother like Arjun who will help him in his studies. His friends are two stupids- Munna and Pundit. Who are worse than him in studies. His mom or nanu no one felt the need of a private tutor still now! Although they too don't give time for him.

So he went to Naina. Naina is a very kind girl, with that she is in love with Sameer. Although her father's greatest enemy ( According to Rakesh) is Sameer. But still she likes the sweet nature of Sameer. When everyone sees only mistakes in him or beauty in him...she sees the sweet qualities in him. When a girl loves a boy this is what she sees. So she went against papa and started to teach Sameer secretly. Sameer used to give her chocolates in return of this study...so that was not free. Although Naina never taught him for chocolate. Naina was a good teacher and she used to explain everything so easily that Sameer started to improve. He was growing respect for her, that she is not only the behenji or bimbo or tel chipku girl. She is a very intelligent girl. Study could go on this way and soon they would fall in love . But villain was at the door step. Papa Rakesh. One day he caught Naina. He asked Naina and forced Naina to tell Sameer that she will not help him in his study and it was a mistake etc...Sameer has no idea about the condition of Naina in her Papa's life, or in the family. He thought Naina a dhokebaaj. As in his family life doesn't go like daal-chawal. It goes like "Kurukshetra/Mahabharat...Shakuni mama and etc. No wonder he found Naina something like Surpnakha. Betrayer, khamoandi, papa ke chamchi, another small version of Rakesh who hates him( Sameer) etc. He went to exam. Naina who still has feeling for him sacrificed her good luck charm for the boy she loves. Sameer most probably has no idea about the sacrificed good luck charm-----Naina's pen.

Sameer answered 100% but got 50%. His mom was not disappointed with his result. He used to get 25% before Naina helped him, so she gave him a gift. But step dad was not satisfied.

How he was caught

Just before the exam Pundit and Munna decided to help Sameer and they stole key from Naina's house . But Sameer refused to steal question paper because his nanu told him "honesty is the best policy. But unfortunately he forgot to throw that key. While he was talking with his friends after everything was over, his step dad heard it. He called the school and complained secretly.

While Naina fell on mud, Sameer helped her to wipe the mud by giving his rumal. When Naina took that rumal she found the key in the mud. Next she told what happened in the Principle's room. Rakesh kept slapping Sameer on his face in front of his step dad and mom, while other teachers and Principle was present. None of them stopped him or slapped Sameer. Sameer at last grabbed Rakesh's hand------which I think was insulting for Rakesh and Sameer was wrong. But if Principle or other teachers wouldn't involve Rakesh in this matter this wouldn't happen. Pundit and Munna confessed their crime but Rakesh ignored that. Because his anger is not because of the stealing...because Sameer is a rich boy. If that was Munna or Pundit I guess he wouldn't outburst like this. May be he too has some kind of personal issue from his past.

Sameer's step dad forced his mom to leave Sameer alone in that room. Rakesh wanted a TC for Sameer. It was Nanu who came and saved Sameer saying...You found the key...but are you sure he stole the papers? When Rakesh misbehaved with nanu ( rich guy, trustee ka nawaja etc) he just asked...is Sameer a criminal who deserves to stay in prison or a student who should get studentwala punishment?

How he got separated from his mom

They came home. Sameer's mom started to yell. Sameer blamed his step dad, mom thought he is is doing all these because he doesn't like his step dad. As to her new hubby is more like "Father India "Greatest Dad etc and who is doing all these because he cares for Sameer. Sameer who knew exactly what that man is denied and her mom burst in anger...Why can't you let me be happy? I will leave you. Sameer told, "The only thing you know is leave. So please leave. Sameer's mom was shocked. She is kind of very immature woman to be a mother. I guess doesn't have practical knowledge and absolutely has no idea how to raise kids. Most probably Sameer got his sudden anger, emotions etc from his mom. She was shocked. Step dad came and pulled her away from Sameer. She kept looking at Sameer, she thought he will fight, he will hold the other hand of mom and tell, "no mom, I don't want you to leave. May be this is how she was separated from Sameer's biological father. My guess, so don't know. The scene was emotional and pathetic.

Next on Sameer's birthday Nanu called her and she refused ( like a school girl) to wish Sameer.

your description is too good jhalak

Well he will loose Naina when she comes to know of the bet...but what will happen if Sameer gets to know that Arjun had taken his dad's key to check on the question paper?? Either ways both will loose ...what I want to see is who will give in...in a relationship one has to give in...who will be it...Naina or Sameer??

Superb post ..u perfectly described everything... even i hv same question... Rohan is in delhi so what the need to buy a bike for him in Ahamdabad??? who ws behind this Sameer's Step dad or his mom herself ?? Do u really think its abt money?? No i don't think so Sameer's step dad is also very successful bussinessman...Sameer India k best boarding m pad raha tha ..who ws not less then oxford...jabki uska addmission impossible ( acc to his mom) 🤔 May be i m wrng but his step dad wants to separate him frm his mom ..phir chachye Sameer k upper kitna bhi paise kyu na karach karne pade.🤔 just a guess

Originally posted by: --Royal--

Superb post ..u perfectly described everything... even i hv same question... Rohan is in delhi so what the need to buy a bike for him in Ahamdabad??? who ws behind this Sameer's Step dad or his mom herself ?? Do u really think its abt money?? No i don't think so Sameer's step dad is also very successful bussinessman...Sameer India k best boarding m pad raha tha ..who ws not less then oxford...jabki uska addmission impossible ( acc to his mom) 🤔 May be i m wrng but his step dad wants to separate him frm his mom ..phir chachye Sameer k upper kitna bhi paise kyu na karach karne pade.🤔 just a guess

And One thing which i noticed ... Sameer 's mom always accepcting Thanks or sry whatevr she did fr sameer.🤢

First -

When she made partha for him...she said -aadha ghanta laga is banane main( as a mother aadha kya 2ghante bhi lagte to what a big deal u did this for her son na) Maa k hath ka partha kha lia,nanaji k ghar rah laye ..ab bas study time.. say sry and go back to your boarding.

Secnd-

When she cleaned sameer's room for his TC.

Vishakha- i cleaned your room now say thanks to me for this.🤢

You r his mom or what?? Room apane bete ka clean kia na..so kya thanks ???

Now he will eat Naina's cake and understand the differences. 😆 Which will make Naina and Sameer more closer. 😳