My Theory...

Page

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 8 years ago

After watching today's episode, I have a hunch which can be true or not!

What we know:

Sharanya has been in coma for the past 2 years after an accident in which she and Vyom were involved.

Sharanya and her dad were involved in an accident prior to that, where I think Sharanya said she was 18?(not good with Hindi numbers), the accident knocked down a guy on a cycle which probably is Shiv!

I think Sharanya and Shiv's first meeting was that accident, I don't think Shiv died, that is how they met each other and that is what Shiv is trying to remind her. If she was 18 then, probably just before she started college and met Vyom! So the possibility of her being in a relationship with Shiv just before she met Vyom is a possibility.

Sharanya has been in coma for the last 2 years, and she has forgotten the past 5 years, so that could mean 3 years of college plus the 2 years in coma, there is a significant reason why she has forgotten 5 years. Shiv could have died anytime in those 5 years. But Shiv does have a grievance against Sharanya, he feels wronged, it could be that Sharanya started a relationship with Vyom soon after Shiv's death and Vyom's dad and Vyom were involved in his death or that Sharanya dumped Shiv for Vyom!

All this just a theory😆

Quote

Frequent Posters

rose1000

@rose1000

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

I am copying what I wrote in another thread...

I thnk the key to the mystery is Madhavi. Today she said...to Rajan Bedi...that when you tell a lie many times, it becomes the truth...something on those lines...Rajan Bedi's fist was shown...he was angry but controlled...so may be Rajan Bedi is a liar...

In the FB of Vyom, when Sharanya was asking him no to drink...in that scene...I felt like Vyom was in love with her...but Sharanya seemed just like a concerned friend...her expressions were more of "surprise"...I did not see any love in Sharanya's eyes...

Just my POV...

Madhavi's lines are important...

Also seems like Sharu was learning to drive, hit Shiv on bike, Sharu's dad got hurt too...and then Sharu was tryiing to make sure if Shiv is ok when the other car came at her...and yes Shiv had stargazer in his hand...

And I too think That is Shiv and Sharanya's first meeting and then they had fallen in love...As I said...I did not see love in Sharanya's eyes for Vyom. May be it was one sided love for Vyom. And so Rajan Bedi killed Shiv...because Madhavi said that he forces relationship on others...something on those lines...

But Shiv may have misunderstood Sharanya due to something and has grudge against her. But I don't think Shiv wants to kill her. He just wants to make her aware about the Bedis...

When Sharanya was in coma, it was Shiv who used to hold her hand...he could have killed her..but he did not...

And you are right about that 5 years...it must have some significance...and Madhavi's words also have significance...also, if Vyom was singer...then why in promos only Shiv had guitar...but not Vyom???? Something is not fitting in...its like a jig saw puzzle with many pieces missing...

Edited by rose1000 - 8 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

beagleboy

@beagleboy

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

cutting and pasting from another thread -

I think too, that they met for the first time at the time of the first accident. It seems to me that their fates intertwined at that point. I also think that the CVs have been very careful in showing Vyom in love in the flashbacks but not Sharanya. So like you say, they possibly did share a relationship, but one of friendship and not lovers. And there is nothing that says you cannot love your friend. But there is a difference between loving someone and being in love with someone. So perhaps Sharanya loved Vyom but was in love with Shiv, and hence shared a romantic relationship with him.

The difference between a friend and a lover, someting that possibly had Vyom confused, is that you lover can be your lover and friend but a friend can be just a friend. There are clear boundaries that one cannot cross. Whereas with a lover, these boundaries merge and become one. I would hope that Shiv was both her lover and friend because when the time comes, it would be easier for him to understand her.

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: rose1000
I am copying what I wrote in another thread...
I thnk the key to the mystery is Madhavi. Today she said...to Rajan Bedi...that when you tell a lie many times, it becomes the truth...something on those lines...Rajan Bedi's fist was shown...he was angry but controlled...so may be Rajan Bedi is a liar...
In the FB of Vyom, when Sharanya was asking him no to drink...in that scene...I felt like Vyom was in love with her...but Sharanya seemed just like a concerned friend...her expressions were more of "surprise"...I did not see any love in Sharanya's eyes...

Just my POV...

Madhavi's lines are important...

Also seems like Sharu was learning to drive, hit Shiv on bike, Sharu's dad got hurt too...and then Sharu was tryiing to make sure if Shiv is ok when the other car came at her...and yes Shiv had stargazer in his hand...

And I too think That is Shiv and Sharanya's first meeting and then they had fallen in love...As I said...I did not see love in Sharanya's eyes for Vyom. May be it was one sided love for Vyom. And so Rajan Bedi killed Shiv...because Madhavi said that he forces relationship on others...something on those lines...

But Shiv may have misunderstood Sharanya due to something and has grudge against her. But I don't think Shiv wants to kill her. He just wants to make her aware about the Bedis...

When Sharanya was in coma, it was Shiv who used to hold her hand...he could have killed her..but he did not...

And you are right about that 5 years...it must have some significance...and Madhavi's words also have significance...also, if Vyom was singer...then why in promos only Shiv had guitar...but not Vyom???? Something is not fitting in...its like a jig saw puzzle with many pieces missing...

I agree, that Sharanya in all the flashbacks , shows no indication of being in love, the only reason Im trying to extrapolate is because Sharanya I think is supposed to be grey. Shiv definitely doesn't want to kill her but he is also not exactly being a loving boyfriend who died. He is scaring the beejus out of her!

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: beagleboy
cutting and pasting from another thread -
I think too, that they met for the first time at the time of the first accident. It seems to me that their fates intertwined at that point. I also think that the CVs have been very careful in showing Vyom in love in the flashbacks but not Sharanya. So like you say, they possibly did share a relationship, but one of friendship and not lovers. And there is nothing that says you cannot love your friend. But there is a difference between loving someone and being in love with someone. So perhaps Sharanya loved Vyom but was in love with Shiv, and hence shared a romantic relationship with him.

The difference between a friend and a lover, someting that possibly had Vyom confused, is that you lover can be your lover and friend but a friend can be just a friend. There are clear boundaries that one cannot cross. Whereas with a lover, these boundaries merge and become one. I would hope that Shiv was both her lover and friend because when the time comes, it would be easier for him to understand her.

True that, and a lot of people misinterpret this in real life too, there is a clear body language difference between how you act with a male friend and even someone you are interested in, even if you are not romantically involved yet.

Been meaning to tell you have been really enjoying your poetic take on the show and the ghost😆

Edited by Cat. - 8 years ago

Quote

clarity

@clarity

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

Damn, great minds think alike. 😆😉

BTW, I remember you from the Begusarai forum. Remember me?

On board with this theory and this is what's gonna happen. Unless the CVs have a desire to change the storyline for whatever reason.

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: clarity
Damn, great minds think alike. 😆😉

BTW, I remember you from the Begusarai forum. Remember me?

On board with this theory and this is what's gonna happen. Unless the CVs have a desire to change the storyline for whatever reason.

Of course I remember you😆

Quote

clarity

@clarity

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Cat.

Of course I remember you😆

Yay.

What shows are you watching currently?

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: clarity

Yay.

What shows are you watching currently?

Just started Haasil and pleasantly surprised so far!

Quote

shreya

@.Lilith.

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#10

Yo Yo Catty!

FYI, she gladly announced that she was 21 back in 2013, when the accident occured. This means, that she was at an age of either having completed or soon going to complete her Bachelors degree, at least.

What's interesting is that she doesn't remember anything after the accident once she woke up from coma, and VyAranya were supposed to be a thing during their college. So I'm trying to formulate a conclusion here...

Did she meet Vyom or Shiv or both while pursuing her Masters? I just finished watching last night's episode- Sharanya saw her FB posts which were full of mushy updates about her love life with Vyom *duh*. So I'm thoroughly confused here.

I'm still not ruling out the possibility of Vyom hiding something. The way he said "Koi nahin tha wahaan pe", his face gave away a sense of nervousness at her trying to remember the accident- he doesn't WANT her to remember Shiv, just like Rajan. And it is only possible because he's scared she'll remember probably NOT loving Vyom?

Also, Rajan is a very interesting character. As I've said before, Prateek is still hungover with the "Maya Mehrotra Magic", so he's putting a little bit of her in almost every male character in this show. 😆

Keeping his wife to himself is his zid, trying to keep Sharanya with Vyom is his zid- aakhir chaahta kya hain yeh aadmi? 🤔

Quote

My Theory...

Related Topics

Explore Topics