Then what would have Neil done?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

srinithi

@AgnesFan

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#11

One simple question is what to expect from a girl rescued from the brothel ? And why to lie to protect her self-respect . Doesn't it sound foolish . The mere fact she was in brothel for all these years doesn't explain how she has a child . What is more humiliating than living in the place . Without a word people can understand about the child . Him lying to Avni in just not acceptable . He knew she would help even if it's his child which she is indeed doing then why to lie . I really couldn't get the point . This indeed shows he had never moved on from past ! doesn't ?

Edited by AgnesFan - 8 years ago

Quote

TSharan

@TSharan

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#12

I have not seen the OLVs for my own sanity but I do not want Neil lying to Avni at all! Audience knows she is someone who will support him unconditionally so Neil lying to her is unacceptable. I seriously hope that's not true and we have a missing piece here. Neil lying to Avni goes really against his character becoz he has always been open to Avni.

As it is there is so much negativity against Juhi's character and if audience see Neil lying to Avni, it will generate more anger! If CVs want audience to tolerate Juhi without backlash, they need to show Avneil working together in this mission without anyone lying to one another.

Showing the romance carrot is certainly not enough!! There are many of us who love Avneil for the kind of relationship they share, for the honesty in their relationship, for the sensible guy Neil has been show to be (unlike other MLs) and not for the off/on romance.

A girl who has lived in a brothel for 5 years must have been through a lot of physical/mental abuse. No one expects otherwise. As a truly nayi soch show, NK needs to show how Juhi and her child get acceptance in the society. Only then this track makes sense

Edited by TSharan - 8 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sps0114

@sps0114

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#13

Could it be he lied coz Juhi did not want him telling anyone that she was raped hence he just calls the kid his

Wasn't there an olv saying Shweta knew about the child fro the past...some connection of Shweta n Juhi this seemed wearied coz why was Shweta doing Juhi shradh

Quote

_Tabs_

@Tabsfully

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#14

OLVs are provided out of context.

so how much Avni knows is unknown to us?

maybe Neil takes her aside and lets her know. maybe he corrects her right after that scene.

Point being Neil and Avni will support each other no matter what.

that's who they are. they love and respect each other unlimited. No fake child or illegitimate issue is going to stand in their way.

If not now, then Later, Avni will find out and I think she'll be even more proud of Neil. She knows what it's like to live and grow up without a father's name. and the fact that Neil is willing to give his name to a child, will increase his respect in her eyes.

Quote

Sonali

@adventure_gurl

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

#15

maybe Neil is accepting for now that child is his to give rationale as to why he is going so far in planning to get the child back. Has Juhi told vilian the child is not his but Neil's instead, that would probably be why Neil is lying to Avni, but I still think it's wrong to lie to Avni about this

Quote

Kaiina

@Kaina.Ain

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#16

Avni was one braveheart who risked her own self only n only to save neils 1st love from tat brothel... it irks me even more when neil lied to her about the baby being his...which is im sure untrue.

Avni is a part of himself..how can he lie to an own self. He considers her his lifeline...all false allegations...declaring to the world around. Either he is faking around abt avni being the world to him nor confessing his true self to avni!

Sorry to say this...dont trust him anymore. Disgusted

Quote

dsupriya

@dsupriya

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#17

I have not posted for long but I think I will trust Zain's IV better than these spoilers. In the first IV he says he went to tell Avni about Juhi and bacchha raaz and he says this us suspense why he says mera bacchha types and you will know whose child it is. He also says you will know soon enough voh kyun bura maan jaati hai. Pointing towards Aditi. In the second IV he clearly says entire bacchha track is suspense and there are reasons for it.

OLVS don't show all but there is a possibility that the episode may mute the complete conversation between them where he revealed truthfully. Otherwise this line you will know Woh kyun bura maan jaati hai will not be said by Zain in IV.

So I would rather wait for story to unfold than speculate.

I definitely am not excusing Neil here but without knowing the story don't want to judge either. Yes if later it is revealed he was not truthful for a very idiotic reason then will bash him. Till then want to understand what story cvs are weaving and why. Why Juhi is also quite or not bothered if Avni has this misconception. There is something more to it.

Quote

srinithi

@AgnesFan

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#18

If all the three are fine with it then there can be only one possibility like all knew the truth

Whatever the fact is its so unlikely of Neil concealing the fact for a dumb reason . Also we never heard what he said before hugging her as she proposes him

OLVs NE Banda phod Di !

We had speculated too much .

Quote

Nandhu_Arshi

@Nan_ArHi

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: _Tabs_
OLVs are provided out of context.
so how much Avni knows is unknown to us?

maybe Neil takes her aside and lets her know. maybe he corrects her right after that scene.

Point being Neil and Avni will support each other no matter what.

that's who they are. they love and respect each other unlimited. No fake child or illegitimate issue is going to stand in their way.

If not now, then Later, Avni will find out and I think she'll be even more proud of Neil. She knows what it's like to live and grow up without a father's name. and the fact that Neil is willing to give his name to a child, will increase his respect in her eyes.

Avni would respect him for that but that doesn't change the fact that he lied to her. Don't you think that's unfair to a wife? If he was open about it, no problem at all. Even when she proposed he said the kid is his when he knows its out of character for Avni to propose and stuffs and she did it for him.

Neil claims he loves Avni, his present, his lifeline but his actions doesn't prove any of that. May be its his plan to Vidyut but keeping Avni at dark is a blunder

Quote

1 2

Then what would have Neil done? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics