|| In Defense of Shivay and Anika ||

Muggle_Diaries thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Hiya Friends,

I was not sure if I wanted to write this or not. Whole night the ideas just popped up in my head and never went. In the end I decided to write this before I lose another night of sleep.

I have divided this into two posts. In Defense of Anika' would be posted soon, may be tomorrow.

Before I begin, you need to understand that I had not watched the separation episodes when they were aired. I watched then on Hotstar last week, and I did forward few scenes with Pinky and few random scenes. Anyway I did get the gist of the story. So if I have missed something or want to add few more points, please feel free. I would love to hear from you guys.


In Defense of Shivay:

Right now Shivay is a man with a broken soul. For the first time in his life he had trusted a person who was not his blood relative. Whether he acknowledged it or not, the moment he became this great wall of Shivay' for Anika, and Sahil in extension, is when we can see he is in love. Till then he protected only his family. That is how he expresses his love. His protection is his love. He can use any words he wants, like responsibility'.

When he fell in Love, he gave everything. He placed her above his family. He gave her his everything, and basked in the knowledge that he matters to her, that she protects him and his family. They are two peas of the same pod.

Then she broke him.

We all know what happened. But he does not. Yes, he should have realized that something was wrong. She stood by him when no one did. Anika he knew would not do such a terrible thing. But, she did behave in a terrible manner and hurt him. We need to understand from his point of view. She might be doing this out of some compulsion and she might be in trouble. So, why did she not confide in him? She should know that he will be with her. Did she think so less of their bond and relationship after all that they have been together? If she might be doing this deliberately, then why? All the things she said or acted out, was it because she wanted their relationship to end and this was her way to getting rid of him? In any of the cases, his hurt and anger is valid. I don't think he believed that she was after money. He must have known or will know, once his anger cooled down, when his hurt is bearable, that there has to a reason. But this will not erase the fact that his heart was broken. Oh! He forgave her the moment she came back to his home. He just wants to know why she did what she did. And that she loves him still. This is SSO we are talking. He will not give in this time so easily. She will have to work for it.

Many of us are understandably irritated with the way Shivay is behaving towards Ragini. I have a different take on it. A stalker harassing a woman, and no one believes her. Ring any bell? Shivay almost lost Anika to one such person, because he trusted Daksh over her. His own sister was subjected to abuse in the past. He will not let another woman suffer when he can help. Shivay in the past would not have done this. (Did he help her before knowing which family Ragini belongs to? Help me out here people). Why does he not believe Anika? Because he desperately wants her to be jealous of Ragini and that is why she is against Ragini. Also, there were attacks of Ragini in front of him. He might be thinking, Anika might have misunderstood the whole thing, even if her intentions are right.

In any case, Shivay will make Anika jealous and make her accept her Farak' while helping a woman in need. If Ragini is lying, what does it matter to him? He can eliminate her at any time. His games with Anika are more important. This is SSO we are talking about. He never has one goal, he has multiple agendas. He will make Anika desperate for him, desperate for his love. He will make Anika tell everything, but on his terms. He will make Anika say I love You' first. As I have always said, there is always one or the other game going on between Shivay and Anika.

What do you guys think?

I will write Anika's POV in my next post.

Love

Kshithi



Edited by Muggle_Diaries - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.3k

Users

7

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

rarefan thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I liked your take on it. Right now, shivay is testing her again. He is testing whether she is still there for him and why if she is. He tries to be there for her. He tries to search her face for answers. He gets frustrated when he doesn't get them.
The whole track started with making SSO come back. But there is a hidden agenda. He is also trying to make her come back.

Maddy
Muggle_Diaries thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: rarefan

I liked your take on it. Right now, shivay is testing her again. He is testing whether she is still there for him and why if she is. He tries to be there for her. He tries to search her face for answers. He gets frustrated when he doesn't get them.

The whole track started with making SSO come back. But there is a hidden agenda. He is also trying to make her come back.

Maddy


You are right Maddy.

Before he accepts her back into his life and he does know it is inevitable, he IS testing her. And he will make her work for him! 😊

Love
Kshithi
LordLuminous thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Why do we need to defend Shivaay or Annika? The whole separation was out of character right at the base. Suddenly Shivika's Awareness doesn't work. Suddenly, Shivaay doesn't suspect that Annika might be doing this for a reason right from the start. Suddenly, Annika has no faith in Shivaay accepting the truth after accepting her.

This is all the writer's fault for making such a forced separation. This isn't even Shivika's fault.

Your post is lovely, but it falls on deaf ears when the writing is so bad. Thank you for taking the time and writing it though. Probably much needed point of views.

(Only read Shivaay POV so I'm waiting for Annika POV. Editing for later.)
Muggle_Diaries thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: LordLuminous

Why do we need to defend Shivaay or Annika? The whole separation was out of character right at the base. Suddenly Shivika's Awareness doesn't work. Suddenly, Shivaay doesn't suspect that Annika might be doing this for a reason right from the start. Suddenly, Annika has no faith in Shivaay accepting the truth after accepting her.

This is all the writer's fault for making such a forced separation. This isn't even Shivika's fault.

Your post is lovely, but it falls on deaf ears when the writing is so bad. Thank you for taking the time and writing it though. Probably much needed point of views.

(Only read Shivaay POV so I'm waiting for Annika POV. Editing for later.)


I try not to concentrate on the writing...😃 because if I did, I would never watch these serials.

I don't think Shivay suspects Anika has any reason for what she did when they got separated. At that time he was only reacting. At this point of time we don't know if he suspects or not. That is why I wrote he already suspected her or he will once his anger and hurt are cooled down.

But, I get what you are saying in terms of writing and other things. To some extent I agree, especially post leap part.

Love to hear from you about Anika's post as well.

Love
Kshithi
missreddy7 thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Hey Kshithi,

Well Done! Good Analysis! It was nice to read your take on this, I guess (looking at the precap anyway!) Shivaay is waiting for Annika to let go of her guard. He is believing what he is seeing (overtaking the house, the fianc, the dress) but I guess he has a gut feeling of some sort? Which probably tells him she still cares. the moment he hears that from her - he might actually do something?

Looking forward to Annika's POV! DO write soon!



Res! (For Annika)
rarefan thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: LordLuminous

Why do we need to defend Shivaay or Annika? The whole separation was out of character right at the base. Suddenly Shivika's Awareness doesn't work. Suddenly, Shivaay doesn't suspect that Annika might be doing this for a reason right from the start. Suddenly, Annika has no faith in Shivaay accepting the truth after accepting her.

This is all the writer's fault for making such a forced separation. This isn't even Shivika's fault.

Your post is lovely, but it falls on deaf ears when the writing is so bad. Thank you for taking the time and writing it though. Probably much needed point of views.

(Only read Shivaay POV so I'm waiting for Annika POV. Editing for later.)

Actually, I have failed to understand the base of this track. I never understood the need or urgency of anika protecting shivay from pinky.
But now that it has been shoved down our throats, it seems only right to make sure that we understand the consequences of this whole pinky drama.
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Finally seeing a post after ages that has something to say in shivaay's defense I thought I was the only one with small group of people who think like but glad to know there are others, well I will not add anything about shivaay and ragini's arc also can't add much because I am not following IB regularly, I watch shivika scenes only so I can PS them later😆 jokes apart, post separation there were my complains that what shivaay is going through is not what he deserves like majority thinks that he got what he deserved also what anika did to him to get separated from him was extremely foolish and that makes my point justified because later when anika returned to OM she admitted it was a big mistake, about shivaay not sensing something wrong and not trusting her is something that does not apply here, he considers family and anika who is also her family his strength, he did sense something was bothering anika but how could he able to connect all that to what anika did to him she used om his brother against him and insulted the whole oberoi family and anika knows that when it comes to family's izzat shivaay cannot tolerate any crap and he didn't and throw anika out of house and later cried and was totally shattered but now like you said he has started to look for possible reasons why anika left him like this though I do not approve his ways either of making her jealous and farak games that should be done on more mature level like shivaay has way of doing and finding out things.

As for anika I love all her scenes when she confronted pinky since she's back to OM I hope she deals with shivaay too in the same rational ways and in defense of both I want a very serious conversation where both will pour out all their secrets as to what's keeping them apart instead of turning whole scenario into a comical thing!!!!


Mallu
Anonyme thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
For me the separation was so badly done that I don't really care about who's guilty or not, who is less guilty etc
For me both failed lamentably, because one doesn't clap with one hand! There was a crack between shivika, only then pinky could have separated them!
The crack was due to both in my eyes!
Anyway back to your analysis, n ignoring my POV about separation, I understand that SSO is too hurt to take the first step this time! However I wished he started introspecting a bit!
Let's see your POV of annika now.

To end the writer forced that illogical separation, the minimum she could do was heal us by worthwhile logical n intense scenes! Shivika progression is missing since past 3 weeks now! That's why people are getting angrier at either annika or SSO lately
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ashti1234

For me the separation was so badly done that I don't really care about who's guilty or not, who is less guilty etc

For me both failed lamentably, because one doesn't clap with one hand! There was a crack between shivika, only then pinky could have separated them!
The crack was due to both in my eyes!
Anyway back to your analysis, n ignoring my POV about separation, I understand that SSO is too hurt to take the first step this time! However I wished he started introspecting a bit!
Let's see your POV of annika now.

To end the writer forced that illogical separation, the minimum she could do was heal us by worthwhile logical n intense scenes! Shivika progression is missing since past 3 weeks now! That's why people are getting angrier at either annika or SSO lately


well said👏👏👏 every word of yours make total sense.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".