Do NRI's overreact? or Desi's don't react

IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Don't kill me for posting this topic.

Hi All,

When it comes to Indian ness.....Festivals..Traditions....Patriotism.......

The people in India....are marching ahead in westernizing the things.....everything is artificial......nothing happens to that extent that happens in Ekta Kapoor Serials...

Do NRI's overreact? Are they more conscious about India, Indian traditions and Patriotism? Is it that the feeling of staying away from motherland makes them grab every oppurtunity to show Indianess........or is it simply a fashion statement...I find most of my NRI relative friends following traditions and all more than we people in India.They even learn the classical music😊

on the other side......The Indians in India.....

Huh! They like Valentineday more than Independence day or Republic Day.....They don't even try to display the Indian Flag....unless and untill it is hosted in Some College, School or Govt Office.....if any one displays the flag at home...all think.."Oh..She is crazy..."......

Are Indians Shy creatures..wrt to display of their feelings?

Please share your thoughts....

Wishes,

Mythili

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

sowmyaa thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
Mythilli, I think there could be lot of reasons to it and we can go on and on with each individual what they want. Most or mass of NRI I can say do more of Indian festivals more to expose their kids who are being raised in other country with other culture. I myself try to do more of festivals traditional way to make sure my daughter is expose to it. And when you are in other country only exposure they get is through you, unlike in India they can see all around them the festiva air. For example, Diwali, what is diya, why diya and not candle, why do fireworks, or Navratri, why do dance, whay wear traditional clothes etc. Just to keep Indian culture alive in our kids we try hard to stick to our tradition and culture more.

COmpared to India, parents don't ahve to work hard to expose them to religion or festival, or tradition. They can see all around them (neighbors, school, tv) that they are Hindu, or Sikh, or Muslim or whatever religion they are or they know what Diwali is.

It could be more than the only reason I came up with, but this also is a reason i have seen around me playing role for NRI's to sticking to and exposing more of their culture and traditions.
SolidSnake thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Woh kehte hain naa ki Ghar se door hone par hi ghar ki yaad aati hai..tab pata chalta hai ki "apne to apne hote hain". 😊
souro thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

on the other side......The Indians in India.....

Huh! They like Valentineday more than Independence day or Republic Day.....They don't even try to display the Indian Flag....unless and untill it is hosted in Some College, School or Govt Office.....if any one displays the flag at home...all think.."Oh..She is crazy..."......

Are Indians Shy creatures..wrt to display of their feelings?

Is this supposed to be a trick question Myth?? On one hand you say Indians like Valentines Day more than Independence Day or Republic Day and on the other hand you ask if Indians are shy to display their feelings.

As for the issue I feel, firstly as SSji said, ghar se door jane ke baad hi ghar ki yaad aati hai.

Secondly, pls don't say that Indians like Valentines Day more than Republic Day or Independence Day. Just because some teenagers or college goers or yuppies celebrate Valentines Day doesn't mean the whole of India relate with it. Though Republic Day and Indepenedence Day are celebrated mainly in schools, colleges, offices, societies/ clubs but most of the people willingly participate there. Have you seen the attendance at Republic Day parade every year in Delhi and every other State capital. Moreover, remember Valentines Day and Independence/ Republic Day are celebrated on different dates, so here it doesn't necessarily have to be either or, it can be both. Just because a person celebrate Valentines Day doesn't mean that he forgot about Republic/ Independence Day.

Thirdly, noone thinks that someone is crazy to hoist the national flag at their home. I think everyone would've loved to display the national flag but the fact is for fifty years the rule was only Government buildings can display the national flag throughout the year. You can't change what has been set into people's mind overnight. Plus there are so much rules and regulations attached to the display of the Indian national flag anywhere even now that people feel it's safer not to display it rather than risk all the hassles. But if you see cars (private/ rental) and some other such things they proudly display the Indian flag. Though I've also seen autos in Bangalore displaying the flag of Karnataka, but that's beside the point and you have to ask them why they display the flag of their state instead of the national flag.

lighthouse thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

When it comes to Indian ness.....Festivals..Traditions....Patriotism.......

The people in India....are marching ahead in westernizing the things.....everything is artificial......nothing happens to that extent that happens in Ekta Kapoor Serials...

Do NRI's overreact? Are they more conscious about India, Indian traditions and Patriotism? Is it that the feeling of staying away from motherland makes them grab every oppurtunity to show Indianess........or is it simply a fashion statement...I find most of my NRI relative friends following traditions and all more than we people in India.They even learn the classical music😊

I don't know about over reacting but NRIs react fondly and positively to anything Indian and perhaps rightfully so with regards to food, entertainment,medicine, religion and spirituality, hence we see constant presence of few bollywood/ tv stars, astrolgers, religious preachers etc. One of the Indian wedding we went to had all mithaii flown overnight from India. 😛 Most ethnic communities behave in similar fashion in the U.S when it comes to food, entertainment etc.

When you go to Indian grocery store here, I can understand buying parathas, pav bhaji masala, chaatt masala, various spices and vegetables etc from India but there is whole isle of soaps, shampoos and cosmetics such as Lux and emami soaps, ponds powder and parle biscuits. 😕 and perhaps pay more then local soap from here which I understand could be cherished over there in India.

Edited by lighthouse - 17 years ago
raj5000 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: souro

Is this supposed to be a trick question Myth?? On one hand you say Indians like Valentines Day more than Independence Day or Republic Day and on the other hand you ask if Indians are shy to display their feelings.

Probably Indians are shy to display feelings targeted to Indians living abroad. If thats true, then no Myth I havn't seen anyone shy... infact we (me and aquaintence I know) love to talk about it and most westerniers are very interested to hear all about.. " That's very interesting " karkey 😆.

As for the issue I feel, firstly as SSji said, ghar se door jane ke baad hi ghar ki yaad aati hai.

That is soo true..also such occasions feel good that we have like minded people around. Food/Sweet comes the last 😉😆 Also as As Sowmya mentioned is also one of the main reasons i.e. for kids sake...have seen so many adv. in desi magazine on cultural/traditions classes being offered here, makes me wonder again itna we ever did as a kid in India.

Secondly, pls don't say that Indians like Valentines Day more than Republic Day or Independence Day. Just because some teenagers or college goers or yuppies celebrate Valentines Day doesn't mean the whole of India relate with it. Though Republic Day and Indepenedence Day are celebrated mainly in schools, colleges, offices, societies/ clubs but most of the people willingly participate there. Have you seen the attendance at Republic Day parade every year in Delhi and every other State capital. Moreover, remember Valentines Day and Independence/ Republic Day are celebrated on different dates, so here it doesn't necessarily have to be either or, it can be both. Just because a person celebrate Valentines Day doesn't mean that he forgot about Republic/ Independence Day.

VD is more hyped then celebrated,,, after Shiv Sena is making big deal out it... all three have its own importance..VD ..I agree is more depending upon age factor but latter two... everyone has equal value...I remember last year many folks in IF were dying to watch the parade...(thanks to Sweta she did upload see the feelings) and doubt is that feeling is any indifferent in India.

Thirdly, noone thinks that someone is crazy to hoist the national flag at their home. I think everyone would've loved to display the national flag but the fact is for fifty years the rule was only Government buildings can display the national flag throughout the year. You can't change what has been set into people's mind overnight. Plus there are so much rules and regulations attached to the display of the Indian national flag anywhere even now that people feel it's safer not to display it rather than risk all the hassles. But if you see cars (private/ rental) and some other such things they proudly display the Indian flag. Though I've also seen autos in Bangalore displaying the flag of Karnataka, but that's beside the point and you have to ask them why they display the flag of their state instead of the national flag.

3rd point yes... I read when I wanted a one for the porch that are rules against hosting Indian flag.

mermaid_QT thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
i agree with most of you above about NRIs retaining Indianness in order to hold on to the roots, while indians in india would be curious about the rest of the world.
the result mythili is what we / you observe i believe.
but then again, it depends on the individual. i never over-did / under-did culture, tradition and festival things.. did not do as an NRI either..
193980 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Myth, I don't think Indians in India have don't care attitude and NRIs overdo the traditions and celebrations. It is just that in India since it is expected, people don't make it a big deal whereas since the number is less abroad any celebrations done here is reported as a big deal.

193980 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: SolidSnake

Woh kehte hain naa ki Ghar se door hone par hi ghar ki yaad aati hai..tab pata chalta hai ki "apne to apne hote hain". 😊

Deepak, Himmy bhai ka gaana hai na😆? Waise agree with this too.

nitasuni thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sowmyaa

Mythilli, I think there could be lot of reasons to it and we can go on and on with each individual what they want. Most or mass of NRI I can say do more of Indian festivals more to expose their kids who are being raised in other country with other culture. I myself try to do more of festivals traditional way to make sure my daughter is expose to it. And when you are in other country only exposure they get is through you, unlike in India they can see all around them the festiva air. For example, Diwali, what is diya, why diya and not candle, why do fireworks, or Navratri, why do dance, whay wear traditional clothes etc. Just to keep Indian culture alive in our kids we try hard to stick to our tradition and culture more.

COmpared to India, parents don't ahve to work hard to expose them to religion or festival, or tradition. They can see all around them (neighbors, school, tv) that they are Hindu, or Sikh, or Muslim or whatever religion they are or they know what Diwali is.

It could be more than the only reason I came up with, but this also is a reason i have seen around me playing role for NRI's to sticking to and exposing more of their culture and traditions.

I agree with you sowmyaa ji.

But in my family itself there are persons who are more foreigner than the actual foreigner.( believe me, not out of jealousy)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".