Season 3 IS NOT similar to Season 1

Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Folks for heavens sake please STOP comparing with Season 1. The stories are totally different. In S1 its about a rich, arrogant guy falling for a simple, poor, small town girl. There was no revenge or other stuff.

Season 3 is totally different story. Its a revenge story. Both Advay & Shivani are social equals. Not only that they actually knew each other in the past, were childhood friends. Shivani's family betrayed Advay's & at least in the FBs looks like Shivani also had a role in that. So Advay is rightfully in avenging demon mode.

Even the backdrop, settings etc are different. Here its Advay who is an orphan & Shivani has a family,

Only similarities i see are:

1. Barun as AYM
2. Rabba ve
3. Trip-Fall-Catch-Eyelock
4. ML practicing weight lifting with FL

But all the above plot devices are common in Gul Maiyya's shows.

So for the love of God please stop comparing the 2 seasons.

Yes I hate the costumes. Everyone does & given a chance I will fire the costume designer but got to know that she is Gul's fav so fat chance of that happening 😡

Acting of even Barun is still a little scratchy but I think he is just a tad rusty. Am sure he will get into full form in a few episodes. Still not totally impressed by Shivani but she is definitely trying so want to give her a chance.

And yeah I hated the burning scene & ve already ranted enuf about that.

But i really dont understand y ppl keep dragging Season 1 here. Folks please dont do that. This story is completely different & if the above glitches pointed out by me are ironed out along with editing the show has potential.
Edited by Angels11 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.8k

Users

12

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

ERA. thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
u have a point but the bg music taking me back to s1
Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ERA.

u have a point but the bg music taking me back to s1



I think Gul is dng it intentionally. Guess its meant to attract barun fans who would love the Barun+Rabba Ve combination.
rafiki84 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Angels11

Folks for heavens sake please STOP comparing with Season 1. The stories are totally different. In S1 its about a rich, arrogant guy falling for a simple, poor, small town girl. There was no revenge or other stuff.

Season 3 is totally different story. Its a revenge story. Both Advay & Shivani are social equals. Not only that they actually knew each other in the past, were childhood friends. Shivani's family betrayed Advay's & at least in the FBs looks like Shivani also had a role in that. So Advay is rightfully in avenging demon mode.

Even the backdrop, settings etc are different. Here its Advay who is an orphan & Shivani has a family,

Only similarities i see are:

1. Barun as AYM
2. Rabba ve
3. Trip-Fall-Catch-Eyelock
4. ML practicing weight lifting with FL

But all the above plot devices are common in Gul Maiyya's shows.

So for the love of God please stop comparing the 2 seasons.

Yes I hate the costumes. Everyone does & given a chance I will fire the costume designer but got to know that she is Gul's fav so fat chance of that happening 😡

Acting of even Barun is still a little scratchy but I think he is just a tad rusty. Am sure he will get into full form in a few episodes. Still not totally impressed by Shivani but she is definitely trying so want to give her a chance.

And yeah I hated the burning scene & ve already ranted enuf about that.

But i really dont understand y ppl keep dragging Season 1 here. Folks please dont do that. This story is completely different & if the above glitches pointed out by me are ironed out along with editing the show has potential.


I don't know about the others, but the cut-paste scene was a major turn off today. They can do whatever they want with the show, just don't expect people to not fire back when such dramatics are being pulled off. Kept on chanting, nothing similar with previous season, I see some aspects not similar, but then going ahead and pulling such an act.. tch tch! Makes me question the creative calls people are making and the hypocrisy with which they promoted the show. To distinguish both seasons, they could've subtly showed the overlapping from the previous season. Pulling such a stunt in the first few episodes was a sure shot to rile people up, don't want constant comparisons, stop shoving the same scenes in the audiences' faces; and if you're still doing it, then be prepared for the repercussions as well. I'm not hating on the new actors, I'm all for them, but knowing everything and then going ahead to pull off these skits... SMH.

The show has a lot of potential, and it will play out in the upcoming days, but if the lather-rinse-repeat keeps going on, the forum shall remain a foreground for continued wars.
Edited by rafiki84 - 8 years ago
rafiki84 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: rafiki84


I don't know about the others, but the cut-paste scene was a major turn off today. They can do whatever they want with the show, just don't expect people to not fire back when such dramatics are being pulled off. Kept on chanting, nothing similar with previous season, I see some aspects not similar, but then going ahead and pulling such an act.. tch tch! Makes me question the creative calls people are making and the hypocrisy they portrayed while promoting the show. To distinguish both seasons, they could've subtly showed the overlapping from the previous season. Pulling such a stunt in the first few episodes was a sure shot to rile people up, don't want constant comparisons, stop shoving the same scenes in the audiences' faces; and if you're still doing it, then be prepared for the repercussions as well. I'm not hating on the new actors, I'm all for them, but knowing everything and then going ahead to pull off these skits... SMH.

The show has a lot of potential, and it will play out in the upcoming days, but if the lather-rinse-repeat keeps going on, the forum shall remain a foreground for continued wars.

rafiki84 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
I apologize for triple posting 😕
Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: rafiki84


I don't know about the others, but the cut-paste scene was a major turn off today. They can do whatever they want with the show, just don't expect people to not fire back when such dramatics are being pulled off. Kept on chanting, nothing similar with previous season, I see some aspects not similar, but then going ahead and pulling such an act.. tch tch! Makes me question the creative calls people are making and the hypocrisy with which they promoted the show. To distinguish both seasons, they could've subtly showed the overlapping from the previous season. Pulling such a stunt in the first few episodes was a sure shot to rile people up, don't want constant comparisons, stop shoving the same scenes in the audiences' faces; and if you're still doing it, then be prepared for the repercussions as well. I'm not hating on the new actors, I'm all for them, but knowing everything and then going ahead to pull off these skits... SMH.

The show has a lot of potential, and it will play out in the upcoming days, but if the lather-rinse-repeat keeps going on, the forum shall remain a foreground for continued wars.



When Season 1 stared there was a similar backlash from Geet fans. Many of the fainting, lifting, eye lock scenes were supposed to be lifted from there. And i did go back & watched those scenes on net & yes they were right. There were lot of similarities between the scenes. So from what i understand its standard MO of Gul in all her shows. These scenes come in almost all her shows (I dont watch Indian serials but many ve told this). So not sure where so much anger is coming from 😕
MistiofMistz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
No matter how many times you explain the difference. Nobody going to observes it. I watched Geet, Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon (Season 1 & 2), Qubool Hai, Ishqbaaz & now Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Season 3. There are going to be similar romance, but different atmosphere. Hopefully, with time everything gets better. Maybe once story settles in then, clothing might change for Chandini.
rafiki84 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Angels11



When Season 1 stared there was a similar backlash from Geet fans. Many of the fainting, lifting, eye lock scenes were supposed to be lifted from there. And i did go back & watched those scenes on net & yes they were right. There were lot of similarities between the scenes. So from what i understand its standard MO of Gul in all her shows. These scenes come in almost all her shows (I dont watch Indian serials but many ve told this). So not sure where so much anger is coming from 😕


Clearly Geet fans were enraged at that time and IPK fans are enraged now. I don't see any difference. Yes the basic requirements of Gul shows are similar, in fact same in most cases, but when there is a previous season whose fans are still very active on each platform, by doing something like what they did today, will cause them to face backlash. For example tomorrow, if IPK3 shows Chandni burning Advay's car or throwing shit at him, I'm sure IB fans would be enraged as well. That's why I don't see any difference. People here are entitled to whatever they want to feel and post; also you can't really help the comparison when they makers pull such stunts.
rafiki84 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: MistiofMistz

Maybe once story settles in then, clothing might change for Chandini.



That's too much expectation bitiya 😆 The clothes, as story progress, get worse. Been there so many times 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".