With all the theories flying around about neil perhaps being akash, there are a few things I have noticed that make me doubtful.
When nanno and neil were having that convo, and nanno showed him a pic with asha and avni in it, neil didn't react or recognise her.
Secondly, neil knows that ali loves avni, so if he was akash and is in love with avni, why would he react so indifferently. I imagine if another person talks about being in love with the same person you love, a person wouldn't act the way neil does.
Also, what about this childhood love called juhi who died? Why is it that even DD knows about juhi and even said to ali that if anybody knows about love, then it is neil, and considering this was coming from DD, and how seriously he said it, it doesn't seem like its a girl who he only met briefly in childhood. It was definitely a stronger more mature love story that ended in tragedy, which caused neil to take up law enforcement.
Honestly, I gave up on the 'neil is akash' theory along time ago, and now all I think is that juhi was probably murdered, otherwise why else would neil want to go into law enforcement over his girlfriend's death, unless he saw her being murdered, or she was murdered by somebody, but the person was not caught. If the man was caught and punished, I don't think he would have become a cop, but rather I would say the murder mystery of his childhood lover/ girlfriend and the person not being caught would have driven him to take the decision to become a cop. And I think it is obvious that the culprit would turn out to be the main villain of this show.
I really hope this theory of mine turns out to be true, because I have no hope anymore for the akash theory, and plus if my theory turns out correct, then it would make more sense, be logical, and would add more depth to avneil's love story and neil's character.
What do you guys think of my theory? Do you think juhi was murdered by some unknown suspect who was never caught, and neil, both enraged and devastated, decided to take up law enforcement as a result?
Edited by sammy17 - 8 years ago