I can't agree with most of the points that you said. The gobbar scene was worthe watching. The smug smile on all their faces. Nakuul's expressions, the excitement, the hope, the smile
But Tia wala drama jama nahi. Initially when she seemesd worried that Anika is calling Dushyant and Svet said that it's okay, he's dead. Tia's expressions weren't exactly how they should have been. She looked as if she knew he's alive. And then came the whole Mrs. Kapoor's web of lies and we know that Dushyant is with her.
Tia can't recognize his voice or what? It was so very his.
And then Shivaay needs to learn some detective giri. I mean Tia would have said what she thought if he didn't interject. I know he's an Oberoi and his naam khoon khaandan do not let him eavesdrop. (Cue a big eye roll please)
Other than that Rudra's expressions were a give away. When Anika said uska pyaar or something, Rudy had his signature eyebrow raise (that I have grown to love ☺️) and then when she said Dushyant he had this victory expression...
And in the Saumya's letter scene, after reading it when Anika was giving him asvice the devar bhabhi had a nice conversation. They were as if talking through their eyes. She told him he cares so he shouldn't let go. All that was lovely ❤️
Special mention to Nakul-Surbhi's timing, the expression. Dono ekdum jamm chuke hain. I absolutely enjoyed that part. ❤️