Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1k

Users

11

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

srilatha1 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
i am just in awe of all the posts in this thread. i don't think even the makers would have ever thought that they are going to create a phenomena called JNDSD. and the actors, shivani and vikram, the passion that they brought to these characters has made it both believable and unbelievable at the same time. it's like they both are living these roles.
totalmess thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: beagleboy

Dearest Alishah,

It cannot be true that you don't know about being in love, because you do. Being in love is no different from loving someone, the feelings are just inclined differently to include an attraction that extends to the physical.

There is much said about love by authors, poets and film makers. Love is an unquenchable thirst, the more you drink the more thirsty you get. You really cannot have enough of it. When you fall in love, or when you love, it completes you and makes you happy and sad all at once. It takes you to great heights and pushes you down these tall heights too.

But what is love?

Love to me is an amalgamation of minds, not just the heart - A harmony of thoughts and values. You can only be in love with a person you respect. And you can only respect a person whose ideals and values you respect. The physical attraction and passion comes later.

In Vividha and Atharv's case, Atharv fell in love with Vividha because he respected her. The only time he was willing to let her go was when she lost a little of that respect. Equally, Vividha fell in love with Atharv because she respected him. Ofcourse, they were also insanely physically attracted to each other, but without the respect it would have come to naught. The attraction would not have blossomed into love.

Often, movies and shows give young girls the wrong idea that you can fall in love with persons of a different mind set. If you are educated and have the ideals and values of an educated woman,it is not possible to fall in love with someone uneducated, because you will not share the same goals and ideals or values in life. There will always be a mental divide which will ruin the relationship once the physical distance and other socio economic differences creep in. I hear of girls who have eloped with drivers, local thugs and I feel really sad for them and for what lies ahead in their lives. Irresponsible cinema and TV is to blame.

Vivdha and Atharv are both educated and both of them share the same ideals and goals. Both are strong and opposed to injustice. And so with a little drama and a lot of intimacy, they make a strong pair. When a parent is wrong, and opposed to a relationship for irrational reasons, a child will have to rebel. However, at times, Parents are right. Kailash was wrong because he was blinded by ego, status and hatred. The people in the V mansion are wrong now because they are giving precedence to false notions of marriage, thus ruining 3 lives. So, I think it is only right Atharv and Vividha stand up for what they have jointly believed to be right - freedom of choice and the pursuit of what is right (because it is right and not what the society believes to be right).

Their love story is beautifully portrayed and I hope it continues to be portrayed in this manner.



Dearest Beagle🤗
Can I just begin by thanking you for your response and letting me know that its wrong to say I don't know love?! I just don't know romantic love😆

Such a pleasant notion you have put forward, that when all, not only hearts, are in perfect harmony, that is love. And respect, such a key pillar of love. Without respect, like you said, the base of love is weak. Anything thats structural integrity can be brought into question won't survive forever.

I can also sympathise with your point about irresponsible TV and film to a large extent too. Being with someone as an act of defiance, rather than accidentally just falling in love, has been dramatised and romanticised and just Bollywood-ised to within an inch of its life!

Ultimately this is where the buck stops. Freedom of choice and the pursuit of what is right, as you so aptly put, is ultimately where the story of love should end. Funny really how so many, just like ViTharv are not granted these freedoms due to archaic and arbitrary concepts.
totalmess thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

Where were you all this time? Even you beagleboy and aditi you guys are only posting now? Why? This forum needs more writers like you lot.

Vividha & Atharv are what you call a true insanely passionate couple. This whole empowerment angle really added a whole new angle to a boy meet girl love story. A girl who had no real direction, a hidden strength met a boy with such strong ideals. She made him happy, soothed that emptiness he felt since forever and he gave her the push to stand up for what she believes in. I just find that aspect so beautiful! Every time Vividha stands her ground, I just have to give credit to Atharv for getting that out of her. Atharv's smiles and happiness are because of Vividha's presence which filled his incomplete life.

Like they say themselves, they both gave each other a meaning to the others life. They respect each other so much, they're a couple who actually TALK, they're a couple who are so passionately attracted to each other - something which existed since the first moment they had their almost crash in front of the tabela...what a magnetic moment that was!

They're a COUPLE madly in love, an extension of each other because they both discovered sides they didn't know existed within them.



I'm not sure if you're complimenting me Reemz, or telling me off for being active here only now but I will say thank you so much anyway. 😆

Could not agree with you more, the idea of empowerment through love is so significant, especially to this story. They made each other better, what can be more loving than that?

...an extension of each other
I particularly appreciate your phrase above, so accurate for ViTharv.


Edited by -Alishah- - 9 years ago
totalmess thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: CaputDraconis

Great post! Even I've never been in love and I totally don't buy the crap they dish out on TV/movies in the name of eternal love. I think Vitharv's journey towards discovering each other is a writing victory of sorts because I'm someone who's always decried the soulmate trope as portrayed in movies as hogwash. But this show has managed to delineate a cliched trope and given it a realistic spin. The metamorphosis of Vividha from a shy young girl blinded by her father's classist ideals in the garb of an over protective parent to someone who can fight against the archaic traditions is spectacularly portrayed. Basically, Atharv managed to sense Vividha's inner potential and strength of character which she herself was alien to given the social conditioning, and hence pursued her to free her from the shackles of of a conniving, control-freak of a father. It's a truly beautiful portrayal of the meeting of the minds deftly handled by the writers as well as the actors which has given unparalleled gravitas to this oft-repeated girl-meets-boy-falls-in-love trope. The cornerstone of any relationship especially that of love must be of mutual trust/admiration beyond the basal and ephemeral physical attraction. Only that sort of a relationship can be everlasting IMO.


Thank you! Damn, I wish I was as much a realist as you, I used to buy the whole coochie poochie notion from films like Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, DDLJ etc😆

Yes, certainly a victory in terms of writing. Phase 1 was written beautifully, especially in regards to ViTharv. Could not agree more that a cliche has been enhanced with normalcy and reliability. The portrayal of the conflict between Vividha and her Father was treated with enormous fragility, rightly so. And it was further intensified by her development as a human being altering the nature of the conflict.

He knew what she was capable of even before she did. Soulmates, or what?

Ultimatevikku7 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Beautifully written alishah...👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".