Addressing the stigma

Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
So back in november i was studying a module in uni called social exclusion. One of the lectures was on mental illness and stigma, and how people with mental health conditions are socially excluded in society. That module really was my favourite, especially this specific lecture. It made me realise how the media portrays a negative image of people with mental illnesses. This show to me also falls under this category of stereotyping and conforming to the negative image of mental illness just for entertainment and drama quotient.

I know that not everybody will agree to this point of mine, but maya's character and the way it has been written annoyingly conforms to this category. Basically part of the lecture was showing us newspaper article titles that sensationalised news related to mental illness by connecting it with crime. Some examples that i remembered were one called something like "Bonkers pilot crashes plane killing all aboard" where the pilot was suffering from depression and another was a woman suffering from post-natal depression killed her sleeping baby. The titles and news articles that the media write in relation to people with mental illness is one that projects them as being 'dangerous', 'out-of-control', 'unpredictable', 'selfish' and most importantly, unable to participate in society on the same levels of 'normal people' or whatever normal means in their books.

The point is why do the writers feel the need to make maya, a girl who has had a traumatic childhood and experienced profound grief, appear manipulative, unpredictable, someone whose nature cannot be trusted or selfish?

Why for once can't a tv show or movie make people with mental health conditions seem realistic? Maya's distrust for people and behavior of keeping people at bay for everything that happened to her is the only realistic thing i see about her apart from her possessiveness and fears of losing people she loves. Apart from that her overtly calculative actions, her actions of doing something nice for someone bordering on a facade and for her selfish motive of keeping arjun closer to her, as well as her intentions of playing smartly in order to put herself in the good books of arjun and his family are all giving the impression that because she has poor mental health, she isn't capable of thinking or being good to someone without having a purpose and can't forge genuine relationships with people without putting on a pretense to a certain extent. It gives the impression that having a mental health issue justifies someone acting selfish and only thinking about themselves so that's what people do.

Why can't she be shown being and acting like the real maya. I don't like the idea of her giving a job to saanjh, not because she truly wants to give her the job, but she sees that arjun is possessive about saanjh and is hurting to see saanjh away from him, so she decides to kill two birds with one stone by giving a job to saanjh in her office so saanjh will be by arjun's side and and he will no longer run away from maya just to run to saanjh all the time and at the same time, to once again get herself in arjun's good books. Why couldn't she have been shown actually doing it for arjun or out of respect for the fact that saanjh is arjun's best friend so she wanted to do it for him, rather than doing all this to further cement her good image in arjun's eyes?

If i was to re-write her character i would have kept her possessive side, but without all the mind-games of showing fake goodness in front of arjun and genuinely attempting to make good relationships with people, but at the same time her past trauma's acting as somewhat as a barrier to all those. Her initial no-nonsense attitude was really great, and so would have kept that the same and her being distrustful, as well as making her a girl who displays resilience and a bit more of a fighter attitude, as tough life experiences can often make people that way rather than always fearful, but i would have definitely left out the whole bull**** of her overthinking when trying to impress arjun and his family. Maya needs to be shown as genuinely wanting to change herself for arjun and his family and get out of her past, but being shown to still be possessive and insecure of losing them, so this making thinks more difficult for her, instead of pretending to be someone she isn't and doing things she genuinely doesn't want to do but just doing it because it will improve her image and make those people more closer to her. Make maya real and approachable.
Edited by sammy17 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

756

Users

6

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

ishakumar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I understand that you want to see her possessive side, and I want to see that too
But don't you think by making Saanjh work in the same office is showing signs of possessiveness because she will always be able to keep an eye on Saanjh and Arjun ;)
I'm sure after the wedding once Arjun and Maya begin to live together, Maya won't let Arjun spend much time with Saanjh other than in the office ;)
She will want Arjun all to herself
I think since they can't show a live in relationship in the show, they are showing arya'S wedding... because once two people start living together many things and circumstances change
Then you have to start living according to mutual agreement and that's what starts problems
I'm sure Maya will not want Arjun spendIng time with people that could potentially take Arjun away from Maya :)
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Maya has been possessive of Arjun ever since she had developed feelings for him. I too would like to see that side of her. She has appointed Saanjh so she can keep an eye on both.
MrsAkyurek thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
This is probably the BEST post I've read on this forum highlighting the discrepancy in the characterization of Maya! I'll come back to it in a while!
TFS
SStephy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
It's realistic that if mental issues aren't addressed rightly and allowed to fester for years, it does affect the one's mind-set and behaviour. It's like with any other regular illness... if we don't take the treatment, it'll get worse.



SRJKiShraddha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
ery beautiful post
Thing is many psychological issues untreated can result in crime but not all people living with mental issue are criminals. Normal people do have mental issues, they can suffer from depression.

Now coming to maya i will not call her psycho , she has some issues , i don't think maker want to show pyscho turn into criminal. They are emphasis is on junnon / beyhadh / passion.
If aim of the story was to show how love can heal psychological problem. Than there was no need to highlight maya's manipulation. Due to her past maya id highly insecure person , doesn't trust other n she will got to any extent to keep them with her. So her past just justify her behaviour not her actions .her actions i can't appreciate atleast this is not way redeem n get 2nd chance . Passion is temporary trust n love is permanent.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".