Shouldn't karthik understand?

Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
I get that karthik is incredibly hurt that naira didn't trust him and accused him of killing her mother, but shouldn't he understand that all the evidences were not only against him, but he himself didn't remember what happened, and even when naira asked him the day he came to her house he kept saying that he doesn't remember what happened. The only justification that he gave was that he THINKS he could never do such a thing, which wouldn't usually convince any human. To top that off, naira lost her mother, her father was an emotional wreck and her whole family were hurting over the death of akshara, and all the evidence was pointing towards karthik. Any human would have reacted the same way as naira did in this situation.

If karthik was in naira's place and instead of her mother, it was his mother killed and all the evidence pointed towards naira or another member of naira's family wouldn't he have also reacted the same way? I think right now karthik is just so hurt that he isn't in the right frame of mind to empathise with naira fully and understand that the way she reacted was not her fault and any human would have reacted the same way in that situation.

For now i think naira should perhaps give karthik space and not constantly ask him forgiveness. Time heals all wounds, and a little distance between him and naira will make him realise why she did what she did and make him miss her presence more. Hopefully naira instead goes back to trying to support her family in these difficult times as more than karthik, it is her father who needs her, and hope she concentrates on getting her dace academy up and running and concentrate on improving her art. Karthik has his whole family running after him, plus he needs space before he can think about forgiving naira.

For sure manish will be happy seeing karthik upset with naira and not wanting to talk to her, but i know that his happiness will not last long as kaira love one another way too much to stay apart from one another. Hopefully also naithik now relents and forgives karthik.
Edited by sammy17 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

1.5k

Users

6

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

whispa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I think the main reason why Kartik is so hurt is because Naira didn't give him the benefit of the doubt. As Suvarna said to Naira, one of the most important aspects of love is trusting the one you're in love with. If Naira had said to Kartik, she will believe he was innocent till proved guilty, Kartik would have accepted that. But she believed he was guilty without talking to him and that devastated him.

Yes of course, Kaira is right in her views too, because she reacted to the evidence.

I think both are right in their own way. You can't really blame either one for their reactions to the situation. Both were hurt and both lost someone they loved. But while Naira followed her head, Kartik followed his heart.

It will be interesting to see how they find their way back to each other.


joe10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
I am not on the same page as you...
I am no one to judge Naira what she did and why she did...
Kartik however did not get even a benefit of doubt...let alone trusting him...
In Kartiks words let the evidences go haywire he dosent care...he wanted was trust...
He never said that he dint remember anything...he said clearly... that there was no one during that accident...and just a stone...nothing else...the fact that he dosent remember the other car was becoz he had already met with an accident and unconcious to witness any other car...
It was the constant hurling of accusations that he gave up on himself and let fate decide...

Love is Trust...and Kartiks life background will reveal how vital role trust plays in his life...more than even Love...

The reason ...that...All the proofs pointed towards him is purely illogical...
No one listening to him..is his real pain..when he was screaming out his lungs that he dint do anything... and killed no one...there was just a stone...

Naira too needing a proof(their phone conversation) to even consider that Kartik maybe innocent is disappointing... her inner voice also reminded her... that she was just directing her pain and anger to Kartik to let it out...

As Swarna says it "Pyaar vo hai jo Kartik ne kiya hai"...
"Belieiving one without any conditions or proof is Love..."

Just for a thought think if in place of Kartik , there would have been some other family member... say Shaurya, Nannu, it could happen with anyone... would the family treat him/her the same way...

Anger is justified...Distrust isnt
even if she would have hit him in anger...in pain... he would have embraced her and tried to melt her pain...
But hell broke down upon him after the bridge scene...where she kept saying ... that Police has proofs... that you did the accident...
That moment of distrust has led to his hurt...
He himself has gone thru the pain of losing mother...he says it loud...
"Tumhara dard samajta hu me, par mujpar bharosa na karna ye manzoor nahi"

Just my view...
#noOffence😊...

Edited by joe10 - 8 years ago
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Naira was right in her place but even Karthik is right in his place.
bad bad thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Mere is baat ko agar koi smjh skay to smjhny ki koshish kary..pyar sirf kartik ny kia hai jis mein trust aur pure love hai,naira ka pyar bht hi weak hai,har bar wo kartik py ilzam lgati us py shak krti,phr jb wo proof deta hai tu us py yakin krti hai
Phly kohli uncle wala incident
Phr Naitik ki kidnapping wala scene us py ilzam lgaya usny..
Kartik ny aj tk us family k lye hamesha apni jaan py khel k unki help ki,hamesha wo ink lye khara raha...kartik k sath itna arsaa reh k koi pagal bhi smjh jaye k wo kitna honest kitna true aur kitna sacha admi hai..agar usny accident kia hota to wo sidha police k pas jaa k khud ko surrender krdeta..wo kbhi naira k ghar puchny nai ata k kia hua haii.
Saaf dikh raha tha k uski car stones n barriers se takrai hai..wo pyar hi kia jis mein trust na ho..us pyar ka sari zindagi koi faida nai hai..aj manish goenka ny btaya k usko apny bety py kitna yakin hai aur uska beta kitna sacha n honest hai..ye hota hai yakin jo usko apny bety py hai..
Kartik ny apni 1st priority py naira ko rakha hua hai,sb se imp uski life mein wo hai..but afsos naira jaise kachy kaan ki emotional lrki uska pyar deserve ni krti bcz jahan trust nai wahan kuch bhi naii..kartik jaise honest larky py shak krna sb se bari bewakufi hai singhania n maheshwaris ki..soo i hope k ab kartik kafi time tk stand ly sai wala..itna jldi kbhi maaf na kary
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: bad bad

Mere is baat ko agar koi smjh skay to smjhny ki koshish kary..pyar sirf kartik ny kia hai jis mein trust aur pure love hai,naira ka pyar bht hi weak hai,har bar wo kartik py ilzam lgati us py shak krti,phr jb wo proof deta hai tu us py yakin krti hai
Phly kohli uncle wala incident

Phr Naitik ki kidnapping wala scene us py ilzam lgaya usny..
Kartik ny aj tk us family k lye hamesha apni jaan py khel k unki help ki,hamesha wo ink lye khara raha...kartik k sath itna arsaa reh k koi pagal bhi smjh jaye k wo kitna honest kitna true aur kitna sacha admi hai..agar usny accident kia hota to wo sidha police k pas jaa k khud ko surrender krdeta..wo kbhi naira k ghar puchny nai ata k kia hua haii.
Saaf dikh raha tha k uski car stones n barriers se takrai hai..wo pyar hi kia jis mein trust na ho..us pyar ka sari zindagi koi faida nai hai..aj manish goenka ny btaya k usko apny bety py kitna yakin hai aur uska beta kitna sacha n honest hai..ye hota hai yakin jo usko apny bety py hai..
Kartik ny apni 1st priority py naira ko rakha hua hai,sb se imp uski life mein wo hai..but afsos naira jaise kachy kaan ki emotional lrki uska pyar deserve ni krti bcz jahan trust nai wahan kuch bhi naii..kartik jaise honest larky py shak krna sb se bari bewakufi hai singhania n maheshwaris ki..soo i hope k ab kartik kafi time tk stand ly sai wala..itna jldi kbhi maaf na kary

Bold..
Kohli time they wer not even friends..
Nk time they wer frnds..but by then.naman had brainwashed her

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".