Who is the 'nayi soch'? Ravish or Vividha.

jonjimmy thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Scrolling through d live updates of jndsd in Twitter I saw many tweets on Ravish being the nayi soch.Then came my personal favorite 'Ravish vashisht nayi soch' montage.So I asked one of them why do u think Ravish is a nayi soch.It was a legit question , not a mockery,so I got a genuine reply
"He is strong,a man of his words,he is the one who never bows down in front of difficulties.Ravish faces all difficulties without doing victim drama, he does not hold bitterness in him. He is doing good of everyone without expecting anything in return."
I agree with everything thing she says. But be honest, isn't this the character of almost all the heroines of saas bahu serial from stone age. Only thing new here is that it is portrayed by a man. He faces almost same difficulties and take d same decisions. Don't we have enough of this type of 'nayi soch' from d age of pamphlets? Yes, it is good to know that this unrealistic collaboration of traits are still d benchmark in judging a person. After all everything good should prevail. But where is the 'nayi soch' in this? All I see is an old wine(Ravish) in a new bottle and we all know how that tastes like.
To me 'nayi soch' is something that has never been portrayed before. It is something that questions the way we live and the rules we follow. It could be good ,bad or shades of both.So let's talk about 'ek chutki sindoor ki kheemath'. I am an Indian girl and I know the sanctity of sindoor and mangalsutra. To me it represents the promise of commitment and to love one another no matter what. The keyword here is 'REPRESENTS'. Why do we need a representation for a promise that binds two heart? Is it that weak a bond that it will disintegrate without the binding of a thread. Obviously in an era where a maiden can't look at a man more than a few seconds without being blackmarked require such nurturing. But what if the nurturing does not require such a binding? Well I am not wise enough to question the existence of eons old system like marriage. But can I question the origination of such a system? Being a romantic at heart I would love to believe that marriage started as a declaration of promise of love and commitment. Now this declaration has grown so strong that only the people who are married will have a valid promise of commitment and love. One of the arguments that Vividha should stay with Ravish was that they were married. Did marriage become that strong to dictate who to declare our love? I get that they are really selfish people who doesn't care about others feelings using the same argument to disolve marriages. But do we have to categorize a girl whose circumstances resulted in a forced marriage using the same argument as 'cheap'. Can't we afford a little leave in this case. Or has marriage become that rigid that it is irrevocable. Then why is divorce legal in India? I understand that almost 90% of the marriage are successful ,but what of the rest? Does a majority have to suffer to make some compensations in a system? Why ,is the majority that weak that it will be broken by the minority? Can't it be acceptable that Vividha could leave Ravish and still have dignity?
Another argument was Ravish is a good guy he deserves the heroine.Note that it is heroine they want not Vividha as such. Can I ask u something, Is it mandatory that a girl should fall in love with every nice guy in her life? Can't she have her own feelings and wishes? Does have to fall in love with a guy that society deems is right?
Isn't this issue worthy enough to be a 'nayi soch'. Yes, as u all can guess Vividha is a 'nayi soch' for as of now. Should only the old values made at old times still be set in stone can't it evolve with time? This is 'nayi soch' for me. But the question is are ready and brave enough to ask the same questions?

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

78

Frequent Posters

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Right I'm going to come across biased no matter what so I'll just say it how it is.


ATHARV - He is the one who actually represents 'Nayi Soch', he is the first hero to keep his mothers name as his surname. When was the last show which had a male protagonist who was such a feminist? Like NEVER! He continuously encouraged women around him to fight for themselves. Anyone here on this forum able to give me a character who has had such ideals in a Hindi tv serial ever? Even movies?


NO-ONE CAN FIGHT the above!! I would love to see who anyone who could negate this.


VIVIDHA - To me she started out quite ordinary and we have seen bubbly heroines with that inner strength. What makes her stand out though is her unflinching devotion towards her true love, Atharv. There's one side of her which has the typical Indian tv bahu syndrome which feels guilt and obligation towards her in-laws but she is THE MOST bold and daring heroine to be presented in that she continues loving the guy who she always has loved. She has NOT compromised on her emotions hence making her controversial but it's still very NEW & UNSEEN on Indian TV. That's why she keeps bothering a certain section of viewers because she isn't doing what she's 'expected to'.


RAVISH - I don't know?! Lol. I guess he's nice enough to witness his wife look after her love. But then again his character has a lot of resemblance to characters I've seen before...I can list many!
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
If u ask me its neither ravish nor vividha but its atharv sujatha who is nayi soch..
Kavithaa83 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Who ask vividha to marry ravish. It's her own decision so she have to face the consequences. Her ma ask her to step out but whatever the blah blah reason she did it with selfish. How can she be a nayi soch. Only ravish is nayi soch even he remove mangalsutra but y did she put it again. He said he give freedom to her and and her soul from the mangalsutra. I think u have to watch the serial again... The one who fights all the barriers and to think good for all is called nayi soch then surely ravish is nayi soch.
Srilathakoneti thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
For me Atharv Sujatha is nayi soch.now every one follow Thier mother's name but atharv is the trend setter for nayi soch.
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Kavithaa83

Who ask vividha to marry ravish. It's her own decision so she have to face the consequences. Her ma ask her to step out but whatever the blah blah reason she did it with selfish. How can she be a nayi soch. Only ravish is nayi soch even he remove mangalsutra but y did she put it again. He said he give freedom to her and and her soul from the mangalsutra. I think u have to watch the serial again... The one who fights all the barriers and to think good for all is called nayi soch then surely ravish is nayi soch.

Oops.. its ravish who asked vividha to retain mangalsutra till he breaks d news to suman..
Vashisht family is not even remotely close to what u can call nayi soch
teribts7 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
OMG finally someone who has the same thinking as me.

Nayi soch is vividha by breaking her marriage and going back to the person who she has always dreamed of being her husband. By doing this she breaks all the Indian tv bahu barriers that are created by Indian society and TRPS. In terms of the lead has to adapt to the changes as that what "fate wanted" and that going back to her boyfriend is immoral BS. Because everyone forced or against your will marriage tend to be "true love" in all Indian shows. However, nahi soch is breaking these standards set by people because that doesn't happen in real life.

Atharv is also Nahi soch because he would be making all efforts to gain vividha back by his promises jointly made by the pair. If vividha falls for ravish then what is nahi soch about this story??? That would be totally bullshit because nothing about the show is nahi soch as everyone knows what happens next.
Ravish would be nahi soch if he divorces vividha and marries someone else.
Edited by kompass - 9 years ago
jonjimmy thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Di

Originally posted by: Kavithaa83

Who ask vividha to marry ravish. It's her own decision so she have to face the consequences. Her ma ask her to step out but whatever the blah blah reason she did it with selfish. How can she be a nayi soch. Only ravish is nayi soch even he remove mangalsutra but y did she put it again. He said he give freedom to her and and her soul from the mangalsutra. I think u have to watch the serial again... The one who fights all the barriers and to think good for all is called nayi soch then surely ravish is nayi soch.

yes she should have valued complete strangers feelings over her lovers life.Also she should not feel guilty for the one whose feelings she hurt.She should not have helped him at least once for freeing her from a mockery of marriage. And the old values should only be promoted,since old is gold and there is no space for new idea's or views
Edited by jonjimmy - 9 years ago
Africanqueenkel thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
I would say vivi , but whispa is the person that can do that argument well ... I support her and she is IT for me. but I don't have it I me to explain because , its obvious , and I get angry when people , take away a persons free will and will to live for their own biased views...

So Atharva sujata and anyone who fights this is just 😕
Edited by Africanqueenkel - 9 years ago
mcdreamy. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Your post is so on point! The thing is that a certain set of people will completely overlook the logical point you mentioned and will go on the same rant that Vividha was not forced into the marriage solely cos they cannot differentiate between a character and their fave actor LOL!

Remember that scene when that guy was teasing Vividha in the market and Atharv was watching, I thought it would go the same typical way and Atharv would beat the crap outta him, but it was a surprise when the complete opposite happened and Atharv pushed Vividha to stand up for herself and defend herself instead of waiting for a man to save her! THAT was nayi soch for me and Atharv Sujata is the nayi soch.

Honestly, when I saw just the precap of Ravish taking Vividha's manglasutra of, I was quite impressed only to laugh at myseld seconds later when he told her to keep the facade up for his mother 😆 where is the nayi soch in that?
Edited by mcdreamy. - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".