Would you be able to tell your husband? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.3k

Users

15

Likes

98

Frequent Posters

faryal-malik thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
first and foremost Vividha situation is not equal to those real girls who really have no way out and have to marry Vividha had a way out she could reveal the truth to vashists on wedding day itself The tandav she was doing againt her father threatening him she should have done that to reveal his truth but of course she would be sensible , sensitive and strong woman only then she would have done that but she is insensitive , dumb woman who did not think about this
secondly even if she couldn't but when you have mature and understanding husband who on first night itself showed what a gentleman he is who did not celebrated force himself on her , he did not even sleep on same bed with her why not tell him the truth ? He again and again asked her seeing her sad face what is the issue but she refused to tell him .Many of those real life victim of honor killing girls are not blessed to have a gentleman like Ravish as their husband Most of victim girls whose cases have come forward husbands are brutes , mcp types but Ravish is not this type so and vividha knew that clearly so why she took so long to tell him the truth and today she told him after seeing Atharv and his condition Its no gutsy work by her but yes if she would have done that on wedding day itself she would be really STRONG woman or chalo i would have even appreciated her if she would have done immediately because it was important , very important to tell him but naa she kept on delaying and before she told Ravish the truth he had already gave her choice Make up your mind , make a decision and then tell me i will accept your whatever decision and she really needed to see Atharv in mental state to make up her mind otherwise ?

she deserves no applause in my eyes
13thwish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Personally, I have very strong views regarding marriage, so it's kinda hard for me to picture myself being in a forced one. 😆
That said, if I ever were in such a situation, I would not have made a lot of the choices Vivi made. For instance, I would have proactively looked for Atharv instead of relying on someone as unreliable as Uma. After that, my big priority woulda been to become financially independent, so that my option of walking out remained viable.
Regarding the telling part, I frankly admit that I would be very selfish, bide my time, and only tell when I was certain of my lover's and my own safety (because obviously that would remain my first priority). Survival n all that.

But yes, similar to Vivi, I would also return niceness with niceness in the meantime.

I would like to point out here, that in real life, it is unlikely that my "husband" would fall in love with me (no matter how nice I am) without sharing a single meaningful conversation. That is so not how these things work. Even people with crazy amounts of attraction take ages to reach the love stage. Who the hell is gonna fall for a frigid, cold-shouldering wife? They would be an idiot if they do! 😆

With regard to the antagonism toward Vivi, dude it's mainly because of her (non)-reaction toward R. They expected to feel conflicted and really struggle with her choice. I mean how could she not melt after spending so much time in the company of His Awesomeness.
Instead, her clarity has people shook.

I think we (the people who actually know and love Vivi) are only ones unsurprised by this turn of events because she always had mental clarity, but the CVs just weren't letting her act on it, so it didn't seem like much. 😛😆
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: faryal-malik

first and foremost Vividha situation is not equal to those real girls who really have no way out and have to marry Vividha had a way out she could reveal the truth to vashists on wedding day itself The tandav she was doing againt her father threatening him she should have done that to reveal his truth but of course she would be sensible , sensitive and strong woman only then she would have done that but she is insensitive , dumb woman who did not think about this

secondly even if she couldn't but when you have mature and understanding husband who on first night itself showed what a gentleman he is who did not celebrated force himself on her , he did not even sleep on same bed with her why not tell him the truth ? He again and again asked her seeing her sad face what is the issue but she refused to tell him .Many of those real life victim of honor killing girls are not blessed to have a gentleman like Ravish as their husband Most of victim girls whose cases have come forward husbands are brutes , mcp types but Ravish is not this type so and vividha knew that clearly so why she took so long to tell him the truth and today she told him after seeing Atharv and his condition Its no gutsy work by her but yes if she would have done that on wedding day itself she would be really STRONG woman or chalo i would have even appreciated her if she would have done immediately because it was important , very important to tell him but naa she kept on delaying and before she told Ravish the truth he had already gave her choice Make up your mind , make a decision and then tell me i will accept your whatever decision and she really needed to see Atharv in mental state to make up her mind otherwise ?

she deserves no applause in my eyes




How can you be so sure these common women haven't got good husbands like Ravish? How can you guarantee they're all abusive? You have stats?

She could've told Ravish on the wedding night but who was he? A stranger. Who bloody goes and tells such information to a stranger? When they started having a good equation, BOTH didn't hear each other out and your Ravish actually remembered those moments when she tried to say something. So why are you not seeing that?

I can still bet that if you were in her position, your mind would be lost completely on whom to trust! You wouldn't tell your husband 😆 KUCH BHI na?
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: 13thwish

Personally, I have very strong views regarding marriage, so it's kinda hard for me to picture myself being in a forced one.😆

That said, if I ever were in such a situation, I would not have made a lot of the choices Vivi made. For instance, I would have proactively looked for Atharv instead of relying on someone as unreliable as Uma. After that, my big priority woulda been to become financially independent, so that my option of walking out remained viable.
Regarding the telling part, I frankly admit that I would be very selfish, bide my time, and only tell when I was certain of my lover's and my own safety (because obviously that would remain my first priority). Survival n all that.

But yes, similar to Vivi, I would also return niceness with niceness in the meantime.

I would like to point out here, that in real life, it is unlikely that my "husband" would fall in love with me (no matter how nice I am) without sharing a single meaningful conversation. That is so not how these things work. Even people with crazy amounts of attraction take ages to reach the love stage. Who the hell is gonna fall for a frigid, cold-shouldering wife? They would be an idiot if they do!😆

With regard to the antagonism toward Vivi, dude it's mainly because of her (non)-reaction toward R. They expected to feel conflicted and really struggle with her choice. I mean how could she not melt after spending so much time in the company of His Awesomeness.
Instead, her clarity has people shook.

I think we (the people who actually know and love Vivi) are only ones unsurprised by this turn of events because she always had mental clarity, but the CVs just weren't letting her act on it, so it didn't seem like much.😛😆




Oh I agree, I would've taken different actions to...but that's me. I compare Vividha to those other women because Ajmer is a small town and such incidents happen in small towns. How easy is it to tell your in laws the truth? Yet she did after a month or so.

Her clarity is what bothers them true! She doesn't FLINCH or feel guilt for loving Atharv, she's proud of her love, her choice. She's guilty for unintentionally hurting others but when it comes to herself she KNOWS what she wants and that has hurt a lot of people today :) Wait, she hurts them in different ways everyday!

LOL. I know right @'him falling in love with Vividha the robot. Meh! Has he seen the real her? kaha...kaise pyar hua beta?
Khushi.... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Vividha's situation is so complicated.
For every argument for, there might be an argument against.

I always wanted Vividha to say the truth from the beginning, at least once she had started to trust Ravish. Vividha didn't want to move on from Atharva, she had no intention of trying to accept Ravish as her husband, and I agree with that, as no woman should be forced into marriage. But for that same reason I thought she should tell Ravish the truth, for her own sake and Ravish's sake. To me that would've shown how strong Vividha was, and also save Ravish some pain.

But then there's the point she was scared if the marriage broke Kailash would go after Atharva again and try to kill him, and so didn't tell Ravish the truth. Yes everyone will say that is wrong, that she shouldn't use Ravish, but the counter argument is do you let someone you love die? Also could she trust Ravish, she blindly trusted her father all these years, and he was the one who ruined her life, so how can she fully trust Ravish?
In the end Vividha had the intention of telling Ravish the truth earlier on and I wish she did because I do feel sorry for Ravish and he has fallen for her.

The situation is clearly so complex that I think everyone will have different opinions.

As for real life situations, I would not expect a woman to speak up. Can you imagine a woman who has just witnessed an attempted honour killing of the love of her life be brave enough to speak up? That is not a realty. Often these women are extremely vulnerable and afraid for their lives and the lives of others, and have nowhere to turn to for help. They are not cheap. Loving someone does not make you cheap.

991876 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: faryal-malik

first and foremost Vividha situation is not equal to those real girls who really have no way out and have to marry Vividha had a way out she could reveal the truth to vashists on wedding day itself The tandav she was doing againt her father threatening him she should have done that to reveal his truth but of course she would be sensible , sensitive and strong woman only then she would have done that but she is insensitive , dumb woman who did not think about this

secondly even if she couldn't but when you have mature and understanding husband who on first night itself showed what a gentleman he is who did not celebrated force himself on her , he did not even sleep on same bed with her why not tell him the truth ? He again and again asked her seeing her sad face what is the issue but she refused to tell him .Many of those real life victim of honor killing girls are not blessed to have a gentleman like Ravish as their husband Most of victim girls whose cases have come forward husbands are brutes , mcp types but Ravish is not this type so and vividha knew that clearly so why she took so long to tell him the truth and today she told him after seeing Atharv and his condition Its no gutsy work by her but yes if she would have done that on wedding day itself she would be really STRONG woman or chalo i would have even appreciated her if she would have done immediately because it was important , very important to tell him but naa she kept on delaying and before she told Ravish the truth he had already gave her choice Make up your mind , make a decision and then tell me i will accept your whatever decision and she really needed to see Atharv in mental state to make up her mind otherwise ?

she deserves no applause in my eyes


You think just because he didn't force himself on her he's a gentleman? Wow here's stupid me thinking not raping people is just the humane thing to do and not being a savage predator. It's astonishing that people can applaud men and give them a pat on the back for doing what any normal person should do i.e. not rape women. What a world we live in.
Edited by burnedlace - 9 years ago
vspdandeli thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

I would never be able to confide to a person whom i just met in the marriage mantap about my past immediately. That will have to wait until i get some sense to his judgemental ability (being nice and courteous does not necessarily mean the person can be trusted).
I am disappointed with the shows writing that failed to delve much into Vividha's thoughts and emotions after marriage. Mostly these are left to viewers imagination and Vividha has been bearing the brunt of it on the forum.

I am a silent reader on this forum and do not agree entirely with all the views put forth about Vividha, Atharva and Ravish. But i feel for Vividha more than i feel for the men. For her age (21 ?) and who was born with a silver spoon, she has seen/borne much for a lifetime and i wouldn't judge her so soon for her impulsive streak and immaturity in some of her actions. Yes she is not perfect, but that's what makes her character as possibly close to real life. Most girls in smaller cities are married off at a young age and everyone has their share of journey to mature into their role and relationships...some get there sooner, some take longer. And like you have said, i fail to understand why is it wrong if women along the way learn to think for themselves ?

Vividha's plight reminds me of another show Saraswatichandra, where in the leading lady Kumud mostly bore the brunt of the forum for readily marrying to another person when the leading man Saras impulsively called off the wedding. It is mostly the woman who is labelled as being at fault.
(But unlike Vividha, Kumud was older and mature plus the writing was not as patchy as this show at least the first few months after marriage).

monu_tan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
Its very difficult to do what Vv did yesterday. A woman being loud and clear of her choices is something unheard of. Point to be noted here is that Vv never accepted Ravish as her husband. She was even forced to put on the mangalsutra sindoor but She was already fighting it out in her space with Ravish. Ravish already knew he cant touch her, he was a friend to her. Marriage is not a mere mangalsutra sindoor artifact? Marriage is mutual acceptance and respect of the relationship. There was no acceptance on Vv's end and glad she voiced it very well. If a man doesnt accept his marriage he can voice it but a woman should not. A man can dump a woman but a woman should not, why?
InsaneDivine thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Since u all hav put forward almost everything, I will just copy, paste .. 😆 😆

Personally, I have very strong views regarding marriage, so it's kinda hard for me to picture myself being in a forced one. 😆
That said, if I ever were in such a situation, I would not have made a lot of the choices Vivi made. For instance, I would have proactively looked for Atharv instead of relying on someone as unreliable as Uma. After that, my big priority woulda been to become financially independent, so that my option of walking out remained viable.
Regarding the telling part, I frankly admit that I would be very selfish, bide my time, and only tell when I was certain of my lover's and my own safety (because obviously that would remain my first priority). Survival n all that.

But yes, similar to Vivi, I would also return niceness with niceness in the meantime.



As for real life situations, I would not expect a woman to speak up. Can you imagine a woman who has just witnessed an attempted honour killing of the love of her life be brave enough to speak up? That is not a realty. Often these women are extremely vulnerable and afraid for their lives and the lives of others, and have nowhere to turn to for help. They are not cheap. Loving someone does not make you cheap.


I compare Vividha to those other women because Ajmer is a small town and such incidents happen in small towns.

Agree !! Vividha was not even let complete her graduation.. Personally I would have take some actions against KK and ankit and wud have felt happier had the shown some legal entanglements than filling the episodes with Shraps and apshaguns...


I would never be able to confide to a person whom i just met in the marriage mantap about my past immediately. That will have to wait until i get some sense to his judgemental ability (being nice and courteous does not necessarily mean the person can be trusted).

I am disappointed with the shows writing that failed to delve much into Vividha's thoughts and emotions after marriage. Mostly these are left to viewers imagination and Vividha has been bearing the brunt of it on the forum.

But i feel for Vividha more than i feel for the men. For her age (21 ?) and who was born with a silver spoon, she has seen/borne much for a lifetime and i wouldn't judge her so soon for her impulsive streak and immaturity in some of her actions. Yes she is not perfect, but that's what makes her character as possibly close to real life. Most girls in smaller cities are married off at a young age and everyone has their share of journey to mature into their role and relationships...some get there sooner, some take longer. And like you have said, i fail to understand why is it wrong if women along the way learn to think for themselves ?

I agree with u..It could have been better... Vividha could have worked smarter, faster and better... I wished for a more intellectual Vividha who could continuously think and equally execute her thinking to reality... However, I still appreciate a change even if it is little... I am glad that the PH tried .. They tried to give her a choice and she stood by it ...
😊 😊 😊 😊


Her decision will definitely disappoint Ravish's loved ones nd that's sad but still some decisions have to be taken irrespective of of whom u would end up hurting... A person who is not happy within himself/herself can never ever spread happiness among the people within his / her sphere... For that u have to be first peaceful, happy and satisfied within urself...
Edited by .life_is_fun. - 9 years ago
InsaneDivine thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
here's stupid me thinking not raping people is just the humane thing to do and not being a savage predator.

And I agree again.. 😆 Kindness and Humanity should always be a natural way of living ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".