Raglak's n Swasan's ethical delimma - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.4k

Users

7

Likes

41

Frequent Posters

tiny15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: luvakanksha

I don't think it's so easy, swara has the worst case scenario. She has to take a stand with either ragini or sanskar n as I mentioned no one is wrong or right here all of them are facing ethical dilemma which means a complex situation that often involves an apparent mental conflict between moral value, in which to obey one moral value may be u would have to give up another moral value.

i agree & i also meant that but i m saying she knows sanky did it 4 laksh's well being so she will understand him & support him wen laksh will b against sanky.tho it"ll b difficult 4 her but she will b on sanky's side.
StarySKY thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: luvakanksha

See no one is right or wrong here the problem is that the situation is horrible and different people handle horrible situations differently.
Lakshay's problem has been his impulsiveness he is bad at handling critical situations, remember how he dealt with ragini kidnapped her tried to kill and when she became malkin he physically used her. Also when he thought swara stood him up in the wedding he ran and got married to ragini and then when he married Kavya he blamed his family for ragini being in his life. So that's his nature and he is exactly doing what his nature demands, he wants fast results desperately without the struggle.
Well sanskar is just being the big brother he did what he had to do, he had no choice.
Ragini well she has her first love doing something illegal for his ma papa, she is a fix. Ragini understands lakshay's vulnerability actually everyone does but u know ragini she thinks nothing when it comes to lakshay she can do any thing for him
Swara well she has to stand firmly with sanskar or Ragini, n her dilemma is that fortunately or unfortunately she could understand both of them.


I totally agree with you ..

As I said at the beginning ..
"It always hard to choose which side you will stand especially if been neutral is not an option .. and the hardest when it about the people you love "
All the 4 will have choose side .. it is not about right or wrong ..
All will react in their own way ..
As I siad it will lead to a [ civil war ] which will end in a destruction ..
Nupur_5 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
Actually it's a time where Swara-Sanskaar & Ragini-Laksh are in huge dilemma!
So here is my take & what I feel:
Sanskaar - According to me, Sanskaar is absolutely right in his place & whatever he did was right not only as a responsible, caring elder brother but also as a human as that was the right thing to do!
And he had no other way! He spoke with Lucky, tried so hard to make him understand & bring him in right path Bt Laksh didn't listen, and moreover he vowed to walk in wrong path afterwards! So Sanskaar had to take a drastic step for Laksh's own benefit! He tried to settle it by talking & tried to make him understand but it didn't do any good as Laksh, impulsive & immature as ever, didn't pay heed and Sanskaar had to send him jail. And he only wanted Laksh being in jail for only one night without any case filled, or beaten up bt AdRi thanks to Dadi filled case & make him beaten and that's not Sanskaar's fault! So Sanskaar is right as he can't let his brother to dig a deeper hole for himself bcoz as a caring & responsible elder brother he cares for his brother!
Swara - If anyone is in huge dilemma, it's actually Swara! She have to & I'm sure will support Sanskaar not only bcoz he is her husband bt also bcoz he is right & he had no other way! Bt at the same time she has responsibility towards her sister to make her understand & she cares for her sis as well. So biggest dilemma is for Swara! I think she will support Sanskaar & will try to make Ragini understand! She will play the role of a catalyst!
Laksh - I understand his POV, his depression, aggression! Bt I don't support his actions! I know every person deals with problems different way & react different way as well bt that doesn't mean he will deal with problems with the support of wrong & illegal way! Bcoz that's not a way in the first place! So I can't give a benefit of doubt to him bcoz his doings & actions invited this things! Even Sanskaar didn't get him arrested & AdRi made him beaten, in future he would have got into big problems! He would have fall in deeper hole from where he would have no way out! As Sanskaar rightly said, it's easy to way in bt no way out!
And he turned into a deaf & decided not to pay a heed to his family's words & decided to continue doing illegal things! As I said, I understand his situation but that doesn't mean you will do wrong things!
YOU CAN'T DO SOMETHING RIGHT BY DOING WRONG!
Then what will be the difference between AdRi & Laksh? Bcoz if Laksh is doing something wrong for his parents sake then AdRi also doing lots of heinous things for their own sake & benefit!?
No matter how good or justifiable your reason is a wrong is wrong! And I would have given Laksh some sympathy if he tried a better & right path before going wrong at the first place bt no, he didn't even tried!
Ragini - I don't support Laksh or neither I sympathize with him Bt still I understand him & his situation! Bt if I don't understand anyone that is Ragini! Why she is in dilemma? Being a wife she should make Laksh understand! Why she is supporting him?
I was so shocked yesterday bcoz it was her who doubted Laksh behavior at the first place & she was so worried thinking what if her LakshJi choose a wrong path? Bt yesterday she forbade everyone to ask Laksh anything & trusted him blindly that too immediately when Laksh's reasons were not convincing! No I understand & know that she loves Laksh like obsessively bt she could have said that let Laksh rest & question him later! Bt she just got furious when others tried to inquire him!
And after knowing the truth, she should make Laksh understand for his own betterment! And if he don't listen then she should use his love for her & her love for him to stop him! Bt she is supporting him & justifying his actions!? What the hell!?
Someone were saying that she loves Laksh obsessively that's why supporting him - Bt this also don't make any sense! Bcoz as she loves him & he is her obsession, she should refrain him for his own betterment! He will face more problems & grave dangers if he continues! So I expected her not to stand against him bt stand against his doings! Bt she disappointed me ONCE AGAIN!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".