Stop ruining the show CVs - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2k

Users

11

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Thanks for being truly sensible and upright in posting the facts.
Just today I commented not to make Supriyaji's Charecter a typical Saas type Charecter. She deserves the best. The writers are not doing justice either to Shaheer or to. Supriyaji..
Way back I questioned the writers why they are deviating from the initial promos which held great promise . Quite disappointed with the way Iswari's Charecter is written.
Again thanks for this post.Good to come across sensible writers like you.
rogerrocks thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Sruji1

Well said. I love dev sona both. But I think to show sona a strong character they are degrading dev character. If they want to balance both characters and people feel both for them and felt their pain they can show that dev and sona mutually talking and when ishwari is not happy with their relation so they will give time to her adjust in the new relation until dev will make ishwari understand and make her trust that dev is always her son and she is always is first priority. They can Show that with out butchering dev character but no they went the same famous Indian TV shows formula glorify female lead and butcher male lead. And ishwari character she is supposed to be a mother who is insecure of her son and try to adjust when her son fallen in love and cope up with the new development in her sons life. But what we are seeing a mother who can't see her son happiness and made her some kind of psycho. And sona I can understand her disappoint and hurt but I don't understand what she expect to dev do when his mother attempt suicide. She knows he loves her and because of his mother he make the decision to break up. I know it's wrong but I think at least sona will understand dev and why he did it. Seriously I lost the connection to these three characters. When break up happened people supposed to be feel bad for them and want they will stand for each other and make ishwari understand their love. Not people thinking it's better sona find another guy and dev left alone. If this show about sona strong women after a bad break up finding a perfect guy and perfect sasural then they are going right way. But if this show about dev balancing his relation between his mom and sona, ishwari journey about mother to mother In law. Sona how she balance her relation between dev and ishwari. Then they need to get their brain and together and find a track where people will connect with three characters.


I really din't intend to justify Dev's decision by means of this post..We probably can understand his pain given how we know he really really loves his mom it doesn't change the fact that he is being an ass to Sonakshi..If Dev is hell bent on getting his mom's approval, he should have waited for it and then proposed to Sonakshi or any girl for that matter. Unless you are confident you'l stand by your words (even if it means you'l go against your mom or try everything in your power to convince her), you have no right playing with a girl's life and making ridiculous promises..My issue is entirely different..IMO, they are making Dev into a really weak character who lacks conviction..And I have no words for Ishwari..That woman disturbs me..So i have problems with the writing cos am unable to relate to the story or the characters..I don't really intend to justify their actions 😆
randomramblings thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
Totally agree with the post. IF this show is about how an insecure mother learns her lessons and turns into a better MIL, how a son comes out of his "maa is my everything" to acknowledging the face that " his spouse" is an equally important lady in his life and about how a DIL helps both these people grow emotionally and in the process, betters herself as a person, then the current track is NOWHERE on these lines. CV's please stick to your original storyline and dont change the story due to either TRP or any other factors. its time that we see realistic shows and not hunky dory images where all ends well or even a show where the leads get to marry each other even after each of them marrying 2 or 3 three different people !!!!!
My POV on the characters and how i expected them to be based on the initial promos.

1. DEV - today we get to see a hopeless Dev who makes all the OTT promises to his GF and yet when he sees everyone hurting her emotions , he never for once raises as much as an eyebrow over it. come on man, agree that MAA is your world and as said so often by you, you really cant see anything else when it is about her in question. May be i can relate to certain extent that all your senses are lost out of the window when it is something concerning her and knowing that she tried to end her life because she is not able to come to terms with your relationship with sonakshi, you impulsively take the decision to break your relationship... I am waiting to see how you break the news to sona before i can judge you on this. I have seen these kind of situations in real life where the parents try the emotional blackmail and make you feel guilty to the extent that you lose all your senses and end up making grave mistakes and yet neither party stands by you and ultimately you are only one at loss. i wish to see Dev making a comeback after the breakup, he trying to get his hold and an emotionally stronger Dev who realises that every relation has its space and no relation is above another especially between the spouse vs mother. I want dev to make all efforts in wooing back his lady love, leaving no stone unturned.. i want him to see the colours in other relations also ( say sibling etc) and accept that the fact that his mom is "human" and not "GOD"

2. Sona - i understand that she want to be accepted whole heartedly and expects equal partnership in a relationship. between Dev and Sona, its always sona who exhibited hert emotions more freely , be it as a free spirited girl, a strong woman or a lady hopelessly in love. . But why suddenly when someone is treating her nastily, she put up a brave face and make it look like everything is under control!!!!
and coming to DEV, she is aware of his shortcoming, his vulnerabilities and its she and only she who has seen the shades in him that are not shown even to his "mother". in that perspective when he decided to break up , does Soan try to open up a communication with him??? see what he is going through... i agree she will be totally shattered hearing him say about the breakup and the agony that come with it will cloud her for a few days. but remember she are the only " friend" with whom he shared his deepest worries, would she as a friend not even think about his mental state when he said those words. from the previous episodes it was she who said if you seriously love a person, you would not mind waiting for him for eternity during natasha incident. I want to see this character as a strong woman who retains her identity and in the process helps DEV to get a spine. as said during his confession " Dev wants to become a better person because of Sona" I really want to see Sona becoming his lighthouse and guiding him on the emotional front. he needs it badly . Last but not least, when we accept a person, its along with his falsies. during this acceptance stage, its we who get burnt and bruised.

3. Eshwari - she is no doubt a very possessive mother who did not share her son even with her own daughters. its not that she does not want her son to be happy . her biggest fear is that she will be replaced by Sona in her son's life. may be initially she will be happy with the breakup that her son chose her over sona, but during the phase of breakup , i want her to realise that her son is living but not alive. the " SPARK " in him is gone. he becomes a zinda laash ( sorry i cannot find a right term in english for this) . it becomes the turning point for her to start an introspective journey from where she emerges as a better person realizing that relationship dont compete with each other , rather every new relationship compliments the other and culminates into the rainbow of colours in our lives.

4. Neha- i always felt this character will be the catalyst in Eshwari's realizations. she with her indepth insight into her mother is the only person who can see beyond her external facade. its more like she reads ishwari's mind. there is a lot of hope for this character as a sibling who lived through the worst crisis of the family. as dev often said, only he and neha are aware of the circumstances that made the Dixits to be what they are today. She surely will have a bigger role to play during the breakup . i think with her character, we get to see the actual storyline of a mil- son -dil journey as promised by Yash patnaik during his interview.


sorry for a long post, but this is what i expect from a show that has the guts to come out of the box and embark on realistic storyline.
Sruji1 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: rogerrocks



I really din't intend to justify Dev's decision by means of this post..We probably can understand his pain given how we know he really really loves his mom it doesn't change the fact that he is being an ass to Sonakshi..If Dev is hell bent on getting his mom's approval, he should have waited for it and then proposed to Sonakshi or any girl for that matter. Unless you are confident you'l stand by your words (even if it means you'l go against your mom or try everything in your power to convince her), you have no right playing with a girl's life and making ridiculous promises..My issue is entirely different..IMO, they are making Dev into a really weak character who lacks conviction..And I have no words for Ishwari..That woman disturbs me..So i have problems with the writing cos am unable to relate to the story or the characters..I don't really intend to justify their actions😆

arey I am not justify dev ya ishwari actions 😆 I am saying if CVS want people to feel for all three characters then they need to do something. If they want people feel only for Sona then they are achieving it. I am also saying writers fault there is no consistency in characters.
rogerrocks thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: randomramblings

Totally agree with the post. IF this show is about how an insecure mother learns her lessons and turns into a better MIL, how a son comes out of his "maa is my everything" to acknowledging the face that " his spouse" is an equally important lady in his life and about how a DIL helps both these people grow emotionally and in the process, betters herself as a person, then the current track is NOWHERE on these lines. CV's please stick to your original storyline and dont change the story due to either TRP or any other factors. its time that we see realistic shows and not hunky dory images where all ends well or even a show where the leads get to marry each other even after each of them marrying 2 or 3 three different people !!!!!

My POV on the characters and how i expected them to be based on the initial promos.

1. DEV - today we get to see a hopeless Dev who makes all the OTT promises to his GF and yet when he sees everyone hurting her emotions , he never for once raises as much as an eyebrow over it. come on man, agree that MAA is your world and as said so often by you, you really cant see anything else when it is about her in question. May be i can relate to certain extent that all your senses are lost out of the window when it is something concerning her and knowing that she tried to end her life because she is not able to come to terms with your relationship with sonakshi, you impulsively take the decision to break your relationship... I am waiting to see how you break the news to sona before i can judge you on this. I have seen these kind of situations in real life where the parents try the emotional blackmail and make you feel guilty to the extent that you lose all your senses and end up making grave mistakes and yet neither party stands by you and ultimately you are only one at loss. i wish to see Dev making a comeback after the breakup, he trying to get his hold and an emotionally stronger Dev who realises that every relation has its space and no relation is above another especially between the spouse vs mother. I want dev to make all efforts in wooing back his lady love, leaving no stone unturned.. i want him to see the colours in other relations also ( say sibling etc) and accept that the fact that his mom is "human" and not "GOD"

2. Sona - i understand that she want to be accepted whole heartedly and expects equal partnership in a relationship. between Dev and Sona, its always sona who exhibited hert emotions more freely , be it as a free spirited girl, a strong woman or a lady hopelessly in love. . But why suddenly when someone is treating her nastily, she put up a brave face and make it look like everything is under control!!!!
and coming to DEV, she is aware of his shortcoming, his vulnerabilities and its she and only she who has seen the shades in him that are not shown even to his "mother". in that perspective when he decided to break up , does Soan try to open up a communication with him??? see what he is going through... i agree she will be totally shattered hearing him say about the breakup and the agony that come with it will cloud her for a few days. but remember she are the only " friend" with whom he shared his deepest worries, would she as a friend not even think about his mental state when he said those words. from the previous episodes it was she who said if you seriously love a person, you would not mind waiting for him for eternity during natasha incident. I want to see this character as a strong woman who retains her identity and in the process helps DEV to get a spine. as said during his confession " Dev wants to become a better person because of Sona" I really want to see Sona becoming his lighthouse and guiding him on the emotional front. he needs it badly . Last but not least, when we accept a person, its along with his falsies. during this acceptance stage, its we who get burnt and bruised.

3. Eshwari - she is no doubt a very possessive mother who did not share her son even with her own daughters. its not that she does not want her son to be happy . her biggest fear is that she will be replaced by Sona in her son's life. may be initially she will be happy with the breakup that her son chose her over sona, but during the phase of breakup , i want her to realise that her son is living but not alive. the " SPARK " in him is gone. he becomes a zinda laash ( sorry i cannot find a right term in english for this) . it becomes the turning point for her to start an introspective journey from where she emerges as a better person realizing that relationship dont compete with each other , rather every new relationship compliments the other and culminates into the rainbow of colours in our lives.

4. Neha- i always felt this character will be the catalyst in Eshwari's realizations. she with her indepth insight into her mother is the only person who can see beyond her external facade. its more like she reads ishwari's mind. there is a lot of hope for this character as a sibling who lived through the worst crisis of the family. as dev often said, only he and neha are aware of the circumstances that made the Dixits to be what they are today. She surely will have a bigger role to play during the breakup . i think with her character, we get to see the actual storyline of a mil- son -dil journey as promised by Yash patnaik during his interview.


sorry for a long post, but this is what i expect from a show that has the guts to come out of the box and embark on realistic storyline.


THIS..Its probably just me but am really not looking forward to Sonakshi screaming at Dev and Dev being tongue tied and acting like a bechari bahu in front of her as well as Ishwari..It does nothing for any of the characters..I'd rather they both move on then..I really cannot handle male leads who ruin things and then pull a Devdas..And am not sure i can handle Ishwari's disturbing behaviour anymore 😆 Oh and am probably the one of the few who absolutely hates jealousy tracks on Indian TV..Mainly because most writers have no idea how to go about it and ruin the characters further in the name of showing 'jealousy' and 'passion'..Oh well, i guess am just annoyed with the way this show is being written right now 😆
Edited by rogerrocks - 9 years ago
randomramblings thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
you are not the only one who hates jealousy track. personally its not always essential that a third angle is always needed to realize our own feelings for someone. ( unless of course we never acknowledged them).
In the case of both Dev and Sona, they are very well aware of each others feelings. they both made some promises to each other without even thinking . Being in love is between 2 individuals and marriage is between 2 families. these 2 look very same on the outset but they are poles apart. so far the track has been on point 1, where everything was between sona and dev. now comes the track where every individual of the family plays a role, be it eshwari, asha or bejoy. Eshwari's actions are not directly related to the relationship in itself but more towards the fact that she fears that her position will be snatched away. on the other hand asha and bejoy welcome the relationship but now when the relationship has to go through the roughest patch how accepting/forgiving can they be? will they let the love birds to fly , fall and then learn to soar????
in any relationship its for the 2 individuals to find their own rhythm, currently we are this stage where Dev and Sona need to find out their own rhythm. during this phase, they will have to face many obstacles, survive the worst turmoils to emerge victorious.
Introducing a third angle will totally propel the show in a different direction.
The story needs to be the journey of sona and Dev on how they better themselves as individuals and make their relationship stronger baring the harsh realities of life.
sajinifaby thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

I don't know if am the only one but the show has really gone for a toss the past few days..Why is every character being destroyed left, right and centre? 😕 What is up with glorifying the female lead at the cost of every other character on the show? If your concept was about a woman breaking free from a suffocating relationship and claustrophobic family, you are totally on the right path..But if you actually wanted to show a story where the viewers related to the 3 protagonists despite everything, you are failing big time..If I wanted to see a strong girl-blind mom-doormat son prototype, I have other options..From the initial promos, i assumed they'l deal with it in such a way that you feel for all the characters equally..Understand Dev's dilemma, Ishwari's insecurity and guilt and Sona's plight..I see none here..I only see an utterly selfish and psychotic mom, a doormat son who cannot stand up for himself and a girl who should be relieved about the break up rather than feel sorry for it..And am pretty sure thats not what the writers intend to show cos this dude requested the viewers to not judge Ishwari and understand her emotions 😆 If only you put in more efforts and wrote the characters with more sensitivity, you wouldn't be requesting the viewers to understand her..It would have happened on its own..The biggest failure of a writer is when you want ppl to sympathize with your characters yet you cant get them to feel even a tinge of emotion for them 😆 They probably used up all the sensitivity and creativity for the initial promos and the first 70 odd episodes cos i see none right now..Its easy to glorify one character and make you feel disgust for the rest..That happens in every saas bahu soap..Your talent lies in weaving a story where viewers relate to all 3 protagonists and understand why they took certain decisions..Unfortunately, this show has failed big time in that regard and now its only about how the female lead deserves better (which is the case with 99% of the shows on Indian TV)..Am sorry if am being harsh but Supriya deserves better..She is better than the rest of the cast combined and she is being reduced to play a character which has just become ridiculously uni-dimensional off late..


i only want to tell u... i got a husband like Dev n a MIL like Ishwari...
so am not sure if u feel, the CVs are not showing reality...
they are human although we treat our mothers equal to God..
they like controlling their children life n are utter failure as wife.. n mother.. forget MIL or grandmother...

this show is an eye opener... for many sons to understand their cunning mothers...and also help protect many of us DILs or those who gave up on love due parents ego...
Unfortunately, i had given up due to my parents...

today's line.. dont such parents have some responsibility to give their kids happiness.. and give respect to their love...
KambakthIshq thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
Ayyoo.. Have you seen today's segments?
Sona keeps checking the phone during her engagement ceremony.. In hope that her Prince Charming dev will come to her rescue and she can dump Ritwik at the alter (well..engagement 😆 )
So romantic yaa..
With this act, they are not even glorifying the FL 😆
I think they are buying some time to round back to the first promo. I'm just waiting to see what crap they are going to come up with to make the viewers sympathize with Ishwari and dev. Right now they both are acting insane.
KambakthIshq thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Shoot.., I just realized you posted this topic last week 😆
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
@rogerrocks
I am glad that this topic was opened. I posed some questions in both Annapquins post and Tito post S I will rephrase and post here.
When I signed up for this show I was looking to watch a show based on reality where the insecurities of a mother are dealt in a mature and classy way by two sorted individuals who fall in love. The way I interpreted or misinterpreted the promo was Sona gets upset at Dev for breaking up, then she realizes why with Dev help and both together understand the mom insecurity and though helpless work towards resolution even though the resolution part was not shown this is what I thought...now I gave different view...and this may turn out to be wrong too but here goes
Are they trying to show a girl fell in love with a man who made lofty promises but failed to keep them for he just refused to come out of his mothers thumb...all this Bhagwan crap I don't buy. Entered a sorted guy who seems pretty ordinary in looks I mean and forms support for the girl and slowly the girl realizes that there is more to love than fairy tales...in all this I don't know what is Dev role ..maybe to show you lose if you don't take ownership and Easwari maybe to realize when you hold something too strongly you tend to suffocate it...if they go this way in my opinion I do think it will be pathbreaking for Tv

Edited by gemini54 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".