MADHYAMAVATHI thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
In 18th August episode, Gopi confronts Meera and asks her how could she shoot her own sister. If anything happens to Vidya she will disown Meera.

Didn't Gopi kill Radha, her own sister. OK Radha may have been a criminal.

Wouldn't Gopi's mother also have felt the same towards Gopi when she killed Radha.

Somehow I was not convinced Gopi confronting Meera this way. There was no authenticity.

If Meera had asked Gopi at that point as to how she could kill her own sister so brutally what would be Gopi's answer.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

2.8k

Users

4

Likes

23

Frequent Posters

kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Even I felt the same when I watched this episode. The worst thing is that nobody made an effort to stop Gopi from killing Radha. When she was about to strangle Gaura, ahem stopped her giving her his mom's kasam. He could have done the same even at that time.
Radha had tortured the Modi family a lot. She had kept Meera away from the family. Gopi was away from the family for 8 long years. She left the house at the state of her 2nd pregnancy. During that time any woman will be needing her loved ones be around her especially her MIL & husband or even her own mother.

Radha was about to kill Gopi & had almost done that and she was about to kill her own daughter. Killing for self defence or for protecting others is always exempted.

But what I didn't like in this scene is that she didn't listen to what Meera has to say. I felt bad for Meera at that time. Usually, Meera does not even retaliate when she is in trouble.
MADHYAMAVATHI thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
More than Radha, Gopi and her family suffered because of her killing Radha.

Radha might have lost her life but Gopi's and her family's life had never been the same again.

They suffered the most.
Had Gopi not killed Radha she would not have gone to jail, Ahem would not leave the family and there would be no Mansi in their life.
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Radha & suffer? I would by no means say that she suffered except in the case where Rashi treated her like a servant & kindled with her emotions. No one was ready to listen what she wanted to say. No one was ready to hear what Rashi did to her. Although Madhu heard it from her mouth, she did not take action against Urshi. That was the only time I felt bad for Radha.
Ahem had every right to be upset with Gopi for such an act & for giving her kasam that no one should meet her during her term but leaving the house is not a solution.

After getting Rashi Jr. safely, they could have handed Radha to the cops. The CV's wrote a very bad story line.
xLavenderx thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Both the cases are different they cant be compared...radha was a criminal...madhu knew it that one day she will lost her daughter due to her bad deeds but meera is not a criminal...she was just blackmailed
Edited by Aanahat - 8 years ago
MADHYAMAVATHI thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Aanahat

Both the cases are different they cant be compared...radha was a criminal...madhu knew it that one day she will lost her daughter due to her bad deeds but meera is not a criminal...she was just blackmailed



So treating your own sister and her daughter like servants is not criminal.

Getting someones signatures by fraud is not criminal.

Taking away your own sisters child and forcefully sending away a child from home is not criminal.

Meera is still a criminal may be of a different kind. And where was Meera blackmailed. She got tense only when she knew that Priyal was kidnapped. Even then she was strong enough not to come out .
coolhi1988 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Both d cases r diff..
comparing Gopi & meera is baseless...

coz Gopi killed Radha who had troubled a lot to her family...
done a lot more bad deeds...
& before killing radha, radha had tried to kill gopi...

But here... vidya had done nothing to spoil meera's life.. meera thought vidya is responsible for her state... meera herself took away vidya's daughter.. & gopi shouting at meera was absolutely correct..


madhu knew radha is bad..

gopi knows vidya is innocent ...

so hw can meera counter question gopi on this!!!!
MADHYAMAVATHI thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Both situations are different in the sense that the victim(Vidya) herself was shot at in the present case whereas in the case of Radha the victim(Gopi) was the one who killed.

I come from the point that Meera deserves no sympathy in the present case because She is like Radha.

But just the dialogue from Gopi that how could Meera have thought about killing her own sister is not apt coming from Gopi's mouth.

kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: MADHYAMAVATHI

Both situations are different in the sense that the victim(Vidya) herself was shot at in the present case whereas in the case of Radha the victim(Gopi) was the one who killed.

I come from the point that Meera deserves no sympathy in the present case because She is like Radha.

But just the dialogue from Gopi that how could Meera have thought about killing her own sister is not apt coming from Gopi's mouth.


Of course, that may not be apt but all the evidences are against Meera & any parent would react the same way in this situation. Even Meera called Gopi a monster & murderer after getting to know that she was in jail after killing Radha.

She was not even ready to believe when Kokila revealed the truth whereas Vidya, Sahir & Samar regretted. Even Jr. Rashi apologized to Gopi after knowing the full truth but Meera accepted Gopi as her mom only after she brought her home in a injured state.

We cannot compare Gopi's act with Meera's as Radha tried to kill Gopi & Jr. Rashi. Gopi killed Radha mainly to protect the family if not for herself & that is exempted.

Why Meera showed the gun to Vidya, threatening her that she will shoot her? Like Radha, she too trusts wrong persons.
xLavenderx thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: MADHYAMAVATHI



So treating your own sister and her daughter like servants is not criminal.

Getting someones signatures by fraud is not criminal.

Taking away your own sisters child and forcefully sending away a child from home is not criminal.

Meera is still a criminal may be of a different kind. And where was Meera blackmailed. She got tense only when she knew that Priyal was kidnapped. Even then she was strong enough not to come out .

I agree that these r criminal activities but meera was blackmailed in all these radha was not...radha sirf ek baar blackmail hui thi...she was not blackmailed again and again by someone...but meera is

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".