Suman Tiwari: The right in Wrong

SleepyPsycho thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
I had promised for an Analysis on Suman over the weekend but could not do it.Apologizing for it as I was not in a physical state to do that,I hurt my right hand and back again by falling in school so this bit of analysis will be short and not so in depth.

Suman Tiwari is a girl who keeps her love and self respect on two different pages. If she feels that her self respect is at stake or being degraded she wouldn't care about the love and stand for herself even if it takes her being rude to the person she loves the most. Her funda probably in life is You make yourself before some one else does.

Coming to the point where Suman Tiwari chooses the path of jealousy to get back Shravan is justified. Note that she doesn't know what Shravan feels for her yet and yes that's not her fault here. Just like Suman even Shravan has been giving her mixed signals,sometimes he is all helpful and on the the other side he pushes her away refusing to defend her.So when she notices one way where he gets affected,where she can get him to realize his love for her she grabs for it without looking at the other consequences that follows. Note again here that this girl here likes him for months now but has been caught within the chains of family and duty and could be freed could be returned to her home i. e. Him only of he realizes his love.
Note-SHE IS NOT AWARE.
We all say that Suman is a sketched realistically so common if you are ever fixed in a state like this or if you want to win someone who has some feelings for you won't you once use the path of jealousy?Be honest!
Though this path is not fully correct and fair but as they say 'Everything is fair in love and war'.

Last where we all are bit angry or confused as to why she accepted PCT from Aditya and not Shravan.
For this I am going to give you one question and then put out my view on it.
Go back to the time and see the way Shravan gives the PCT papers to Suman and compare it with the way Aditya does the same. You will get your answer here :)

Take in note yet again that Suman believed that it was Shravan Malhotra who had purposely destroyed her PCT and it was his father who had destroyed their relationship. And so when Shravan had decided to give it back,more apt words being throw it back at her face,she had refused and rightly stated that she wouldn't once take his 'ehsaan'.
Whereas Aditya had played with his words and had created the feel and understanding that it was because of her potential she was getting PCT back and not because of her vulnerability(which Shravan and Ramnath made her feel once)
And too all those who still have questions and confusions look back and notice how Suman had rejected Aditya's help just like she did with Shravan and how she had decided to leave PCT when she had known that it was Ramnath who was behind it. This clearly states on how she still had her self respect within her and how she still stood for her but then it was the sense of deservness she was given by Aditya that she accepted it.And also her thought about Shravan being behind all this like a silent helper because he was still bent on giving her PCT back and she had refused gave her another reason of accepting PCT back.

Suman Tiwari is no wrong,she is someone who does teh right but forgets to take in the notice about the consequences be it bad or good that comes along.

Nith I will be waiting for your view specially since it was you who had me writing this.
All your views are welcome.
Thank You.

-Mitali

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

3.1k

Users

13

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

zindgidilse thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Mitthu pls take care of yourself...don't ignore the pain of your injury nd its sideffects..


mitthu... pls take this hug for this analysis 🤗
You said it all...nothing biased...i love you dear ..you made my day...after long time i have seen a neutral post and thats yours👏
But i missed your long post.,though i can clearly see that this is not the half of what you writes..can i have a long sumo analysis after your reconvery.? Pls


I just wanted to say that both shraman are at fault . Neither of them is completely right nor of them completely wrong...shraman are rightly wrong (this statement i said in AT when i was dicussing it with ranjhu).

The much i said about you will be less at the end mitthu..truely ..
Edited by zindgidilse - 9 years ago
KostinsQueen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
RES
UNRES

Mittu ... can I come & give u a bones crushing hug ??
Seriously , u always make me wonder with your analysis , the way u understand the characters , so deeply & clearly is amazing .
Coming to the topic , nothing to add, u said it all.
Suman was & is like this from the start , no change in her , if she changes then it will be definitely not our Suman tiwarI.

Remember her dialogue at sangeeth Function hall , when Shravan asked her to shift venue to other hall , she denied it saying she can't compromise with her decision, but that was all to show him how stubborn she is and she wants him to accept her the way , but we know what's in her mind then ,
" Shravan thumhare liye main apni Jaan bhi dhe sakthi hoon , Kaash main thume apni MAZBOORI batha sakthi " which clearly says that Shravan holds very high in her heart.

But all thanks to Ramnath's deal & his brain washing sessions , that everything got backfired to her. Sigh, your baby is not bad but the way he uses his words makes him a manipulator .

I just loved this analysis, do write more but first take care of yourself .

Love
Suhasini
Edited by KostinsQueen - 9 years ago
SleepyPsycho thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: zindgidilse

Mitthu pls take care of yourself...don't ignore the pain of your injury nd its sideffects..


mitthu... pls take this hug for this analysis 🤗
You said it all...nothing biased...i love you dear ..you made my day...after long time i have seen a neutral post and thats yours👏
But i missed your long post.,though i can clearly see that this is not the half of what you writes..can i have a long sumo analysis after your reconvery.? Pls


I just wanted to say that both shraman are at fault . Neither of them is completely right nor of them completely wrong...shraman are rightly wrong (this statement i said in AT when i was dicussing it with ranjhu).

The much i said about you will be less at the end mitthu..truely ..


Awww Ritu 🤗
You made me smile.
Well how can one not be neutral? The show clearly conveys how both the characters have flaws being wrong yet right at the same time. No one is completely right nor completely wrong and as you said they are 'rightly wrong' I completely agree.
You have said the most apt word and said it all.

I cannot promise as such right now as I have exams coming up in September but I will try my best.

And your comment truly made me smile making me less cranky.
Thank You 😳
spshastr thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Mittu hope your hand is better..
Wonderful analysis👏

Suman TIwari allso has a big heart of Gold but she does impulsive things especially with Shravan.
I was watching some of the old episodes when her shaadi baat was happening and she did pretty much this to him.It back fired then as well😆 but the girl never learns

I also want to add that the self respect jaap has gone overboard recently . SHe never had that with Shravan (which he points out during the accident as well) but with the Ramnath episode she has been using that as her shield and her armor..
It went overboard because of Ramnaths games.

That said i am waiting for the love to win over self respect.😳

Great analysis and I love how you see both sides of the story😊
Both are flawed but adorable .. they are the two halves that make ONE .. Trully Ek Duje ke vaaste
Edited by spshastr - 9 years ago
nith125 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Res
Unres

First of all Mithali , thank you for such a lovely post 😊
It is a beautiful analysis of what Sumo is. She indeed keeps her love and self respect in separate pages but I differ a little on your opinion that she is willing to hurt the person she loves the most to keep her self respect. She is doing it for him, plain and simple.That is what Sumo is, she takes everything at face value. She does not think through. Sometimes I am surprised at how naive she actually is to how "matlabi" she gets portrayed as.

Let me explain what I think, going back to Ramnath. She had 2 choices, choose Shravan or choose money and she choose Shravan, I don't think it was about self respect at all. So what does one do when offered such a choice ? She could go to Shravan and would Shravan trust her about his father ? No way. The only choice left to her was to prove that she is worthy of Shravan's love by choosing him.
She is choosing him above all and will always do that.

Her going the jealousy route is again a testimony to how naive she is. Simple solution to a complex problem.
Make him jealous, get him to confess, end of story. Her charachter is as simple as Shravan's is complex.
Again accepting PCT from Adithya, she did no wrong. I agree the first time Shravan gave it to her, it was not the right way. Even when he called her up he was like his father will give them the land. For her accepting it means accepting that she is giving up Shravan, it is like accepting the cheque. So infact while Shravan thinks that she is rejecting what he is giving her, she is actually doing it for him. Another example is her not accepting the help from Adithya first time around simply because Shravan said so. For her he is more important than anything else. Even now before giving the papers to Adithya when Shravan asks her, he says "help kar doon".
Had he said Sumo, this is it, you are taking PCT, you can pay rent or something, she wouldn't have refused. She wants him to take that haq.
Adithya did it very well. I dont know if there are investors or not. Seedhi ungli se ghee nahi nikalta ho, to ungli tedi kar dena. I personally loathe him but his charachter is being played very well.

So in the end, I agree with you partially, she does value her self respect a lot but she values her love more than anything.

P.S : Please take care of your health !

Edited by nith125 - 9 years ago
SleepyPsycho thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: spshastr

Mittu hope your hand is better..

Wonderful analysis👏

Suman TIwari allso has a big heart of Gold but she does impulsive things especially with Shravan.
I was watching some of the old episodes when her shaadi baat was happening and she did pretty much this to him.It back fired then as well😆 but the girl never learns

I also want to add that the self respect jaap has gone overboard recently . SHe never had that with Shravan (which he points out during the accident as well) but with the Ramnath episode she has been using that as her shield and her armor..
It went overboard because of Ramnaths games.

That said i am waiting for the love to win over self respect.😳

Great analysis and I love how you see both sides of the story😊
Both are flawed but adorable .. they are the two halves that make ONE .. Trully Ek Duje ke vaaste

You said it all Agreed!
Ramu is one a**!
Thank You,hand is much better though my back is off completely!
Frosty_Moon thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
mittu get well soon dear..🤗
finally some neutral post on sumo..

she rejects on first place when adi says ramnath give him papers and she is ready to give that damn papers back to him but here the guy mr. adi aka chomu is so damn good with words full of sugar coats and our shraman lacks in this. (waise its not their fault they dont need any formalities) and she agree to take pct back

about jealousy i dont mind that coz sumo dont know shra love her and shra dont know she loves him so it was fun ..

sumo dont believe in proverbs..think before u speak here i say think before u do and she lacks in studies na so its not her fault😆
jokes apart like u said she never think about consequences and still think shra help her via adi and she forgets that shra is one who warn her about adi and he feels jealous when she take help from adi and still she thinks shra helps her via adi..this girl sometimes thinks too much woh bhi kuch bhi😆
shra comment her and then offer help.yeh banda bhi na.😆

its not shra or sumo its shraman who both are at fault..

dono hi pagal hai but i love my shraman❤️

meri pehle post hai jo itni lambhi hai..😆
Edited by _Eternity_ - 9 years ago
SleepyPsycho thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: KostinsQueen

RES

UNRES

Mittu ... can I come & give u a bones crushing hug ??
Seriously , u always make me wonder with your analysis , the way u understand the characters , so deeply & clearly is amazing .
Coming to the topic , nothing to add, u said it all.
Suman was & is like this from the start , no change in her , if she changes then it will be definitely not our Suman tiwarI.

Remember her dialogue at sangeeth Function hall , when Shravan asked her to shift venue to other hall , she denied it saying she can't compromise with her decision, but that was all to show him how stubborn she is and she wants him to accept her the way , but we know what's in her mind then ,
" Shravan thumhare liye main apni Jaan bhi dhe sakthi hoon , Kaash main thume apni MAZBOORI batha sakthi " which clearly says that Shravan holds very high in her heart.

But all thanks to Ramnath's deal & his brain washing sessions , that everything got backfired to her. Sigh, your baby is not bad but the way he uses his words makes him a manipulator .

I just loved this analysis, do write more but first take care of yourself .

Love
Suhasini

Hasuu I am always up for hugs.
🤗
Agreed to what you said here.This girl loves Shravan Malhotra to the core and holds him above anything but Ramnath and his manipulation on Shravan is affecting her causing her to walk the path she is not willing to.
Thank You ❤️
zindgidilse thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: SleepyPsycho


Awww Ritu 🤗
You made me smile.
Well how can one not be neutral? The show clearly conveys how both the characters have flaws being wrong yet right at the same time. No one is completely right nor completely wrong and as you said they are 'rightly wrong' I completely agree.
You have said the most apt word and said it all.

I cannot promise as such right now as I have exams coming up in September but I will try my best.

And your comment truly made me smile making me less cranky.
Thank You 😳

yes i agree both the characters hv flows..you will see one epi goes to sumo and later episode goes to shravan or vice versa...i mean they will show from both side of perspective..

Its no problem dear...xms are important.,all the best for your xms..
And sorry i forgot to tell you that your analysis on shravan was superb...i read it but i thought i didn't commented there 😆sorry about that but it was beautifully done analysis on shravan.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".