Thapki's character butchered

fan.matsh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Yes she used to keep secrets but she never uttered lies. She was always shown as sacchai ki murthy especially during the Sharuv wedding track. How she refused to cheat someone and tell lies when Bihaan asked her to do it to beat Shraddha in the card game. But now she is uttering pure white lies to Bihaan of all people who is supposed to be the most important person in her life. She is not bothered about Bihaan's life also. She thinks keeping DS secret is more important than Bihaans life! Ultimately if Bihaan dies (God Forbid) then what will she do? She will be still happy because she kept DS sacchai a secret and hence she will not expose DS also? Because from her pov, what has happened has happened. U cant bring back Bihaan back so let the family live in peace? Omigod what a character assassination will it be!?

She always keeps telling mera papa kehte hai ki ... ---> Where did her papas words and ideals go? Gone with the wind? Did her papa tell her that keeping the family in a state of false notions is the best thing to do even if it means sacrificing a life? If like @Lachu always said for her Thapki and Bihaan are one - so she doesn't mind him dying? I am sorry - if this is love, I don't buy that kind of love. I don't need that kind of love nor will I promote such kind of love!

Even I believe in the Sanskrit Subhashini - satyam bruyaat priyam bruyaath na bruyaath satyamapriya,.
But this is not about not "uttering unfavourable truth" but it is about "uttering lies". Thapki has been lying to Bihaan.

If this is FL glorification track, then I don't believe they are achieving it. They have butchered her character sufficiently. I am wondering whether this track is for butchering Thapki's character or to make a Saopla out of DS or like some people / spoilers say this is Bihaan ke pyaar ki parikshaa?! I can't believe. It is all about how low Thapki can fall to keep her ex-es true secret from everyone. She can even go to the extent of killing her husband (indirectly of course - supporting or keeping quiet when a person commits a crime is equivalent to committing the crime).

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

1.7k

Users

12

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

oceanbubble thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Agree to everything you said...Thapki is not being snaskaari when she is hiding his truth from the family to preserve family's happiness...!! She is infact endangering it herself...
She saw how much grief stricken everyone was in those moments when bihaan was not opening his eyes after being buried under the cement...or did she not see that...??
She has seen that Sapola can not redeem himself...not now atleast...then why even bother preserving his repu in front of family & keeping the family happy...& leaving them vulnerable to Sapola's antics...
Is she still giving him a 14th chance of redeeming himself...does she think he will change...?? NO...!! She clearly does not think like that...!!
She knows now that DS can stoop to any lows...& she has seen him talking to bihaan thrice...& she has seen bihaan is getting more & more upset...!! WHY can't that damned woman react...?? Take some action...??
Dialogues bade bade...what has she really done to safeguard ANYONE from that sapola...?? NOTHING...!!
She is just glaring & flaring...!! Nothing else...!!
supporting or keeping quiet when a person commits a crime is equivalent to committing the crime
This is exactly what i had said in the DEDT yesterday...!!
This is not called being good...!! this is not called being sanskaari...!! For your ex's repu...endangering everyone's life...does not care enough for bihaan...its ok...but it seems she doesn't care for the family either...& if something untoward happens...& she starts CRYING...that would be the last nail in the coffin...WHY cry later...when you had the chances to do something to prevent the mishap earlier...!!😡😡😡
Karaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I think Thapki is still in character. She would got o any lengths to "keep the family happy" including sacrificing her love and life.
She was never above lying or cheating. She was in the profession of lying and subterfuge both as a "reporter" and a "lawyer". Her lying and cheating reservations have only been related to Shraddha. May be she has always had a complex that Shraddha is better than since Vasu selected her for DS!! So she tried to prove her superiority by taking her high horse.
The purpose of the current track:
-- create a story line
-- destroy DS so that we know who is lead
-- drag the show


Not sure how it is the test of Bihaan's love, unless according to CVs blind love and love are same. I cannot blame him for misunderstanding Thapki.
fun4ever89 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Character consistency was never a strong point of this show...so Thapki's change in her behaviour can be attributed to it but even then the 360 degree contrast shown is utterly indigestible.

I am sorry but a man who constantly harasses you has no reputation to save...she has no regard for her husband's life as well as she clearly was not disturbed by his near death experience...


fan.matsh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
@Sakshi - Agree she is endangering her life... Which is really OK... She isn'c concerned nor are we?! 😆 But if Bihaan dies because of her, has she thought about the impact it can have on Bauji and Dadima - forget the others - none of the others really cares! Even Vasu - she might cry out of guilt rather than anything else.

I wonder was this much butchering of Thapkis character really necessary! This is certainly not the Thapki who has been built up the whole year. She is been shown lying so much which is undigestible for me.

Its besides the point that I have stopped watching TPK for the past couple of weeks!😆
fan.matsh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Katori

I think Thapki is still in character. She would got o any lengths to "keep the family happy" including sacrificing her love and life.

She was never above lying or cheating. She was in the profession of lying and subterfuge both as a "reporter" and a "lawyer". Her lying and cheating reservations have only been related to Shraddha. May be she has always had a complex that Shraddha is better than since Vasu selected her for DS!! So she tried to prove her superiority by taking her high horse.
The purpose of the current track:
-- create a story line
-- destroy DS so that we know who is lead
-- drag the show


Not sure how it is the test of Bihaan's love, unless according to CVs blind love and love are same. I cannot blame him for misunderstanding Thapki.



@Bold: As a reported I havent seen her. But as a lawyer she didn't lie.

Why did they show her as so much as a Harischandra ki beti during the Shraddha marriage track!

Yes I agree she always kept secrets. Yes she sacrificed everything - she was even ready to give up her life. But here she is not giving up on her love (which I feel is still ok for her mahanta) but she is giving up on Bihaan's life - I dont mind her giving up on hers - thats real sacrifice but here Bihaans life is under threat! Thats my real concern!😆 During divorce track, she was ready to divorce to save Bihaan, now she is ready to get him killed to keep DS secret? Whos side is she on really?!

Point of this track is to drag the show - That I agree!!!😆 CVs are experts at that!
fan.matsh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: fun4ever89

Character consistency was never a strong point of this show...so Thapki's change in her behaviour can be attributed to it but even then the 360 degree contrast shown is utterly indigestible.

I am sorry but a man who constantly harasses you has no reputation to save...she has no regard for her husband's life as well as she clearly was not disturbed by his near death experience...




Yes agree... Total inconsistency in characters! Thapki is butchered totally!
dushturain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Fan. Matsh,
it is not dhruvs reputaion she is saving..she doesnt care a fig about what happens to dhruv...she is saving whole family from pain(bihaan included) ...i know its ridiculous, and yea it is FL glorification,...almost all serials I hv ever watched, misunderstanding has occured because the FL hid sth for "The GREATER GOOD"

Which is never "good" and never happens eventually ...lol

But i think Thapki's this behaviour is in her character and i can understand her point of view actually...she is a mahan atma she is thinking of family...not of herself-bihaan, because she is still thinking she can handle dhruv by herself ( yea yea fl glorification).
Edited by dushturain - 9 years ago
Karaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: fan.matsh



@Bold: As a reported I havent seen her. But as a lawyer she didn't lie.

Why did they show her as so much as a Harischandra ki beti during the Shraddha marriage track!

Yes I agree she always kept secrets. Yes she sacrificed everything - she was even ready to give up her life. But here she is not giving up on her love (which I feel is still ok for her mahanta) but she is giving up on Bihaan's life - I dont mind her giving up on hers - thats real sacrifice but here Bihaans life is under threat! Thats my real concern!😆 During divorce track, she was ready to divorce to save Bihaan, now she is ready to get him killed to keep DS secret? Whos side is she on really?!

Point of this track is to drag the show - That I agree!!!😆 CVs are experts at that!


Who says she loves Bihaan? I don't. I have seen a lot of talk about it but her actions have never shown it. So what's the issue in sacrificing him?
-Ila- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Well I am as unlucky as Bihan in the eating your own words business lol...Anyway, the hiding was fine till the that confrontation when she called him sapola but after that she should have told everyone the truth. But thapki is not out pf character at all she still works on the old principles except she is mahaan to the point of being completely dumb (such a small word to express my exact feelings) But I still say it is rest of the world including animals and plants >Bihan >herself in the priority list for her. Its nothing to be outraged about lol completely normal lol

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".