Did you agree with the story of Astitva?

Poll

Did you agree with the story of Astitva?

Login To Vote
roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
The movie spoke about a serious issue that shows that if a women commits a mistake, she isn't forgiven whereas her husband can be forgiven despite of cheating his wife. It was a bold subject and the story made me think if Tabu was right or wrong. However, I agreed with the end that she chose to walk out of the relationship.


I would like to know what do members here think about the story.
Edited by roni_berna - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

5.1k

Users

20

Likes

74

Frequent Posters

roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Nobody saw this movie 😒
Ranbirrocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Good topic .
Let me sum story - Tabu and her hubby live happily . Her hubby travels a lot . She has a music tutor ( Monish bhel) . She gets physical with him and is preggers with his baby. She asks Monish to go away. Gives hubby impression that baby is his. When boy is grown up, he gets letter that he has inherited MB's property. Truth comes out that about his dad's identity.
Tabu's husband blames her. But later on his friend reminds him of all sleeping around he has done while traveling. So it's even case of cheating .
Even her son is angry with her .
In the end , family forgives her but she walks out on them.
Mallika-E-Bhais thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I did. And I absolutely love it. It spoke more about female sexuality/women committing adultery & how our society creates unfair expectations & considers women to shoulder the onus of all Morality & Chastity & how unfair, hypocritical & dismissive it is with respect to a woman's sexual desires & needs. It is one of Tabu's best roles & all through the movie I wanted to smack her husband & son with a few thousand slaps. This is a huge, long topic but 2 scenes will always stay with me-


1) When her husband is railing at her for betraying him, for being a woman & a mother & cheated , her cry & very simple Q- "What do I do if I too feel desire? If I don't have what I wish for? I did wrong but I too have desires & a separate identity apart form just your wife & a mother" and that just summed up the whole movie for me. It was Tabu's finesse as an artiste that we empathised for her rather than for the "betrayed parties", her husband & son.



2) Thr climax. Head held high,guilt finally rid of she holds her head high & finally realises that her husband & son can & will never accept her, understand her & I loved that her son's gf (Namrata Shirodkar) sees her strength & is disgusted by her sons hypocrisy who was lightening fast to condemn her for her infidelity because he had to rudely wake up to the fact that his mother was a flesh & blood human. IST of us do have the tendency to put our parents on pedestals & it is when we realise that they are as fragile & vulnerable as us, is when we truly become 'adults' & can enjoy a more equal relationship with them IMO.




Bold movie but so beautiful & casting Tabu in it was a casting coup!! No-one else could've brought her to life & it is one if her best works, much better than her acclaimed Chandini Bar!


P. S. Sorry for the wall of text, I get so rambley over things that I love! 🤣
Edited by Mallika-E-Bhais - 9 years ago
Her-mion-e thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Mallika-E-Bhais

I did. And I absolutely love it. It spoke more about female sexuality/women committing adultery & how our society creates unfair expectations & considers women to shoulder the onus of all Morality & Chastity & how unfair, hypocritical & dismissive it is with respect to a woman's sexual desires & needs. It is one of Tabu's best roles & all through the movie I wanted to smack her husband & son with a few thousand slaps. This is a huge, long topic but 2 scenes will always stay with me-


1) When her husband is railing at her for betraying him, for being a woman & a mother & cheated , her cry & very simple Q- "What do I do if I too feel desire? If I don't have what I wish for? I did wrong but I too have desires & a separate identity apart form just your wife & a mother" and that just summed up the whole movie for me. It was Tabu's finesse as an artiste that we empathised for her rather than for the "betrayed parties", her husband & son.



2) Thr climax. Head held high,guilt finally rid of she holds her head high & finally realises that her husband & son can & will never accept her, understand her & I loved that her son's gf (Namrata Shirodkar) sees her strength & is disgusted by her sons hypocrisy who was lightening fast to condemn her for her infidelity because he had to rudely wake up to the fact that his mother was a flesh & blood human. IST of us do have the tendency to put our parents on pedestals & it is when we realise that they are as fragile & vulnerable as us, is when we truly become 'adults' & can enjoy a more equal relationship with them IMO.




Bold movie but so beautiful & casting Tabu in it was a casting coup!! No-one else could've brought her to life & it is one if her best works, much better than her acclaimed Chandini Bar!


P. S. Sorry for the wall of text, I get so rambley over things that I love! 🤣




There is just one thing I didn't liked about the movie that's Aditi could have told her husband about the son before Shrikant found out himself. I know she tried to tell him just when he was back from the tour but never got the opportunity at that time. May be she was not finding enough courage for that. Shrikant Pandit was extremely chauvinist pig so it wouldn't have changed anything...

More that Sachin, I hated her son Aniket. What an asshole he was. The abuse he did to Aditi was beyond pardonable.

Rest I totally agree with post. Tabu was fabulous. It was her best along with Maqbool..and how many times I have see the movie on tv 😃 I actually remember all the lines she said at the end. And I loved the end. At least she was able to live her rest of the life peacefully guilt free unlike his son and husband
roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
MEB: Absolutelt agree with you. There were so many factors shown in the movie and they tried to explain everyone's POV considering the way they viewed the infedility issue. The son and father were seen to be hypocrites and the way Smita too stood by Tabu was fab. No wonder Tabu won the NA for this movie 👏

Edited by roni_berna - 9 years ago
TotalBetty thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
I tried to watch the movie but couldn't... I read the synopsis


None of the main characters including the FL are likable

I don't think letting a man believe the child was his for all those years when she very well knew who the father was is okay!
ShadowKisses thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
I thought it was an incredible movie about her search for her identity and while infidelity was obviously a huge part of the movie, the movie as a whole was so much more than just a neglected wife giving in to her physical desires.
It put a mirror to a society where infidelity is written off as "Men will be men" when men are the offending party but when women are the offending party, all hell breaks loose. Women are expected to forgive, forget and remember that at the end of the day, he comes home to you. What good is that if her philandering husband never cares or respects her desires (not just physical ones but her desire to have a career, to be her own person)?

She should have informed her husband that her son was not his; her silence led to a long-lasting deception that he absolutely had the right to feel betrayed and wronged by. However, he is not the victim he portrays himself to be. He physically forced himself on Aditi (without giving a second thought about what she wanted), expected her to put her entire life on hold while being away, kept her from working, slept with a number of women during the course of their marriage, and wanted to publicly shame Aditi for what is essentially a very private matter. His indiscretions do not excuse her infidelity or lying by omission but the pot can not call the kettle black.
CoffeeCake thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
I watched it long back
Tabu was indeed a cheater, not becoz she slept with someone else, but she forced child of someone else on her husband. That's wrong

That man brought up that kid thinking his own blood, invested money on his education, loved him like anything just to know that that child is from one night stand of his wife?

It's not about man and woman, it's about emotional attachment.

Her need, desire, physical requirement etc are fine but then it's wrong to force baby produced from that desire on someone else. Take responsibility and walk out of the marriage after giving message 'I'm a human and I made a mistake' OR 'I dont regret anything' immediately, not after years when her husband exposed her.
Edited by Divine-Pearl - 9 years ago
zehreeli.kheer thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail 15th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
No.. I would have agreed had she come out clean on her own, not when her husband probed her about it

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Briaahna

2 months ago

When you even agree with samosas 😂

I liked HAHK more than DDLJ cos of Madhuri Now call me a feminist 😂 https://x.com/rohitjswl01/status/1928485583514644485?s=46...

https://x.com/rohitjswl01/status/1928485583514644485?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: FBIr3port

2 months ago

Do you agree ?

https://x.com/seriousfunnyguy/status/1924680811866968518 What do you think of this video ? Only 2% of Indians pay taxes.

https://x.com/seriousfunnyguy/status/1924680811866968518
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Rosyme

2 months ago

Ajey teaser - The untold story of a Yogi.

https://www.instagram.com/p/DKgxsbNKsze/?img_index=1 igsh=bmNrZHh3ZXJhZ2s3 4 5 6 words

https://www.instagram.com/p/DKgxsbNKsze/?img_index=1
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

1 months ago

Nitanshi Goel in MS Dhoni the untold story

Nitanshi Goel in MS Dhonu the untold story https://www.instagram.com/reel/DKkd0zNyb9R/?igsh=aGQ2bGY2aHVsNGhi

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

1 months ago

Cute story about Hrithik’s biggest fan

Cute story about Hrithik’s biggest fan https://www.instagram.com/reel/DKmboUHyNb_/?igsh=aXp4OWtkcjBieTdl

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".