You are the best sister, she is the bahu of this house - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2.2k

Users

9

Likes

94

Frequent Posters

moonwearer thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
The circumstances faced by both families is so different and the hatred and venom and judgemental response from all directions i think makes...we understand that their status is different. Does that make grief of a mother better or worse due to the labels society pins on people. Pins arbitrarily...without a thought or step taken to unravel the truth. The entire police force society be they residents of Chandini Chowk or Sinha House. They are all so reactive falling for the net cast by Iftikar and his gang.

As a reminder that what is accepted and what not Jaya's pulling up of Swa i understand. Why did she not allow Swa to take Simmi away?
Suha has already told that Swa is the best bride for Adarsh and bahu for the Sinha House.Maybe this is testing times for all and the biggest test is for Swa as the way things pop up affords no processing time or coping mechanism.
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: sp108

Nice post Shruthi!

But I was fuming at everyone in the Sinha family (barring Simmi) as well as on Swadheenta's parents.

Yes, the Sinha family is dealing with the loss of a loved one and that too in such a brutal fashion. But did even one of them, or at least Adarsh, put himself in Swadheenta's shoes? Forget Adarsh, did even Swadheenta's mother put herself in her daughter's place? Did Jaya even think twice before unceremoniously calling the brother-sister relationship as non-existent, put herself in Swadheenta's place? Doesn't everybody know about Asad's importance in Swadheenta's life? Were they not witness to the beautiful speech that Swadheenta gave after her wedding about Asad?

It is unfair for everybody to expect Swadheenta to forget the Gilani's and mourn for Abhay (not that she is not mourning his loss). And the poor girl can only mourn for her dead soul-brother in solitude, where nobody would hear her mourns. I wish Swadheenta's mom had shown a modicum of sensitivity and maturity. I wish she had given her a shoulder to cry on, to mourn for Asad. A girl can't build and sustain new relations without the support of the existing ones. Relationships are built in the heart, they are not easy to discard. Can't someone in her circle understand that much at least?

My heart goes out to Swadheenta, more so because everybody will understand Simi's grief, but no one will even bother to understand what is Swadheenta's situation. If each of the members of the Sinha family had put themselves in Swadheenta's place, they would have understood the amount of pain she is in. I just wish people around her could see her pain. Even if they believe that Asad is a terrorist, what stops them from sympathising with Swadheenta? Shouldn't they at least empathise with her because she has been faced with this cruel truth that her brother is a terrorist? All I see is everybody asking her to forget - as if forgetting is such a simple thing. And is it not shocking to find out that your brother is a terrorist? Wouldn't that be heart-breaking and traumatic to deal with? Can Adarsh not see it from that perspective at least, that his wife is in a kind of traumatic shock? I didn't see anyone lend a shoulder to her, no one.

I am not too sure if anybody will support her. As I see it, she might have a long lonely battle ahead. And I hope I am proven wrong.


agree with every word you said.even if asad really is a terrorist even that is shocking and enough to break swadheenta. I havent seen anyone sit down and talk to her about how she is feeling not even adarsh. He can only see his pain.I never liked the way jaya spoke to swadheenta yesterday

Lets see how the show progresses from here till when will Swa have to fight alone.
And i dont believe Swa has to first see her duty f a DIL right now. If Abhay can forget his family duties of a husband and to be father and sacrifice his life for the country, if Asad can forget about his duties of a brother, son, lover, then Swa can atleast fight for Asad to prove his innocence & for Abhay to bring out the truth. There is a bigger picture involved here DIL duties can come afterwards or actually even sacrificed.
I remember what Mamu had said to Swadheenta. What will i leave for my future generation with regard to the PIL. its the same case with SWA, what is she giving the future of india if she is allowing a innocent man to be convicted, & something which will be used to further divide the country.

Jaya has one goal only to be a good DiL but Swa has other important responsibilities to fulfill
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@pom we need to know that Jaya is a traditional girl and knows the decorums that needs to be kept as bahu irrespective of personal turmoil. And to give credit to her she has kept the decorum perfectly as the happily married woman in public.

If you see Jaya closely, she does close the door and talk to Swa. And she expects her to maintain the decorum. She has to be there. Else tongues will wage. Where is the new bahu. And it will hurt swa only.
Though the words she spoke was harsh, I would say she did the right duty as the eldest bahu. She protected Swa's honor as she didnt tell anything else to anyone else. Jaya will guide Swa through the mess. And Swa needs one.

Yes Mano Asad did tell she will be best DIL also. And thanks you found relief in my post. But for the show no relief is in sight, tonight it is going to be more intense.


no I understand that is where jaya was coming from, every character makes sense on this show. as much as social customs are annoying, one has no choice but to follow it sometimes. everyone is asking for the nayi bahu, if she is not there then what will people say? especially considering the awkward position swadheenta is in right now. However, I think swadheenta has the right to mourn because asad was special to her. simmi atleast has the freedom to cry and when she does, someone will always be there to hold her but what about swadheenta? unfortunately no one is there to understand her pain and now she cannot even cry in peace.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
@priti if I am right swa freedom will come from simmi.Today jaya told everyone respect her in sinha family. But simmi will break lose and tell something harsh. Her loss is more and swa isone way or other responsible for it.so it will become swa honour and suha has no option but to allow her to fight for her honour. @naq swa is a new bride. What u said can happen once u becomes part of that family.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".