Please don't bash, just trying to be logical!

CONTEST : IPL 2026 Prediction Game

Page

Next Last

3fra

@3fra

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

don't compered dear shagun left ruhi do to her selfish reason, ishita force by raman to commit suicide, don't fly high dear soon pihu will forget shagun raman will again sing ishita song

Edited by 3fra - 9 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Ramyalaxmi

@Ramyalaxmi

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

@TM: I agree, as CV's have made ishu dropped to the level of shagun as shagun can never be raised to be like Ishita. Though the circumstances (from what I read) seems to be different. There shagun left ruhi whereas ishu was asked to leave. But I respect your points. Seems logical.

P.s: Why you give the card of not to bash. No one has the right to bash others. we all have the right to display. Is it not public forum? We can always disagree with our views in a diplomatic civilized way. Its not moral policing and its not my job. But I felt sorry that you are so scared to share your view.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sonu_ishradivan

@sonu_ishradivan

Explorer

Posted: 9 years ago

Ishita left out of guilt, helplessness n a feeling of being unwanted by family n Raman. Shagun left cz she wanted money, luxury, n not a kid. Whras can clearly c Ishita tadping 4 her kids.

Quote

mcvra

@mcvra

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

ramans words would have been jusified if he had informed pihu about ishitha being her mother when she was assumed to be dead.he didnt inform pihu about ishu and made shagun her mother.then wat is the use of his stupid srrogacy idea??his plan was to give ishitha the feeling of motherhood through her own child.now pihu doesnt even know her mother and many ppl think pihu as shaguns child.

in my pov that is the biggest mistake raman had done.he didnt respect ishu even when she was assumed to be dead.

he is not even showing one ounce of guiltiness for saying that stupid words to her before leap.

Quote

3fra

@3fra

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshinedaisyme

But if she really cared she should have atleast enquired about her kids once.

easy to blame difficult to understand she lost her heart her daughter ruhi

Quote

janani

@janani_divan

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshinedaisyme

But if she really cared she should have atleast enquired about her kids once.

are you following episodes regulary.i think you should watch ishita pov y she not enquire about anyone.

Quote

mcvra

@mcvra

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshinedaisyme

Well if raman told her about her mother committing suicide and the circumstances wouldn't phi have felt like its her fault, wouldn't it have had an effect in her? It doesnt change the fact that ishita didn't even bother to atleast enquire about her child.

when he told a lie that shagun as pihu's mother why cant he just say ishu was her mother and she died of some other cause. also it was not becoz of pihu she committed suicide but it was due to ramans words. may be raman would have thought pihu will hate him if she comes to know that his father was the reason for her mother's suicide.

everyone has different perspective to this.

Quote

Meher

@Water_Angel

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshinedaisyme

If she lost one child doesnt she also feel that her newly born child also needs her mother, why punish the new born for

She didn't punish anyone. Ok so when people have theories for Raman being hurt inside and all that's y letting his frustration out in form of crass words hurled at Ishita, then I have also a theory for Ishita. First of all, she went away bcuz of the words Raman said to her, and fyi, if u remember what raman said, was VERY harsh, like, tum sauteli maa se bhi battar ho, tum meri baccho k liye manhoos ho, tumne sabit kardiya sauteli maa sauteli rehti hai, manhoosiyat ho tum, etc ,etc. Ishita believed it, when she was in the most vulnerable state. And she took Raman's word to her heart. She actually believed, she's bad omen, and shudn't be around Raman's kids anymore. It's easy to say, she didn't inquire bout her own kid and all, but y people r not seeing, y she didn't inquire? She went thru a trauma, come on she attempted to commit suicide, and those who do that r seemed to be mentally ill. She never had the courage to do so, to inquire bout her family, kids, even Raman. See, I'm not saying ur points r wrong or illogical, but sometimes u have to look into the depth of the matter. Just my POV. No offence to u or anyone.
P.S I'm not any Raman hater or Ishita lover, I watch the show for the genuine bonding of relationships on screen, which attracted me to the show at first place, be it for IshRa or IshRu or IshAdi or IshRaRu. PEACE OUT!

Quote

DivanIshraru

@DivanIshraru

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

she went to commit suicide coz of raman's words and never went back coz of raman only
and if you see the episodes,mani told her to check on her family bt she never coz she thought once she sees them she would want to be with them and she knew raman hated her.
the only person whom she trusted erased her existence as a mother as a wife
so its entirely raman's fault that ishita never returned back