Inconsistency in grades

I don't quite understand the basis on which grades are given and the bottom 3 are chosen .I'm esp,at a loss with Sureshji's way of grading.....In today's(24th episode),we saw that Sagar,Loria and Vasundhara got B+ from Sureshji and A from Sonu....One doesn't have to be an Einstein to guess that they shld be in the bottom 3....but when they announced the bottem 3,Vasundhara was substituted by Anamika!!!how????!!Anamika got A+ from Sureshji....does that mean Sureshji doesn't agree with his own grades?

Today Sureshji was randomly giving grades(I'm sorry to say this,but it was my opinion).....I thought Vasundhara did a pretty good job,but she got B+(ok,so let me presume Sureshji is strict with his grades)...Rohit did a very good job(lost sur only once due to jumping) ,but otherwise he was bang on with expressions,tune and sur in other places. I'm sure the jumping was Zee's idea and Rohit got chided for it.And...lo and behold,he still gets a B+.....Ok ,I thought,Sureshji is the strict teacher who doesn't tolerate even mild mistakes.....Then Loria gets B+, I was taken aback,...Loria was not in sur at all.......B+ to Loria and B+ to Rohit..,...does that mean they were equal? Wasn't Rohit far superior? Ok,I console myself, Rohit was at the high end of B+ and Loria at the low end..makes sense,right?....Well,now comes the shocker....Smita gets A...Now,yeh kaisa insaaf hai?Smita was totally off key, almost thruout the song, and she gets A (Coz she made a sad face?) and Rohit gets B+.. ...I'm lost here😕..........and more to come.....Anamika gets A+,now isn't that going too far,she was not that outstanding......

Can anyone explain/make sense of this grading?To top it all ,once Sureshji remarked something like'mere liye,personally,sur sabse zaroori hai,expression kum bhi chal jayega,pur sur ko nahin chodna'.....and then A to Smita......I think one of Sureshji's problems is that he hasn't heard most new songs(maybe he never heard tinka tinka and dil na diya).......Having never heard the original, he didn't have anyone to compare Anamika with...and hence he liked her singing....the same thing worked to Rohit's detriment...the baisc tune of Dil na diya is very simple and the song has some parts like dddddddil etc,which may sound like utter nonsense to a person who has never heard the song before. Since Sureshjii had never heard the song,he had no idea abt its tune,mood,style etc...the song probably sounded like nonsense to him and the result,of course,B+...

I personally think Sureshji was a li'l hard on Rohit and Vasundhara this time.He judges them by the high stds which they themselves set in the initial stages of the performance.He shld,in my opinion,be judging them relative to others.....And not having heard and not liking a song is not a criteria to reduce marks for a singer😊..

If u actually read this whole post,then thanx for ur patience 😊.😊.....plz let me know ur opinions 😊

Rock&roll...beta...u did a gud job..an A+ this time.keep it up 😆 .
u r right. there is no mean 4 their grade. same thing was confusing me. but i was bit lazy 2 type long post. but u did it 👏 .plz share ur idea here 😉

Originally posted by: rock&roll

I think one of Sureshji's problems is that he hasn't heard most new songs(maybe he never heard tinka tinka and dil na diya).....

....And not having heard and not liking a song is not a criteria to reduce marks for a singer😊..

I agree with you.

I wont say that you should hear all the new songs. We can understand that people like Suresh W are more attatched to the old songs and they dont much like new ones. It's their choice. But when you are judging a competition it is better that you have heard at least the popular new songs. Even if you havnt heard a song you should only judge their singing not the song. Remember that those songs are not their choice.

I think Suresh W is getting a bit fussy these days. That chemistry b/n him and Sonu is somewhat missing. What could be the reason.......? Hope it's not Sonu😉

Originally posted by: SAnode

That chemistry b/n him and Sonu is somewhat missing. What could be the reason.......? Hope it's not Sonu😉

yah..agree😊

thanx everyone for ur inputs and opinions.'Woh ajnabee',thanx for pointing out the probable reason for low responses...have now highlighed the main points I wanted to make.maybe that wld help others 😊
And Rasny,thanks for the A+ 😆 Main is grade to banaye rakhne ki koshish karoongi 😉

Originally posted by: rock&roll

thanx everyone for ur inputs and opinions.'Woh ajnabee',thanx for pointing out the probable reason for low responses...have now highlighed the main points I wanted to make.maybe that wld help others 😊
And Rasny,thanks for the A+ 😆 Main is grade to banaye rakhne ki koshish karoongi 😉

gud😉