sayee thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

I like they way they are depicting the emotions , but the most disappointing is the way Lakshman is portrayed. I can't digest every time they both behave a bit indifferently towards him. They have spoiled the relation of Ram-Lakshman, Sita-Lakshman.

Sita might have given birth to Luv-Kush but her first son was always Lakshman.
Sita might have been his soul but Lakshman was his breath, Ram never treated him like this. Sita was exiled , then she went back to land. Even after seeing this Ram was alive but the moment he forsake Lakshman he couldn't live another second. He submersed himself in the same Sarayu where Lakshman submersed himself.

Ram - Lakshman where "One soul in Two bodies"

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

4.9k

Users

7

Likes

75

Frequent Posters

Shivam... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: sayee


I like they way they are depicting the emotions , but the most disappointing is the way Lakshman is portrayed. I can't digest every time they both behave a bit indifferently towards him. They have spoiled the relation of Ram-Lakshman, Sita-Lakshman.

Sita might have given birth to Luv-Kush but her first son was always Lakshman.
Sita might have been his soul but Lakshman was his breath, Ram never treated him like this. Sita was exiled , then she went back to land. Even after seeing this Ram was alive but the moment he forsake Lakshman he couldn't live another second. He submersed himself in the same Sarayu where Lakshman submersed himself.

Ram - Lakshman where "One soul in Two bodies"


Couldnt agree more , you have summed up perfectly
Trinaa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I totally agree with you.I dont know why they have destroyed Lakshman's character. Ram-Lakshman and Sita-Lakshman had a very warm relationship. The 14 years that they spent together they enjoyed each other's company alot. Even after returning back, they had very nice memories of those years.They had a very sweet bhabhi-devar relationship. Lakshman used to treat her like his mother and Sita used to take good care of him.
But here, Sita and Lakshman are like always arguing, and Ram and Lakshman lack the warmth that we used see in Ayodhya as well as in Mithila.I feel that Lakshman is shown very lonely.
Edited by trina134 - 9 years ago
sayee thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Shivam...



Couldnt agree more , you have summed up perfectly



I admire all the relations in Ramayana but the only relation which attracts me towards Ramayan the one which excites me & motivates me to read and watch Ramayana the more is Ram - Lakshman. Even Amish's book The Scion of Ikshavaku does more justice to their relation than SKR. If I was asked which adaption then I would have suggested this adaption of Ram-Lakshman rather than any other which SKR is showing.
Shivam... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sayee



I admire all the relations in Ramayana but the only relation which attracts me towards Ramayan the one which excites me & motivates me to read and watch Ramayana the more is Ram - Lakshman. Even Amish's book The Scion of Ikshavaku does more justice to their relation than SKR. If I was asked which adaption then I would have suggested this adaption of Ram-Lakshman rather than any other which SKR is showing.



As much as that book is away in terms of truth , it never destroyed the relation of brothers

In fact in that Ram willingly took a curse on himself to revive a Dead Lakshman

Also , their childhood story was so admirable , How lakshman took a hit for Ram and how Ram spoke lie for the first time to bail out his brother from sumitra's wrath
sayee thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Shivam...




As much as that book is away in terms of truth , it never destroyed the relation of brothers

In fact in that Ram willingly took a curse on himself to revive a Dead Lakshman

Also , their childhood story was so admirable , How lakshman took a hit for Ram and how Ram spoke lie for the first time to bail out his brother from sumitra's wrath



Exactly, even after Ram's marriage to Sita he never let it mull the love of his for Lakshman. Lakshman was his very life force. Even Sita had ample respect for Lakshman.
Justlikethat1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
The beauty of Ramayan is in the fact that every relationship is balanced.. be it the one between a father and his son/daughter, a mother and her son/daughter/DIL, elder brother -younger brother, between friends and between a husband and a wife.

Ramayan tells us how an ideal relationship can be and Shri Ram and Lakshman were the personification of brotherly love.

Ram calls Lakshman his father, brother, son, friend and minister all in one to Hanuman when they are first introduced. Lakshman tells Hanuman that he considers himself to be Shri Ram's servant making Hanuman appreciate the depth of love and dedication they had for each other.

Shri Ram's sorrow during Yudh Kaand when Lakshman does not wake up is an absolute tear jerker. He tells Sugriv that there is no use in either winning the war or getting Sita back if Lakshman is not alive.

The equation between the brothers were so strong that they stood by each other in the worst of the times and acted as each other's strength. When Shri Ram almost loses his mind searching for Sita, it is Lakshman who stands by him, supporting, counseling, giving hope to his forlorn brother to take steps to get her back. He acts as Shri Ram's doodh to Sugriv to remind him of his promise to help search Sita.

What more needs to be said about Sita and Lakshman except for quoting the instance when Lakshman recognizes only Sita's anklet from all her jewels saying that the only ornament he has ever seen is her anklet when he took his blessings from her every day. That was their relationship.. one between a mother and a son more than BIL to SIL.

This relationship can be beautifully showcased without compromising on the wife and husband relationship between Shri Ram and Sita. That is what Ramayan shows us.

I wish the CVs don't forget that Sita's perspective does not always have to be about her actions with Shri Ram.. It can also be her perspective on her own and Shri Ram's other relations.
Shivam... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
@justlikethat1
Truly said dear , the beauty of ramayana is indeed in the portrayal of sensitivity of the relationships involved and what we get to learn from it

And it is not restricted to just ayodhya , it spreads across lanka as well

Vibhishan : Agreed to stand for Justice so went against his own blood brother , will be worshipped like a hero but still the world will consider him a traitor

Kumbhkaran : Had the knowledge what was right and wrong , tried to convince his brother , but even after failed attempt , stayed with him as a mark of loyalty and respect, but here again he will always be considered a villain though a loyalist.
Edited by Shivam... - 9 years ago
moviefan-pooja thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Absolutely agree with u, I feel they r giving less importance to lakshman and his relation with his bhaiyya and bhabhi, I feel that it us the only drawback if the show right now and that too a major one. And I felt scion of ikshvaku was very far from the truth but the author managed to maintain the goodness and feelings between all relations
Shliya thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
I'm a lord Ram devotee and I'm always very eager to see every new version of Ramayan. To see how it depicts the various emotions and what new stories it has to offer other than the main plot.
I like siya ke Ram bcoz they show sita to be an independent woman having her own ideologies and speaking her mind. But I was a little taken aback at the time of vanvas scenes. I really feel at times when sita talks to lakshman there's slight tinge of rudeness in it. Again I say at times. There have been lovely episodes where sita has shown concern for lakshman , in the beginning when she's concerned abt his sleep and then in a scene where she gives him her shawl. But at times it's like they really sideline him. It's good to see siya and Ram moments, but they kind of ignore lakshman. They could have a scene at least once where Ram sita appreciate him and tell him how the exile has been easy bcoz of him and his seva. He deserves it.

In today's episode sita running after shrupnakha I found a bit stupid. It does show her humane side but what about rationality. She tried to lure Ram, kill her and that's the reason lakshman intervened and struck her nose. Just so he could save his bhabhi. N sita running after her to apologise and then to scold lakshman is not done.

I used to feel this but never wrote anything coz I thought ppl here who are fans of skr might be angry but then I believe I'm not the only one thinking so.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".