March 25: Episode Analysis (Edited. Please read and contribute)

sshirley thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Really sorry for the delay. I was out yesterday. From tomorrow onwards will try to post on time.
Please note that I will just highlight and write my analysis of some scenes/characters that caught my attention, without considering the sequence in which they were shown. As such readers will understand this thread better only after they have watched the episode or read a detailed WU.
So, lets start:
Tukde tukde wali bhasha:
That scene was really significant, in that, it brought forward one of the key differences between theatre/stage and tv/films. Especially, the way they operate. In stage or theatre, it is a live performance - there are no retakes n no breaks. So the dance/dialogues/actions have to be memorized as a whole. Kalyani, who had just seen the operations at Rang Sangeet, naturally thought that that way the only way film will be shot.
The director, I feel, changed his style and opted to shoot the complete scene in a single long take only as a challenge to Kalyani. Needless to say, he was impressed.
Different reaction to the same compliment:
Both girls got the same compliment: you are like your father.
To Kalyani, it came as a surprise and the way she (Deepti Naval) still has that sparkle in her eyes thinking of it and that calm satisfaction shows the depth of her happiness at that compliment even today.
Ketki. the bubbly, on the other hand, was all euphoric and that euphoria contains even today. A significant dialogue by Zarina Wahab here.. she told me what I already knew.. Do we see confidence there? or is it simply over confidence?
Kalyani being humble at heart, that compliment takes her by surprise and it means a lot to her. Whereas, Ketki knows her worth, so to say, and knows she's better than others (her dialogues earlier) hence although she still remembers that compliment, she reiterates that she already knew.
Also different are their reactions.. on is silently and calmly soaking in the best compliment she ever got while the other is dancing around, laughing and constantly grinning from ear to ear.
As an aside, this portion reminded me of Jane n Lizzy of Pride and Prejudice. As Lizzy once said to Jane in a lighter vein, "compliments always take you by surprise, me never!" or spmething to that effect.. Also in her letter to her aunt, where she acknowledges her engagement to darcy, she jokingly says something like, "Jane only smiles. while I laugh" - the different reactions here too.
Some other points worth mentioning:
  • Devika being harassed - It is a sad fact that Indian women haven't been safe outside their house (sometimes even in their own house), since times immortal (Ravan's abductuction of Sita, Draupadi's vastraharan). Even today, the timeshave changed for women (Supposedly) but news channels keep blaring with news of crimes against women every day. How can India talk of progress when half its population lives in fear? (yes, women live in constant fear of crime against them, don't we? Isnt that a woman's greatest fear?) Why cant indian women be safe? why cant we have laws that have such severe punishments and the burden of proof on the accused so that these serve as deterrents?
  • Aaji's dance - A good one that. it was a kind of light moment yet it made me think. Rajaran dint know his mother is such a good dancer. Isnt that true of most children? they see their mothers as simply mothers. I'm sure that most of us don't know the talents our mothers have. Isnt that a feat n an indications of the sacrifices our mothers make for us? they get so engrossed in motherhood that they forget themselves and their talents
Edited by sshirley - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

860

Users

7

Likes

29

Frequent Posters

sshirley thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Edited my post.. please read and continue my anmalysis.. whether u agree or disagree.. please do write your POV😊.
jltjlt thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Hi,

Thanks for this analysis. Exactly the points that I just discussed with my mother sometime back.

Really a great show after a long time to come. Very natural, each character is rightly defined and maintained.


Some more interesting points till now:

1) Aajji burning the house and Ketki rejoicing it. I call it Katha Nyaya, i.e., poetic justice. All the shows so far gain TRPs by torturing the audience. While this point has provided a relief even to the audience. And these two are definitely very natural characters and not some OTT ones.

This point also brings out the differences in human reactions to the same situation/scenario. Even Kalyani and Pallavi Joshi's character burned inside when they came to know of the deceit but soon their focus shifted to current crisis management. While Aaji and Ketki could not keep quite till they burnt the house.

2) Kalyani not crying for her father's death, till she took her brother to make him sleep. She started singing and crying also. Mother looking on helplessly. Wonderful Wonderful touch to human reactions.


3) I just can't get over Banu Uday, his excitement, his desperation his helplessness. Even today I keep seeing the flashes of him. I never never thought he could bring out a struggling artist so effectively. What a portrayal that was. I lived through his desperation, helplessness and his excitement and then his heart break. I passed through every emotion there.


All great artists, including the new generation and ofcourse even including the kiddoo... Hope they main this quality and we continue to cherish.

Hope many of you join to discuss this wonderful master piece. I will keep writing whenever I get some time.


1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Perfect Analysis...
The Difference between Theater and Movie work Culture that was Highlighted was Bang-On and how subtly and Naturally they presented it .
One of the Key Points or USP of this Show has been the Simple way of Story Telling yet bringing out the Nuances .

I ABSOLUTELY Loved the Moment of Children talking ti Rajaram post his Death , That is something that's gonna stay with me forever from this Show .


Yes Both the sisters got the same Compliment yet the Reaction .

I like how Distinctively different both sisters are yet they are so Real like they have not made anyone sisters drastically behave different just to make them look Different .

And Deepi Naval and Zarina portrayed the same calm and excited behavior respectively .

Aaji's Dance was Lovely , No wonder Why Rajaram was so Expressive .
The dance also kinda gave a reality check to Ketki too .. the over-confidence that she had post the compliment .

Nt sure abt Devika's Track ...how it gonna affect the current story course.

vyoman thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Excellent analysis...👍🏼
Yet to watch the Friday episode...
Mannmohanaa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Wow Shirley... Awesome!
A perfect judgement and I will agree with all of your points!
Aaji was superb and today I respect her even more! Hats off to her... Kalyani rocked and I am so proud of her!⭐️👏
Swetha-Sai thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Excellent analysis of the episode by u, Shirley! 👏⭐️
mrym_rauf thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Amazing review!👏
M just loving it how kalyani and ketki's characters are shaping up!👍🏼
N aaji's dance was jus so pure n i just loved the attitude in her dance which showed yea she definitely knows how to dance n she also isn't deprived of Kala like her family members, loved her dance!😃
sshirley thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Thank you all for the warm appreciation and your beautiful responses. Really sorry that I could not reply back to u individually n continue the discussion further.
I missed yesterday's epi n will miss oday's too .. so will put out a combined analysis for both epis if that's ok with u all
Edited by sshirley - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".