Originally posted by: Maya_M
https://www.ibnlive.com/news/debate-not-indian-but-indians-gl oat-over-their-success/51004-3.html
Some excerpts from the article:
Indians celebrated when Bobby Jindal, the son of Indian immigrants, was on Sunday elected the Governor of the southern American state of Louisiana. Yet another American desi had made India proud, they said.
But should Indians really be taking credit for Jindal's success? His parents moved to the US 40 years ago and he was born in Baton Rouge, Louisiana?
Check this video
https://www.ibnlive.com/videos/50983/success-in-the-west-yet- india-claims-triumph.html
Topic for debate here is
1. Should Indians really care about these achievements of an American with Indian roots?
2. Now as his father has promised to visit his home town with son Bobby, people are gearing up to clear up the gandagi off street because an American cannot stand dirt and polluted environment of a small Indian town. Your opinion on it? BTW Bobby Jindal converted to Catholicism from Hinduism as a teenager. Yes indians in US care... may be some in india... over all a person who changes his religion to be recognized and apes the west doesnt get much recognition in india... we respect people who wear a dhoti while attending round table conferences... that in american terms is an "attitude"😊
3. Is it always Chak de moment for us Indians when we hear about any acheiver with Indian roots? Indians with roots who want to be identified and keep in touch with india make us proud... Does anybody care about Norah jones even though she is half indian!!!!! You have to believe in collective wisdom... never ever question it....😊.. Does anybody talk about freddie mercury..but we feel proud about laxmi mittal because he cares for india....collectively we have a way of showing the "right" finger to the whole world if required...its not just a part of our values...😆 but if some of these indian-americans and abcds want to appear, feel, seem, keep in touch with the indians... we just reciprocate...and revel in their achievements....😊.. nothing bad about it...I am sure nobody cares about fiji singh... but wonder after generations of being out of india why does he still carry the india in him....😆
43