Did he...do it for her?

Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Karthik could've easily escaped the entire ordeal by saying that he was unconscious for all of yesterday, so he couldn't have know, and he only found out that day. He could've twisted the situation in such a way that only Survi would get punished, not him.
Even when it was the vermillion scene, he had flashbacks to when Survi was about to get that black stuff applied to her face.

Yet he still saved her.

And he keeps on saving her, every time she's been in trouble.

I mean come on! Actions speak louder than words, and if we judge from what he does for Survi rather than what he says about her, it wouldn't be hard to come to the conclusion that he was helplessly and unknowingly in love with her.

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

907

Users

6

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

mary78613 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: LightingHope

Karthik could've easily escaped the entire ordeal by saying that he was unconscious for all of yesterday, so he couldn't have know, and he only found out that day. He could've twisted the situation in such a way that only Survi would get punished, not him.
Even when it was the vermillion scene, he had flashbacks to when Survi was about to get that black stuff applied to her face.

Yet he still saved her.

And he keeps on saving her, every time she's been in trouble.

I mean come on! Actions speak louder than words, and if we judge from what he does for Survi rather than what he says about her, it wouldn't be hard to come to the conclusion that he was helplessly and unknowingly in love with her.



He always has Yusra. He loved her 8 years back and he still loves her with an intensity which he terms as 'hate' but its the hidden love in his heart. He thinks he hates her because of what he thinks that she did to his Ayi, but somewhere deep down he knows Survi cannot do this, but he needs this cover, a reason to hate her. When the actual reason why he hates her is because she left him alone. Survi mein Kartik ki jaan thi and when the person left him by leaving just a letter behind, he was heart broken and he needed a reason to hate her because he could not understand his feelings and hence, put the complete blame of his Ayi's condition on Survi so that he has a STRONG reason to hate her. Because he cannot deal with his conflicting emotions, his feelings and why his heart broken into a million pieces when Survi left. The fact that he loved her and needed her beside him.

He gets comfort in her arms only because his heart knows the truth which his brain is yet to realize. He thinks hurting her would give him relief, and he hurts her but he can't see her in pain for long and becomes her savior too.

He just doesn't want to think of the possibility that Survi did not try to kill his Ayi because then he would have to deal with his conflicting emotions as to why he hates her so much. If only he could recognize the intense love behind all that hatred. If only...
XScarletHeartX thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Agree with u
Didnt u notice when the uncle aunty go after kartik put sindoor
Kartik didnt say anything to survi
Vanellope thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
"And he keeps on saving her, every time she's been in trouble. " And he will keep doing it even if it means the end of him.That's how much he loves her.Survi ke aage peeche sach mein usko aur kuchh nahin dikhta
That's how strongly he feels for her,that's how he has always felt about her.

Like he said "Mein Tere saath has sakta hun,ro sakta hun,Apne dil ki har baat share kar sakta hun.Jitna tu mujhe samajhti hai,utna aur koi nahin samajhta"

Burdened by responsibilities of his family,Survi was the one with whom Kartik could be himself

And he knows how much he loves her & that's exactly why her leaving him broke him inside,devastated him


Vanellope thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: mary78613



He always has Yusra. He loved her 8 years back and he still loves her with an intensity which he terms as 'hate' but its the hidden love in his heart. He thinks he hates her because of what he thinks that she did to his Ayi, but somewhere deep down he knows Survi cannot do this, but he needs this cover, a reason to hate her. When the actual reason why he hates her is because she left him alone. Survi mein Kartik ki jaan thi and when the person left him by leaving just a letter behind, he was heart broken and he needed a reason to hate her because he could not understand his feelings and hence, put the complete blame of his Ayi's condition on Survi so that he has a STRONG reason to hate her. Because he cannot deal with his conflicting emotions, his feelings and why his heart broken into a million pieces when Survi left. The fact that he loved her and needed her beside him.

He gets comfort in her arms only because his heart knows the truth which his brain is yet to realize. He thinks hurting her would give him relief, and he hurts her but he can't see her in pain for long and becomes her savior too.

He just doesn't want to think of the possibility that Survi did not try to kill his Ayi because then he would have to deal with his conflicting emotions as to why he hates her so much. If only he could recognize the intense love behind all that hatred. If only...


What a beautiful reply Mary.Loved it

You put everything absolutely perfect.
Kartik thinks he hates Survi but he can never.He loved her way too much.
I was telling Yusra Exactly the same thing the other day "Survi mein Kartik ki jaan basti hai"
That guy can't live without Survi,which he even admitted to Survi
He is just hurt & broken when Survi chose to leave him leaving behind just a letter
Therefore whenever he remembers Survi's dhoka,he remembers not just his mother falling down but also the letter & Survi leaving.That's why at the lake he said "Zindagi ke har mod par saath chhoda hai usne mera" & then in the jungle when he thought Survi had abandoned him again,he said "Dhokebaaz se wafa ki Ummeed bhi kaise ki jaa sakti hai"

Yes deep down he knows Survi could have never hurt his mother & that's why he is trying to make her tell the truth,giving her a chance to explain everything

I was really happy when Survi said "Shayad woh bhi pyaar hai Jo aapko mujhse nafrat karne ke liye majboor karta hai "

Survi realised Kartik's intense love for her & that is what made Survi's betrayal so much worse.It devastated him.

Hope Kartik realises it soon
Edited by Vanellope - 9 years ago
Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Agree with all of the above
Nafrat aur mohabbat dono dil se ki jaati hai and shiddat se nibhai jaati hai

He knows deep down that she can't do it but needs a reason for hating her

He also says that she abandoned him "Mujhe chod kar chali jaati ho har baar"

He leaves her in trouble but then at the right moments comes to her aide

It's like he wants her in trouble but also can't see her in trouble
Raha bhi na jaaye saha bhi na jaaye
JazzyM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Totally agreed.
He wants her but does not want to be seen as wanting her...Like a dog in manger type of attitude..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".