English SOngs vs Hindi songs?

In you opinion which song do you thuink is harder to sing... indian songs or english songs (not including rap, thats not vcounted as singing)

Plz write you opinion and comment I will very well appreciate it!😳

Originally posted by: SonPan

In you opinion which song do you thuink is harder to sing... indian songs or english songs (not including rap, thats not vcounted as singing)

Plz write you opinion and comment I will very well appreciate it!😳

Cant compare a song can be hard or easy in any language. 😉

i think englsih one is hard to sing

Is this question related to Adi's performance in the finale? 😉

Well, the language does not make a whit of a difference. The COMPOSITION of the song makes it difficult or easy.

All I'm going to say is that every song type requires a lot of practice because they all have very unique styles.

E.g. I once saw Sunidhi singing Mariah Carey's "Hero" in a concert. She was a DISASTER. Worse than Sanjaya Malakar from American Idol.

And this is coming from a hardcore Sunidhi fan.

However, I'm sure Mariah will be just as bad if she is forced to sing Kuhu Kuhu bole koyaliya or some Indian classical piece 😛

erm , i think both are hard in their way but its harder to come up with a composition in a english song i think

Originally posted by: Morgoth

Is this question related to Adi's performance in the finale? 😉

Well, the language does not make a whit of a difference. The COMPOSITION of the song makes it difficult or easy.

All I'm going to say is that every song type requires a lot of practice because they all have very unique styles.

E.g. I once saw Sunidhi singing Mariah Carey's "Hero" in a concert. She was a DISASTER. Worse than Sanjaya Malakar from American Idol.

And this is coming from a hardcore Sunidhi fan.

However, I'm sure Mariah will be just as bad if she is forced to sing Kuhu Kuhu bole koyaliya or some Indian classical piece 😛

Hmmm good dpoint... but my question is why is it so different.......

"Is this question related to Adi's performance in the finale?"

maybee!!😆

Originally posted by: SonPan

Hmmm good dpoint... but my question is why is it so different.......

"Is this question related to Adi's performance in the finale?"

maybee!!😆

They are different 'cause Indian Music and Western Music are 2 separate schools with different methods of learning and influences.

Its like having 2 different religions - the main idea is to worship God, but you do it in a different way. 😊

Originally posted by: Morgoth

They are different 'cause Indian Music and Western Music are 2 separate schools with different methods of learning and influences.

Its like having 2 different religions - the main idea is to worship God, but you do it in a different way. 😊

True say..... good points.... I also fel that english songs dont have extra harkats like desi music has!😕

Originally posted by: desi-chick

i thynk both 😊

Short and sweet!!😆 THanks for replying!

I think it depends on the song...
also how you have been trained