is the magic really lost? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.1k

Users

20

Likes

74

Frequent Posters

roops14 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: meenabhavani

if the magic was completely lost..we would never hold on to show anymore. for me its only Manik that keeps me connected and im watching it for Parth. otherwise there is nothing left basically. i know people are going to bounce back at me..but that is what i genuinely feel. no offence to anyone.

Totally agree, only Parth does his job 100 %. Our Manik is same but something is missing from nandini's side. It's my personal views, no offence to anyone.
Redross thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: roops14

Totally agree, only Parth does his job 100 %. Our Manik is same but something is missing from nandini's side. It's my personal views, no offence to anyone.

I also agree with these comments ...i think Parth is doing his 100% but somewhere i find Niti's acting very very blank in all manan scene..in S1 when Manik used to do such romantic things or teasing it was Nandini's expression also which added charm to the scene...Nowever days i feel Niti is not at all in her charector.Just acting for somebodys sake...That tatoo scene would have been so so romantic and touching if Nadini would have hugged HIM TIGHT WHEN HE SAID SHE IS HIS STAR ...but nahi such a plain expression from Niti..staring without intensity is boring ..But Parth i am starting to like him more bec he is professional...kuch bhi offscreen...it never effects his onscreen presence.
I hope Niti will come back in Diwali episodes...
shindesweety thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
exactly
u said it all right😃
maddy arya part is a bit annoying
but m loving manan 😳😳😳
and sometimes dhruv alya😕 even harshad too😕
sit back and enjoy
and ya they havnt lost the charm n all
its just the new team n new people which are handling them...and we cant expext the same from them too
i wont blame the actors..they are the same😊😳

Rits3016 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
I don't think that the magic is lost or the spark is not there.Agree with you that we have become accustomed to Manan .
But I also believe that there is something definitely going wrong with the creativity and storyline. Imagine we haven't seen a proper Manan hug in S2...leave alone a kiss. Ek forehead kiss to definitely banta tha!!

Till now I have been really positive and hopeful but frankly telling am loosing it day by day.Actors are doing their job perfectly but not the crew. And obviously there is no use ranting because the team is just not ready to take the feedback of viewers.

#no offence #pls don't bash
orpi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
MUWAAAHHH BIG KISSS TO YOU LOVE YA~~~!!
nandini-sb thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
The problem is not parth n niti being disinterested
Every creative writer or director have their own ways of work their own creativity
A show is at the end is a team work
It is not that magic is lost or chemistry is lost
It is just different from what it's used to be
In s1 it is abt new love all intense
Now it is abt a couple in relationship who trust each other understand each other
This tym it only took one lil explanation from nandu to clear manik doubts abt his replacement
Unlike previous incident like musicana or soha fake murder
SamAina_yudkbh thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
for me , i am searching the old spark between the leads.
i am both parth and niti fan. i love their acting. but now a days, i feel niti is akward in manan scenes. her smile seems fake. she looks in confusion about her expressions and many times she becomes blank !

and i feel really really bad! i know she is working hard and all but somehow she is not being able to pull out nandini out of herself when she is in manan scenes. she is such an amazing actress! throughout during season 1 and for first 33 episodes of season 2 she has proven to be a very very good actress! what has happened to her, i don't know but she is 100% not comfortable around parth!

and yes! i am craving for a tight passionate manan wala hug!
-QueenlyChitra- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
omg right i just love ur post and pics sue 😳
damn true yar manan are still there forever hamesha ❤️
MaNan are not changed the magic feelings love care support protecting and trust everything is still there ❤️
the unit is new atmosphere is different some one from cast is leaving every now and then also the storyline is not so good so they should work hard on it and bring some good new chracters
otherwise pani manan are awesome and beautiful as always love them always 🤗
Edited by -ChitraRocking- - 9 years ago
kimnana thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
beautiful caps sue ...manan will never lose their charm
they have power to affect us without speaking even...😊 they r wonderful
n platinum couple of t.v ⭐️
priakachan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
I am reposting something that I posted in another thread too. Firstly...the magic thing...
I would say...Sue...when U make a post..the kind of words U put in..the pictures U put in..U try to present it more aesthetically. We can do anything in 2 ways. Season 1 and Season 2 difference is the presentation. Presentation creates the magic. It's not that the characters evolved or anything of the sort. I mean...even in the Diwali season of last year..when Manik was gifted the lamp by Nandini and then she trips and falls on him and they are eye-locking and his hand travels over her hand and down to her bare waist...I didn't feel that she cringed or acted as if it affected her. She was more into gazing in Manik's eyes. I felt that Nandini did act awkward in certain scenes but then in some later romantic scenes..her expressions were more of bold and romantic rather than shy. 😉😆

Now I read a lot of posts blaming Niti of the lack of chemistry. Some said that it's coz Parth suddenly entered the show.

Personally I would say...it's neither Niti's fault nor Parth's nor that of any of the actors that the impact is not as huge as that of Season 1 specially in romantic scenes.

It is the track, plot, storyline and the direction and the way the characters are showing changed personalities like a more angelic Alya, a more friendly Mukti, a more lively Dhruv and Nandini who gets distracted fast😆...their new looks..(hairstyles, dress etc), the bgm, the settings, all these are making changes in the way things are presented to us. I feel...a major factor is the presentation.

Just go back to Season 1 and check the look that Nandini and Manik had in the initial few episodes. Yes they were younger..but Nandini was less glamorous then..less makeup, hairstyle and that gave her a more simpler look. The way she used to smile and cry was so different...now the way she smiles is a bit more seasoned smile.😆

The way Manik acted was so different atleast in the few initial episodes. First he was monster agree...but then again his hairstyling..the kind of clothes he used to wear..the way he reacted. Manik had this hesitant reaction at points, he used to sort of look very disturbed, very wavering...like the part where Rishabh gets the first attack and Manik sees it and his expressions are really interesting there. That is the Manik I first noticed. The way..his eyes were looking around here and there..and the way he said "Smile..." U are my spot so smile.." and the part he says Rishabh is very lucky because he has you...and the way he points his finger..his expressions watch it and see. U can even say that...that old Manik is twin brother of Manik of Season 2!😆

That Manik is so different in many ways from this Manik. Maybe both their characters evolved. But now Manik's smiles are relaxed, calmed down a bit flirtatious and more romantic and Nandini is also cool around Manik but her smile is sort of friendly more than romantic. 😆 Before Manik used to bite his lower lips..but now I don't see that much!😉

Even in romantic scenes..the way both of them used to look...all depends on the suggestions of the director and director is to guide them with expression etc.

U know..whenever I watch Season 2...I find their looks..the background music...etc totally disconnected with Season 1. If we take for instance...the kind of songs that was used when there were moments of Manik and Nandini together.

Let me put a few examples:~

(1) The scene of Manik and Nandini in store room...one of the most romantic parts...I would say... Manik asks Nandini to climb up the stool and Nandini hesitates a bit..then the way they react when their fingers touch. Nandini has this different sort of gazing...as if she is a bit shocked and then the expressions she gave when she put her palm on Manik's shoulder and Manik took his hand off the stool and perhaps wanted to hold her or he was backing off and they were gazing into each others eyes..a light wind blew (MaNan alone time)...don't know..but what I noticed most was in that scene...the song that was playing was ... "Sham" from "Aisha"


Watch the video of this song and then watch the way the song is applied in the MaNan scene in the store room...just a few seconds and we'll realize that it looks more beautiful in the few seconds of Manik and Nandini more than in the original movie video itself.

Watch this episode where this song is applied on MaNan and U will realize what I meant



Or even the scene where Manik comes to Nandini's house as he was missing Nandini and Nandini is wondering if Manik knew of Dhruv's proposal even before Manik and Nandini expressed their love to each other..that scene..just first few minutes..where Manik is in car and the song when Manik remembers Nandini in the past and when "Bin tere" song plays..the way Nandini throws the car key..the way Manik painfully looks at Nandini and goes away and her reaction after that..look at them...with the simple appearance ( Nandini with less makeup look...simple dress etc) the scene itself looks so pure. It is the beauty of the presentation. I'm meaning this episode:~

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CE_v1Tcovqo

We think that it is all about actors...but lots more is there to it. Even a romantic scene...a simple romantic scene can be made beautiful with the right kind of music, the right kind of setting...the right kind of looks ( as in dress, accessories..look of the actor/actress including hairstyle)...the right kind of expressions and even the slow motions that we even not think about. I mean...people look even more handsome/beautiful in slow motion when their hair move with the breeze or their eyes open slowly or even minutest lip movements. All this added a lot to MaNan scenes. Like I said..if I speak of MaNan scenes alone now the presentation of romance between MaNan and the way it was presented before was entirely different.

Now leaving MaNan scenes...coming to the storyline...I would truly love it...if

(1) Nandini makes Aryaman realize that Manik is the only one she can ever love and him going after her is a total waste of time.

(2) Aryaman realizing the fact and to take a break from Nandini starts hanging around more with Navya and perhaps he starts taking an interest in helping Navya with Abeer and he becomes a support system to Navya..because I feel Navya needs Aryaman more than Nandini (taking into account the way she cares for Aryaman too)😆😛

(3) After Dhruv leaves...I feel maybe a friendship track between Alya and the boss can start and maybe he motivates her to move on in life.

(4) The two adoptive characters should turn out to be fakes and Fab 4 should teach him & her a good lesson in their Season 1 style!😆

(5) More MaNan scenes with good background songs (they can even bring old songs like Ishq bulava, jaise mera tu, zehnaseeb etc)...make Nandini appear a bit less glamorous (less lipstick and stuff...she looks like a doll more that way)😆 and make her have a simpler sweeter look and make Manik and Nandini go on a foreign trip or something...like going on rollercoaster..Nandini getting scared to get on rides and Manik taking her on some adventure sports...then visiting some places like Thailand or something..taking selfies together and then sitting by the beach eating cone icecream and both fighting over one icecream😆 and discussing about their past...such moments can bring tons more romance.

Please dear CV if U intend to bring a MaNan scene..make sure not to sandwich an Aryaman scene or Navya-Mukti scene etc in between. Give one full episode..ie; 20 minutes of MaNan in a stretch. I feel fans would atleast rewatch that single episode. Agree??😳

Note: I re-checked my post and I'm unable to view the video I posted..but the video opened when I copy pasted on browser..try it and do watch the differences in presentation. Same song...two presentations..which one U liked more..do comment!😳
Edited by priakachan - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".