Be a True Indian.... - Page 3

First of all, this is not a topic worth discussing. U say u r an Indian and talking all non-sense things?

Hey we Indians are quite open hearted when its a question of admiring talent. Thats how Amanat got around 7 lacs votes from India. There are many people who really admire Amanat. So please don't bring the issue of Regional voting.

Instead you should admire the voting spirit of we Indians.

And why this lecturebazi is not applied for Non-Indians? I really wonder if any Pakistani votes for any ONE Indian contestant.

trishanku3
Senior Member



Joined: 21 August 2007
Location: India
Gender: Male
Posts: 471 Posted: 30 September 2007 at 2:23pm | IP Logged

------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------

mita1202 wrote:
I am an Indian and Hindu. I feel really bad because I hear other Indians say that Amanat is the best singer but they will not vote for him because he is a Pakistani.That is unfair. This is the chance for Indians to prove that we are open minded and religion or nationality do not play a role when it comes to justice. We Indians are different. All that I can say is if you think Amanat deserves your vote, please don't stop yourself. He is a 18 yr old kid and if he loses because he is from Pakistan it will convey a very negative message about Indians.
India is progressing and so are Indians. Prove it.... Vote for who you truly believe is the best singer... not a good person. This competition is not about voting for a good person it is only about the best singer...
In my opinion Amanat and Aneek are both great singers.... though their mentors are very different. While HR is always promoting Aneek whereas ID never begs for votes like HR.


Please don't generalise, who do you think voted for him to make him the top 3 contestant, don't you think Indians made him the top vote gainer in some of the previous episodes. Some of us like all the three singers and wouldn't mind if any one of them wins, and mind you most of us are Indians.
One more thing is why is this morality lecture only for Indians?
Bear it in mind Indians have welcomed in open arms & admired overseas singers like NFAK, Ghulam Ali, Salma agha, Runa Laila, Atif Islam & bands like Fuzon, Junoon, Strings, so don't have any aspersions about Amanat even if he doesn't win.
Now each mentor has his own method of promoting his protege, HR does go overboard sometimes since he suffers from the horrible foot in the mouth disease, but there are times when he has begged votes even for Amanat & Raja. ID & VS do it in more subdued manner which naturally escapes attention.

If the decision to vote only on the basis of singing & music leaving aside regional bias is preached, the same yardstick should be applied towards all those hate-Aneek-for-his-mentors-antics posts and asking to eliminate Aneek to eliminate HR. Aren't there other ways to do it instead of punishing the wrong person for a crime committed by somebody else.

Kumar 👏 👏 👏for your analytical approach and quick thinking and powerful writing skills.After all A Vivekanada bhaktha.You are blessed by your guru.

After reading so many of these vote for Amanat Indians, I want to say that this is not a good way to compaign for votes. So by making this false accusation they want people to just and only vote for Amanat. Come on let people vote for whoever they like even if it is Amanat.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Amanat is in top 3 speaks volume about Indian junta's support for him. So in my opinion it is unfair to blame Indians at all.

My take on the voting-
There is no doubt any anyone's mind that several Indians are voting for Amanat. He clearly would have been out earlier w/o a solid Indian vote bank.
I think the original oster is commenting not about all Indians but THOSE Indians who prefer Amanat as a singer, and yet shy away from voting for him for political reasons.
I am a Hindu of Indian origin and have nothing against Indians supporting Raja and Aneek for their singing ability. I am not too proud of those FEW voting for one of them just because they are Indian. Let us not deny, there are those although relatively few :)

@ the ones mentioned in bold above- It doesn't matter whether Indian contestants will be invited to participate / win in other countries. May be not, but so what! Can't we choose to be better? Shouldn't we vote for a foreigner if we prefer him as a singer?

I would like to see a Pakistani opening a thread telling his/her country folks that they should not vote for Amanat just because he is a Pakistani. Indians are already quite inclusive.

when did anybody said that i am voting for raja or aneek casue they are indian..please send me the links..i dont believe till i see

one more thing about we indians..we have welcome artist from pakistan all the time...adnan sami,nusrat fateh ali..................list is long they all have made name and fame here..but how many indian had made their name/fame in pakistan..most of the time visa is denied or they say its attack on their culture.only few artist were able to go their and perform on stage..indian movies does not get officially released there..i have read these news all the time in newspapers..

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

I have a question:

Should we call the people who don't vote for Amanat, "FALSE INDIANS". 😛

😆 yes to prove once patriotism we should vote for Amanat......

gosh who wants to be called False Indians.......😆

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

My take on the voting-
There is no doubt any anyone's mind that several Indians are voting for Amanat. He clearly would have been out earlier w/o a solid Indian vote bank.
I think the original oster is commenting not about all Indians but THOSE Indians who prefer Amanat as a singer, and yet shy away from voting for him for political reasons.
I am a Hindu of Indian origin and have nothing against Indians supporting Raja and Aneek for their singing ability. I am not too proud of those FEW voting for one of them just because they are Indian. Let us not deny, there are those although relatively few :)

@ the ones mentioned in bold above- It doesn't matter whether Indian contestants will be invited to participate / win in other countries. May be not, but so what! Can't we choose to be better? Shouldn't we vote for a foreigner if we prefer him as a singer?

Entirely agree wth u mermaid_QT..People r not reading the post properly n simply giving some negative comments..