Sad music, sad faces

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Vidya

@Shinya

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#61

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

She is not helpless and when she wants she exhibits her bravery.
She is a sinner because she adamantly refuses all the help that is offered by responsible persons.

Who has offered her help? Anandi ?

Telling her that I rescue child brides, is called offering help ??

Quote

leavesandwaves

@leavesandwaves

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: Shinya

Who has offered her help? Anandi ?
Telling her that I rescue child brides, is called offering help ??

No one will go and say, ' I am offering help'. It is understood. When the poojari wanted to inform police, it is a kind of help. When anandi gave her her visitng cards and told her to call at any time, it is called help. When MLA came to their house, best opportunity to tell him the truth and get help against Akheraj was lost. Mangala was going outside so many times and she could even search for some help. At the mela also she hushed up which eventually led to Gopal's death.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

SPuja

@SPuja

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: Shinya

She is not helpless and when she wants she exhibits her bravery.
She is a sinner because she adamantly refuses all the help that is offered by responsible persons.

Who has offered her help? Anandi ?

Telling her that I rescue child brides, is called offering help ??

"Help" that is being discussed are - Anandi telling her that she rescues child brides - so Mangala should have immediately sent Nimboli with Anandi - read in the forum that since Akhra/Harki etc. were not there, mangala had great opportunity. As if the girl is just a piece of non-living thing - give it to anybody. Mangala actually hid that Nimboli is child bride at that time - so she became sinner.

Next "help"came when pandit was telling that he will contact police as it is great injustice to Nimboli that second marriage of Kundan was going to happen. Mangala asked him not to go to police. Pandit was not against Kundan Nimboli marriage is not relevant here because pandit is not being criticised.

Next when Anandi came in search of Mannu-Pooja - Mangala again prevented Nimboli-Anandi meeting - so her sins increased - this was another opportunity to get rid of that girl that selfish managala missed.

Then came vidahyak sa - and again Mangala "helped" akhera when she told Urmi is her daughter - so she is certified sinner.

It does not matter that all this only indicated that Mangla does not want Nimboli to be taken away from her - a sign of possessiveness. She herself called Yashoda - and Yashoda ultimately had to let go of Krishna. A lot of things forum members interpret giving examples - so let me give this example - she will be heartbroken, she will resist but ultimately she will send Nimboli to her mother.

And all these examples are not helps - nobody offered her help to give Nimboli a good life - at least I have not seen it. But then I miss so many dialogues and some episodes also - so correct me if I am wrong and someone actually told Mangala that they will help Nimboli get a good life if she sends her with them.

Quote

seraal

@seraal

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#64

Originally posted by: Shinya

I do not agree with the bold statement simply because had mangala known how to free her, she would have never kept her there.

She always wanted to protect the child, she would have been more than happy to free her from that house. But she did not know how to. Or probably she felt there was more danger outside the house to live alone with a child.

So, I will never call a helpless person a sinner.

...if mangla had known some better opportunities she would have...so far sh is possessive about nimboli so she is not using anandi for the security of the little girl nimboli-- she is becoming weaker in parting nimboli from her,,,,,

Quote

Vidya

@Shinya

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#65

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

No one will go and say, ' I am offering help'. It is understood. When the poojari wanted to inform police, it is a kind of help. When anandi gave her her visitng cards and told her to call at any time, it is called help. When MLA came to their house, best opportunity to tell him the truth and get help against Akheraj was lost. Mangala was going outside so many times and she could even search for some help. At the mela also she hushed up which eventually led to Gopal's death.

Poojari wanted to call the police, but was that a help ?? It would mean death for both of them.

Second point, anandi offered help - I wrote many times that anandi instilled fear in her mind. Mangala felt she would never ever see nimboli again if anandi takes her away. This stopped her from asking anandi for help and even lying to jagya that urmi was her daughter.

Had anandi made it clear to her that parents are allowed to meet the girls she rescues, she would have agreed to send her with anandi.

We all know that she does not want to be separated from nimboli, but that does not mean she does not want a good life for nimboli. When she is convinced a certain person/organization will offer nimboli a good life, she will definitely send her away from that hell.

Quote

kate-nic

@kate-nic

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#66

if cvs have not proved Anandi as the most right soul According to her fans she is not flawless Cvs have never portrayed her perfect then why her fans mind so much when people criticize her she is wrong? They all the time keep covering her wrong as well Her flawed wrong thinking, her wrong acts Her fans keep on justifying everything and keep blaming all others in nonsense way Be it Mangala , be it Jagya , be it Ganga ( like Ganga has thrown Anandi out of house which was never shown in serial )What is this ?

Quote

attiya1.3

@attiya1.3

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#67

but i loved the epi...perfectly executed

Quote

1 ... 3 4 5 6 7

Sad music, sad faces - Page 7

Related Topics

Explore Topics