Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
In today's episode, Mangala gave Nimboli some badam as a reward for sleeping outside kothri to give company to Urmi... I was really impressed by Mangala's act... She is teaching her good and bad through rewards and punishment.
Then Nimboli lied to mangala that she does not have to go to school as her master has gone to get books and she smiled cunningly ... I hope mangala spanks her when she finds this out from Kishore.

One more thing, Why was nimboli so confused when she heard the word 'petse'? Has she never in her 12 yrs heard anyone getting pregnant ?

[Since leaves has gone missing, I had to make this thread. I am covering for leaves 😆]

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.7k

Users

8

Likes

74

Frequent Posters

SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
A few things got clear by this episode.
  • Mangala knows what is right and wrong and Nimboli has learnt this helping others from Mangala. Mangala also helped Urmi and so did Nimboli. Mangala rewarded Nimboli after learning about her help to Urmi.
  • Mangala saved Nandini - Nandini had almost pleading looks when she saw Mangala (how did they made a small infant have so perfect acting?).
  • It must be Mangala who cared for that infant - that is why the clothes were with Mangala. It appears that she preserved the clothes so that the girl could be identified if someone comes looking for that girl. It was not her intention to treat the girl as her own - otherwise she should have discarded those clothes.
  • She got attached with this girl after caring for her over the years (we are presuming many things already - so some positive presumption about a side character).

Nimboli did a big mistake by bunking school - it will be in her interest if Kishore gets to meet Mangala instead of Harki or Akhera when he comes to complain/inquire about Nimboli missing school. Akhera may still ask Nimboli to go to school because he has to care for his image - but Harki may use this to make Nimboli drop out of school.

SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
And I agree with TM regarding Nimboli wondering about pregnancy. In order to show her innocence - creatives make her look like dumb. One of the major ill effect of child marriage is - early pregnancy, increased maternal and infant mortality (because of malnourished underage mothers) and large family size and less gap between two children (there is hardly any family planning in those backward areas). Creatives did not show this crucial ill effect of child marriage. Their balika vadhus are cute, well made up, healthy girls. And a 12 years old does not know any thing about pregnancy/child birth 😆.
Creatives perhaps want to spread the word that bal-vivah is wrong because balak var and his family will always behave like monsters. Balika vadhu will do household work and will be starved, locked in store room and got beaten up. And she will eventually get a sautan 😆.
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
nandini getting irritating day by day .she can follow maasa order she can bear massa harsh words she can do all house hold work happily but cannot tolerate kishore sweet scolding
harki always speak badly to nandini but nandini never felt so much bad by harki words but just one sweet scolding from master kishore nandini is feeling bad? and even not going to school to study?

I just hope mangala this timedo not spare nandini so easily because nandini did big mistake this time by lieing about school
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: SPuja

A few things got clear by this episode.

  • Mangala knows what is right and wrong and Nimboli has learnt this helping others from Mangala. Mangala also helped Urmi and so did Nimboli. Mangala rewarded Nimboli after learning about her help to Urmi.
  • Mangala saved Nandini - Nandini had almost pleading looks when she saw Mangala (how did they made a small infant have so perfect acting?).
  • It must be Mangala who cared for that infant - that is why the clothes were with Mangala. It appears that she preserved the clothes so that the girl could be identified if someone comes looking for that girl. It was not her intention to treat the girl as her own - otherwise she should have discarded those clothes.
  • She got attached with this girl after caring for her over the years (we are presuming many things already - so some positive presumption about a side character).

Nimboli did a big mistake by bunking school - it will be in her interest if Kishore gets to meet Mangala instead of Harki or Akhera when he comes to complain/inquire about Nimboli missing school. Akhera may still ask Nimboli to go to school because he has to care for his image - but Harki may use this to make Nimboli drop out of school.


Hats off to you, SPuja, for these points. 👏


It was said mangala saved her to fulfill her motherly instincts. In yesterday's episode they made it clear.

It was also shown how she teaches good values to nimboli... When shivam had played a prank on abhi by filling his school bag with old newspapers, anandi did the same to him to teach him a lesson... At that time, anandi was applauded, her teaching method was so perfect.

But now mangala's teaching is said be insignificant... nimboli's bigger reward was friendship with urmi, badam were nothing. 😆

No matter what, mangala will be put down. 😆

Edited by Shinya - 10 years ago
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
@Surabhi,... I think she is not afraid of scolding. But she feels bored in school. When he was teaching barakhadi, she was the only one yawning and looking here and there.
rohini55 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7


Shinya,

thanks for this. I was wondering if we can start an episode discussion thread like they have in Ashoka forum and some others.


This way, you can continue the discussion without having to open new threads everyday to discuss a particular episode. Other specific things can always be discussed separately by anyone opening a thread of their choice.

I'm suggesting this because leaves has disappeared. Of course, if you want to start a topic each day like she used to do, that's welcome too. I'd be more than happy to respond with my comments.

Because BV has returned to serious, meaningful discussion after a long time. This is the only forum where fangirling is limited to one or two threads. Most other places have only ATs and fan fiction, all of which are just drool and gush fest.

Sorry in case I have hurt anyone. I'm not against ATs or FFs (to each her own)but personally I'm happier discussing content.


I really like that we are able to use the episodes to critically analyse social attitudes, character development etc

So what do you say?


Edited by rohini55 - 10 years ago
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Rohini, earlier episide discussions used to happen on WU thread for the episode. And that was a practice for a long time.

Don't know why but we have diverted from there.

And other specific issues were generally opened up in separate threads by any member.

I am just sharing the info.
Edited by Missesha - 10 years ago
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: rohini55



Shinya,

thanks for this. I was wondering if we can start an episode discussion thread like they have in Ashoka forum and some others.


This way, you can continue the discussion without having to open new threads everyday to discuss a particular episode. Other specific things can always be discussed separately by anyone opening a thread of their choice.

I'm suggesting this because leaves has disappeared. Of course, if you want to start a topic each day like she used to do, that's welcome too. I'd be more than happy to respond with my comments.

Because BV has returned to serious, meaningful discussion after a long time. This is the only forum where fangirling is limited to one or two threads. Most other places have only ATs and fan fiction, all of which are just drool and gush fest.

Sorry in case I have hurt anyone. I'm not against ATs or FFs (to each her own)but personally I'm happier discussing content.


I really like that we are able to use the episodes to critically analyse social attitudes, character development etc

So what do you say?



This is a brilliant idea. Please do start an episode discussion thread.

In fact, I started this thread after waiting for quite some time for someone to start one... Then, I could not wait any longer as I was so impressed by Mangala's teaching method 😆. She is an illiterate woman, not someone who is a graduate with Hons. Yet she knows how to deal with children.


rohini55 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10


Shinya, I'm a distilled dumbo when it comes to things like this. How do you open an episode discussion thread?

And will people keep up with it?

Missesha, I remember that too but lately I'm noticing that WU threads get locked up within the second or third page -- that is even before discussions can take off. Don't know why that is the case.

My understanding is that an EDT is allowed to run the full course like ATs.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".