Episode 37: Humraahi headed towards a Manzil OR ?

AeDilHaiMushkil thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

I'm sorry I won't be discussing the other aspects of the Episode in this post tonight..

Bt before we move on.. I HAVE to Say..

Mr. Khalid Shaikh.. You're the man! 👏 Beneath that ruthless, funny exterior, lies a lion who is territorial, and will rip apart anyone who messes with him or his cubs.. (His reporters and his channel..)

That thunderous growl would have shaken up Kishen, the two faced rat for sure!

If not, Panditji's protest march and your promise will ensure that his film is doomed.. 👏


Are Kabir and Ananya -

Humraahi headed towards a Manzil OR ? towards a Massive heartbreak? Breach of trust, and the repercussions that shall follow?

Oh well.. I need a breather.. And a shoulder to cry upon, if our fears actually come true..

RN-Naveen : *Nooo..* Wails like a TV-serial saree-clad bahu..

Is Kabir jinxed with self-guilt just like Raj was? 😲

*Nahiii...*

That plot has haunted me for a long long time.. It ruined one of my most favorite love stories.. 😭 🥺

Okay.. back to normal.. (Sort of!)

So.. When she questions him about her father, and the case - he pretends to keep a calm face, doesn't get rattled, doesn't show his shock/surprise or a hint of recognition..

He pretends to not remember anything about the case citing the age-old excuse in the book.. Kaafi samay pehle ki baat..'

And she pleads with him, to help her seek the truth about her father..

A : Meri manzil ki raah..'

K : Kya hai tumhari manzil?

How poignantly beautiful was that conversation!! 👏

Their emotions restrained, their guards let down, their eyes doing the talking..


A lot of things swam to the surface today..

Ananya's father was released on bail, but he never returned to his family..

Bahar ka shor toh band ho jayega, Ananya.. Lekin andar ke shor ka kya?'

Sudhir Kashyap was consumed by torment, public humiliation and as his daughter puts it, by the trial by the media'.

And yet there was one man who wrote in his defense..

Of course, Kabir may not have been THE Kabir Sharma back then, but he took a stance and pointed out that there was a chance that her father could have been innocent..


And Sudhir Kashyap's daughter, Kabir's new dost' clings onto that piece of paper for 8 years!

It's her inspiration.. Her only ray of hope.. Her strength..

That one article earned Kabir respect in her eyes and a belief that no matter what, he would always stand up for the truth..

So, why now? When he is the only raah' to her manzil', why does he hold the information back?

Is it only because it's not the right time and situation, or does he want to put her through another infamous test of his?

Or there's a third reason, which I dread to even imagine!

If it's the former, then it does make sense.. He will open up to her, reveal information and help her while she searches for her father..

But that's not Kabir Sharma's style, and so I doubt if it's THE reason..

The second one seems quite plausible..

From the jaane se pehle, it is quite obvious that this, what they're going through is a web of danger and deceit. Of emotions, of traumatic experiences, of tests of strength and courage..

Their emotions make them, and also BREAK them..

He knows how quickly, and gravely Ananya gets attached to a story, and pursues it as if her life depends on it..

So, is he trying to calm her down first, and then peel off layers from the mystery one by one?

Maybe, he too doesn't know much about what happened to her father, and will have to go digging deeper?

OR

The third and the most unnerving possibility..

(@Rinnie, Pankhuri, Malika, Dexter, violette.. - Curse our manhoos kaali zubaans..)

Does he hold himself responsible? Was it the guilt that showed on his face? 😲

Yes, we know that Kabir did not prosecute her father like the others in the media..

But he was working on the story.. He even wrote a hard-hitting article.. And I absolutely refuse to believe that a man as intelligent as Kabir Sharma does not remember crucial information about the case!

So what is it that holds him back?

Is it his inability to put an end to her father's humiliation?

He's not above the law, but he had the power of the fourth estate with him.. If the media had accused and convicted Sudhir Kashyap, Kabir Sharma could have taken a stance against it, and questioned the verdict..

But did he?

Looks like he didn't follow it up.. Yes, he took a stance but what happened next? Why wasn't Kabir or his POV on the case heard of, by the Kashyap family?

And why isn't Kabir owning up to the truth?

Swearing on my 12 years of experience of being hopelessly in love with this man's eyes, I can say without a doubt that this isn't as simple as it looks.. 😆

Either he's genuinely cooking up some plans in his head, and buying time for himself and her;

OR he is weighed down by the guilt..

The timing too could not have been more perfect!

She asks him if they can be friends.. And he agrees to it.. It's a deal sealed for a lifetime!

Again, such a simple, overused scene, but their picture-perfect emotions made the difference..

Ananya's slight hesitation that she might cross the boundaries set by their professional hierarchy and Kabir's superior position, her faith that he might actually accept her friendship.. And Kabir's typically unique manner of accepting it..

They didn't shake hands, but a consensus was reached.. They're friends now! 👏


He knows she believes in him; he is her idol and her inspiration.. So, what does THE Kabir Sharma have to say about it? (I WANT and NEEED a MONOLOGUE!) 😡

Is it the fear of losing a friend', his present , and his future due to the mistakes/lack of foresight in the past?

Was Sudhir Kashyap's story running in parallel to the mayhem in his own married life?

Was Shreya and his bitter parting one of the reasons why he could not follow up the story to its end, and get Sudhir Kashyap acquitted?

Was this the case that blew up Tarini Pal's cover, and forced her to withdraw from the world of journalism?

Is this story the reason why a confident, strong man crumbles into a vulnerable mess, and is bogged down by guilt?

Soo many questions.. But we have no answers..

Maybe yes, or maybe not.. But one thing is for sure..

Sudhir Kashyap and the mystery around him is going to MAKE and/or BREAK Kabir and Ananya's relationship now on..

Though Kabir couldn't have gone out of the way and proven her father's innocence, Ananya will be forced to believe that he could have!

The girl is waaay too emotional, and vulnerable when it comes to her father.. And it won't be easy for her to differentiate black from white..

That one darn line from LRL still haunts me..

Naina to Rajveer : Aapne aapke dost ko bachane ke liye kuch kyun nahi kiya?'

I only hope that we don't get to hear Ananya saying it to him..

The Jaane se pehle has me confused.. But somehow, I feel we know the answer to it..

Was it only about Ananya's impatience, vulnerability, fear of losing someone or was the pointer always pointing towards Mr. Sharma?

Coz come what may, he too is just a mortal..

Yes, he has gained respect, recognition and now a dost', but will his past come back to haunt him and knock down everything that he holds dear to him?

It's obvious that Ananya's paths will finally entwine with Kabir's.. They are each other's Raah', and Humraahi', seeking a Manzil..'

But will they hold hands and walk along, or will they be forced apart temporarily, before they reunite forever?

(@Rinnie : Dost, you asked me the same thing, didn't you? I fear it might be the latter..

But if it is, KaYa will end up being a rock-solid couple, with only each other as their greatest strength and weakness..)


OR there's a huge possibility that I'm reading too much into it.. 😆


And yes, I do think Kabir flirted with her to distract her, to cheer her up and to buy himself some time and respite..

-----


All yours! Feel free to agree, disagree and discusss..

Love,

Avantika.. 🤗

Edited by Fantasia_junkie - 10 years ago


DO NOT COPY THIS POST AS THIS IS EXCLUSIVE TO INDIA FORUMS


Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

3.1k

Users

18

Likes

106

Frequent Posters

rendezvousvin thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Well written and analyzed post...
sonyjknum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
I agree with you
I think Kabir's own family might be involved in that case his brother maybe
And he might have since broken all ties with his family
Also is it possible that his family has handin Ananya's fathet's disappearance and he knew it hence the guilt
I dont think Ananya will accuse him of not bringing out the truth just a guess
But yes his family and Tarini are all linked here and why do I have a feeling that Anurag's condition is also.linked
A
Edited by sonyjknum - 10 years ago
BedouinMe thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Fantastic analysis as always Avantika di !!! And thanks for posting it a bit early so that I could read it and go to sleep. :-)
Now, coming to Kabir's expressions when Ananya reveals the facts about her identity and the media trial her father went through. Well, Kabir's eyes made it clear that he knows and remembers a lot more about Mr.Kashyap's case than what he claims. He couldnt look into Ananya's eyes for once. There is a sense of guilt as well, but I am quite hopeful that its not as grave as Rajveer's. I also have a nagging feeling that Kabir might be aware of Mr.Kashyap's whereabouts.
It was revealed today that Kabir had worked for "Janta times" for only 3 days before he moved on to join Delhi Kranti. Khurana had earlier said that Kabir had been working on Mr.Kashyap's story before joining DK. Which makes it clear, that the article Ananya treasures is actually a peice of Janta times. And probably it was this strife for truth, which caused Kabir to lose his job. A struggling Kabir might have got a secured job in JN after a lot of tribulations. And also it might be so that somebody at the same Janta times along with the actual culprits of the pharma scam had framed Kabir's alleged affair with Tarini only to defame him and kick him out of his job. Also from Shreya's voiceover we know that she had left Kabir due to his failing career and his affair with Tarini. May be this was the time they got divorced and Kabir was forced to believe that power is far more important than emotions. This may be reason why he had taken himself away from the Sudhir Kashyap case and that is where the sense of guilt comes from..
Well, if this happens to be the case, then I think this might be a minor hindrance in KaYa's journey together but not a major roadblock, unless the CVs go for something OTT.
Sagi97 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Yes, Avantika Di. Thats what I thought.
Even I thought something on those lines. Some sort of guilt or hidden feeling.
Or, lets just be fair. He wanted to dig in the case more before commenting on it.

On the other hand, with introduction of a new character (Kabir's brother and Bhabhi as well) there is a setting for family politics as well.

Hope not.

paradigm thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Great minds think alike. I had exactly the same theory on Ananya's father and Kabir. He was probably too caught up in his marital tangles to do more
Here's a link to the topic I made.

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4394185
AAKMH2 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#7


Amazing post like always 👏

I agree with all da points


Kabir was hiding, lying , flirting = daal mein kaala.

And the reason was not just to cheer her up...i think it is much deep , down.

He remember sudheer kshyap...remember very well.

sonyjknum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
I have one moredoubt If he was really seriously guilty Do you think he would not have hesitated in flirting with her as normally happens with our heroes they tend towithdraw themselves
AeDilHaiMushkil thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: BedouinMe

Fantastic analysis as always Avantika di !!! And thanks for posting it a bit early so that I could read it and go to sleep. :-)

Now, coming to Kabir's expressions when Ananya reveals the facts about her identity and the media trial her father went through. Well, Kabir's eyes made it clear that he knows and remembers a lot more about Mr.Kashyap's case than what he claims. He couldnt look into Ananya's eyes for once. There is a sense of guilt as well, but I am quite hopeful that its not as grave as Rajveer's. I also have a nagging feeling that Kabir might be aware of Mr.Kashyap's whereabouts.
It was revealed today that Kabir had worked for "Janta times" for only 3 days before he moved on to join Delhi Kranti. Khurana had earlier said that Kabir had been working on Mr.Kashyap's story before joining DK. Which makes it clear, that the article Ananya treasures is actually a peice of Janta times. And probably it was this strife for truth, which caused Kabir to lose his job. A struggling Kabir might have got a secured job in JN after a lot of tribulations. And also it might be so that somebody at the same Janta times along with the actual culprits of the pharma scam had framed Kabir's alleged affair with Tarini only to defame him and kick him out of his job. Also from Shreya's voiceover we know that she had left Kabir due to his failing career and his affair with Tarini. May be this was the time they got divorced and Kabir was forced to believe that power is far more important than emotions. This may be reason why he had taken himself away from the Sudhir Kashyap case and that is where the sense of guilt comes from..
Well, if this happens to be the case, then I think this might be a minor hindrance in KaYa's journey together but not a major roadblock, unless the CVs go for something OTT.


Haha.. I've had to sacrifice something dear to.me to make an early post.. 😆
Anyhow..
Absolutely plausible and wonderful analysis yourself..

Which is why Kabir can never forget the story.. His entire struggle, career and personal tragedies might revolve around this story..
His divorce, Tarini's plight, his failures and his short stint at JT..
It all might boil down to Sudhir Kashyap's story..

And yes, I too think Kabir might have a fair idea of what happened to her father after the bail.. Whether he knows his current whereabouts or no remains to be seen, but Kabir is definitely the key to the mystery..

Oh I really do not want the OTT and hate story crap.. I'd really love it if they show KaYa handling it maturely.. But the path is going to be filled with pricking thorns - the sharpest one being Kabir's past..
440733 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Avani, let us give each other support Because even I need a shoulder to cry on after today's episode. 😭

They weren't kidding when they promised an INTENSE love story, yeh toh intense se bhi zyaada deep ho gaya hai yaar!
Kabir being a divorcee and his ex wife seems be the least of anyone's worries now 😆

The parellelisms to LRL is scarying the heck put of me. 😔 As you said, We definitely can't bare to go through that pain again. The pain of watching our most favorite and beloved ship die such a tragic death.

But I have hope, I am trying to keep that hope burning so that I can continue watching without dreading what is going to happen next. This is not RN, This is KaYa and I have a lot of hope that third times gonna be the charm for Rajeev and he will get his girl this time. *fingers crossed*

I am not going to go in depth regarding the Kashyap mystery and Kabir's involvement right now because I need more time and a clearer version of the episode with good quality to analyze that 😆

Rather I want to talk about KaYa and how this episode is becoming quite prophetic regarding their future. Avani, I truly feel there is a lot of hardship in store for Ananya more so than Kabir. I know many people will object saying that Ananya has more support and love from her family and friends whereas Kabir doesn't have as many as people as her but the fact is Ananya trusts Kabir more than anyone else in her world, she has such blind faith and dependence on him that if it breaks then she is going to be shattered. This is a girl who broke down so horribly after getting reprimanded by him during the Mahi case because she felt he broke the trust she had in him. Just imagine, now that they are friends and she has spilled every detail of her past, her manzil and her pain, it has changed the entire dynamic for her.
I felt really sad when she, so hesistantly, offers her friendship and even adds she will be satisfied if only he is there for her and could help her.

Ananya is still a girl, not yet a woman and this entire love story is going to change her completely. By the end of it, I'm expecting to see more stronger, mature and dignified Ananya to rise like a phoenix.

Kabir on the other hand He is reminding me too much of Raj right now except for the last part 😆 Raj would have blushed beet red and stammered if he tried that with Naina.

I definitely see Kabir developing very strong feelings for Ananya, a love that surpasses everything he holds important in his life. He won't be like Rajveer nor will he behave like Sujal.
Kabir is more in control than the former two, he will definitely play all his cards right until the crucial moment that Ananya figures it all out and Kabir loses control.

Avani, I definitely see a season 2 for this show because 94-93 episodes are not going to be enough to solve this entire mystery and develop that intense love story.

Yes, your right.
KaYa is going to have go their own separate paths before they are pulled back together to be bound by a thread of love that can never be broken. Their trust and love in each other is going to be tested in so many different ways, it may even tear them apart temporarily but eventually they will be bought back together stronger than ever. Because Kabir and Ananya maybe different in many aspects but their similar in one major aspect and that is loyalty. They are fiercely loyal and protective of the people they love. They have it in them to fight till the end for the people that are important to them.

Am very nervous and scared about what is going to happen next but at the same time, very anxious to see how the KaYa love story is going to develop.


P.S:
Its high time for a bloody monologue by Kabir regarding Ananya! 😡 😡
Give him his bottle and let him think of her! 😆
Edited by .Rinnie. - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".