When news is more valuable than life

tvbug2011 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Hello Guys, I am new to this forum, although I've been watching Reporters off and on since the start. I've dipped into the forum every now and then, but of late the serial has completely grabbed my attention. And today's episode roused me out of my silence to post. 😃

Today's was a fast-moving, adrenaline-driven episode. Intensity, chemistry, danger, fear, concern...a cauldron of emotions that threatened to swamp Kabir and Ananya, and held out the promise of a deepening bond forged from extreme circumstances. It made me do a little jig that the intensity I'd been waiting for has finally arrived. And Rajeev and Kritika were so sure-footed with their expressions that this episode was a joy to watch. Can't wait for what happens next.
The epi evoked very many emotions in me, but the emotion that remains is actually disbelief. Disbelief at the callousness displayed by Khalid and to a lesser extent by Malvika at the danger confronting two members of their staff and, more importantly, two human beings. Can any employer in this day and age actually knowingly put their employee's lives in danger? I just find it so unnerving that Khalid sends them off with a smile - no long scenario planning, no tension, no fear, no training, no plan B (that we know of)... no final pat on the back or extra firm handclasp, no sweat...Is news more valuable than human life? And Malvika's overarching concern is will Kabir make it to read the news on time!! Really!!
Kabir and Ananya's eagerness to cover this news even at risk to their lives also sounds a false note. Perhaps the CVs did not lay the ground for this development. But the single-minded focus on the 'news' even at the cost to their own safety is frankly unnerving.
Ananya's ignorance is defence - to an extent. I still can't believe any reporter would focus on getting 'exclusive news' from an outlaw/terrorist and willingly turn a blind eye to the danger this could put her in.
Kabir's attitude I find even more difficult to swallow - he's a seasoned reporter, who's supposedly been in this situation before, yet he allows both of them to walk into a potentially life-threatening situation with a smile. What protection could one man possibly offer a colleague against an army? With his seniority he could have banned Ananya from covering this news unless she put in place some basic caveats.
Does becoming No. 1 channel trump concern for life? I doubt this is the case in reality. Perhaps the script and screenplay need to be tweaked to strike the right note, otherwise it hints at some deep character flaws, which I don't want to see in such a promising serial. I hope the next few episodes will throw some light on this baffling attitude.
Please don't take this as bashing - I am critiqueing one aspect of today's epi, which struck a false note in an epi that on the whole I found deeply engrossing.
Edited by tvbug2011 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

2.7k

Users

14

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

milinda.shreyz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Sabs baisa !!
welcome to the forum ! aap khud ko rok nehi payi...lol !
807116 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
This thought crossed my mind too. My reasoning was, Ananya could be ignorant about it, but not Khalid and Kabir.
Khalid insisting both of them to sign the document (Channel will not be held responsible in the case of mishap; It shows, he was very well aware of what could happen). Kabir's smile, when Khalid was trying to convince Ananya shows, he was also aware of it. Despite that, he was willing to go. This makes me believe, he might have a back up plan (in the form of Khurana). Kabir might have handed over the telephone. What if he is carrying a transmitter? Fact is, he is still remaining calm.
Zannat18 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: flipfl0p

This thought crossed my mind too. My reasoning was, Ananya could be ignorant about it, but not Khalid and Kabir.

Khalid insisting both of them to sign the document (Channel will not be held responsible in the case of mishap; It shows, he was very well aware of what could happen). Kabir's smile, when Khalid was trying to convince Ananya shows, he was also aware of it. Despite that, he was willing to go. This makes me believe, he might have a back up plan (in the form of Khurana). Kabir might have handed over the telephone. What if he is carrying a transmitter? Fact is, he is still remaining calm.


I know this Kabir is making me confuse 😆
patdash thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Ditto.
How can Kabir not think about his aspect of situation? I am unable to relate this track.
Editor in Chief...mind of his own...cant be this naive or stupid.

😊
milinda.shreyz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
now about ur post baisa ! waise i have not yet watched the episode, so details toh pata nehi but i do know the gist and have understood the source of your displeasure . now, in actual life, journalists do take a lot of precautions and get police / army protections, and their superiors send them on daredevil missions keeping fingers crossed and keep close eye on them and spring into actions if anything wrong happens to them. but then yeh toh serial ki duniya hai bhai...njoy it with a pinch of salt.

And about kabir's taking risk, reporters do dare devil stunts in real life too...i have read some bloodchilling articles of reporters who went to interview the fearsome Virappan,the infamous forest brigand and sandalwood smuggler and that of srilankan militant leader pravakaran...how they were blindfolded, made to walk miles without any clue, how they were nearly stripped naked so that there would be no hidden gadget that can trace the secret location. and these reporters went there willingly most of the time knowing they could be hold as hostages or even be executed. kabir is that born daredevil type...so his part can be accepted and logically explained, baki sab , hehe ! serial mein chalta hai.
welcome to the party baisa ! I am soo sooo glad to see u here. post often, thik hai ?
archpai thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
HI,
I also want to add, the reporters reporting from war zone and terror hit areas as well.
Reporters who cover natural disasters, like earthquake, volcano, Tsunami, Avalanches etc.

They do risk their lives to get the news to us.It more like what Kabir said Kabar Nasha hai!!
They find their adrenaline high doing what they are doing.

Only thing to note in this case- Ananya did not expect the interview to go this way, she was ignorant of the challenges that will come thier way!! While Kabir very well knew how it would go and is fully informed.
BedouinMe thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Reporters do indulge in dangerous interviews and encounters for the sake of their viewers and readers. Many wanted criminals have been interviewed right at their respective dens, even in real life. Even in this case, Kabir and Ananya might have visibly lost all communication with the outer world. But then, hasnt Kabir already informed Khurana, who came over to discuss the whole plan out.. Hence, I dont think so far in case they have shown anything completely unrealistic, but then, its a teleserial, hence a little bit of inconsistency here and there will be found..
violette thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
I can understand ur displeasure.. and not jst this track the previous tracks too had its share of logic lapse and the characters acting out of thr character!😳
I really thot tht Kabir wud go in disguise and tht Khalid and Kabir might have some back plan in mind. We can never guess with Kabir!😳
But bcoz here a female reporter was involved who is so stupid immature and stubborn, I guess the seniors shud've warned her beforehand in strict terms. Thy have all been so unprofessional in handling the issue.
And yet the story is gripping and different from what we normally see on TV so yes its catching everyone's attention not tht it is 100% flawless!😳
but I can keep tht aside and enjoy the epi at the end of the day as long as it has something unique and entertaining to offer!
Plus the actors and acting is so good and such standard is not often seen on small screen!😳 We like each and every character with thr set of flaws. Here too thrs love triangle but we don't feel like bashing Ronnie! And a planning and plotting villain but still we all like Manaav and Khalid even Malvika!😳
So don't take it seriously. Its jst a start may b we might get wat we expect from small screen in coming years.😳 At least thy made an attempt!😳
sonyjknum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Agree with u but will have to wait what is to follow because Kabir is quite relaxed and he did say Ananya this is why u were not allowed to come alone he was almost guessing all their moves I dont think he is that surprised but will have to wait and see
As for Khalid well he only needs ratings and that is true of todays times
But yes Kabir should have and I dont know why but I think he does have something up his sleeve

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".