is it fair for emon? - Page 2

Originally posted by: ArielAngel

ofcourse not!!! javedjii has completely lost it . I dunno what he sees in ankita how can he possibly say that ankita is better than emon . He said he wud choose ankita bcuzz she can perform rite?? O Gosh!! please someone remind him that this show is all about singing and not performance. Furthermore, he said we dont need emon cuz he copy's sonu..wat?? how can no one else see that..I dont think emon is copying sonu at all!!
Javedjii is at least 50-60 years old, so shouldnt he understand that demoralizing a contestant in such a wayy can ruin a teenagers career??
Sorry all javed akhtar fans , but i must say that javedjii is not what he seems to be. He is worser than anu malik!!

i agree with u 100%

this whole show has been unfair to Emon since the beginning of the gala rounds.

When he first started, he did a great job with both singing and performing, and yet he was called "overconfident" by Anu Mallik...
He comes back, giving up with his performance and focusing on sur, does an even better job, and is then criticized for not performing enough

Then even with his phenomenal singing, the judges start to say that he sounds like Sonu. He sounds like him when he sings Sonu's songs, but it feels like the judges have completely forgotten all his great performance that weren't Sonu songs!

Also, even though Emon consistenly gives great performances, the judges will always pick on him for these stupid things- whether it's sounding too much like Sonu or being overconfident. And I think it's incredibly unfair that when Prashant, Amit, or Ankita ever went out of sur, forgot lyrics, or anything important, the judges would be all "Oh, you went out of sur a bit, but I'll forgive you for that"

But when Emon gave one less than great performance (his disco song), the judges made a really big deal about it

And now to top it all off, Javed tells him to his face that Ankita will succeed and he won't? Wow, way to be Javed- crush the dreams of an 18 year old. Real mature, buddy, really mature 😕 😕

sorry for the rant, but it needed to be said