JA's outburst scripted like last week?

Was JA's outburst scripted to get Emon sympathy votes?

Emon is a good singer, and when asked by Mini about the contestant, why JA specifically tragetted Emon? Was it scripted, so that it can get Emon sympathy votes and create drama? Last week it was Alisha who created drama for Chang and this week Javed Akhtar? last week the gala round even started with Chang visiting Alisha's house. This week JA cant do a walkout since he is a veteran, but Sony needed so hype and masala TRP, so JA's outburst??

Also, it got the neccessary attention towards Emon? Was all it scripted? what are your views? I am totally confused..

if that was scripted, then Javed should quit being a lyricist and become an actor...

If it was scripted, then I have nothing left to say about Javed Ji. If someone can play according to a script for money, then there is something seriously wrong with that person. Javed Ji always talks about usool so according to me it was not scripted.

He said what he felt. But I don't agree with him playing astrolger and predicting an 18 year old's future.

I don think it was scripted....He just took out his frustation of losing Ankita over EMON!!!! Wow... wot a judge

Personally, I hope more than anything it was scripted, and Javed Saab is not really like that. If so, I have nothing more to say on this topic. Javed Akhtar has always been one of my favorite people, I admire and look up to him. Not just because he works in bollywood and composes beautiful lyrics, but I admire him as a person. His morals, reserve, the very way he speaks. Seeing him argue with Anu Malik, like two hot headed, ignorant, teen age boys broke my heart. I'm still upset, but the scripting thought gives me hope.

This reminds me of last week's Alisha and Anu fight, which just looked scripted. Javed was more convincing(horrible as it is), but I never knew that Javed wanted Ankita to win.....he never seemed to favor her before now. If so, I've never noticed it.


~Lady Black~

Originally posted by: eshika

I don think it was scripted....He just took out his frustation of losing Ankita over EMON!!!! Wow... wot a judge

not just that but the day before, noone picked his song, so he showed his frustration on emon

Originally posted by: Lady Black

Personally, I hope more than anything it was scripted, and Javed Saab is not really like that. If so, I have nothing more to say on this topic. Javed Akhtar has always been one of my favorite people, I admire and look up to him. Not just because he works in bollywood and composes beautiful lyrics, but I admire him as a person. His morals, reserve, the very way he speaks. Seeing him argue with Anu Malik, like two hot headed, ignorant, teen age boys broke my heart. I'm still upset, but the scripting thought gives me hope.

This reminds me of last week's Alisha and Anu fight, which just looked scripted. Javed was more convincing(horrible as it is), but I never knew that Javed wanted Ankita to win.....he never seemed to favor her before now. If so, I've never noticed it.


~Lady Black~

I admired him as well .... but now it is history .... The reason he has given to back Ankita (womens lib etc) is all BS. If it is true it should have been done for a better singer like Deepali.

If it was not scripted, he lost his reputation.... If it was scripted he came down tumbling from the padestal, even harder.... why? because for a few rupees he agreed to ACT in such a way that he didn't care for the dreams of an 18 year old kid being shattered . He did not even care for a mother, crying silently for her son😭

Originally posted by: identt

I admired him as well .... but now it is history .... The reason he has given to back Ankita (womens lib etc) is all BS. If it is true it should have been done for a better singer like Deepali.

If it was not scripted, he lost his reputation.... If it was scripted he came down tumbling from the padestal, even harder.... why? because for a few rupees he agreed to ACT in such a way that he didn't care for the dreams of an 18 year old kid being shattered . He did not even care for a mother, crying silently for her son😭

Areh wah. One day he is the best judge. Next he is greedy money hungry scum.

I dont think Javed ji lost his reputation because a few teen age brats are having a tantrum. None of us have his achivements or stature. So lets not make it a habit to insult him.

Actually, for me it's the fact that a man of his achievements and stature acted like such an idiot. I understand that he was upset, but what was the need to take it out on Emon?

Originally posted by: doctorwordsmith

Actually, for me it's the fact that a man of his achievements and stature acted like such an idiot. I understand that he was upset, but what was the need to take it out on Emon?

Acted like an idiot? Wow.

JA spoke the truth about Emon's voice. IT might not be what you want to hear about your favorite contestant. Emon acha gata hai, technically very good. But he DOES not have the voice quality. Yeh sach hain.

JA shut out Anu Mallik who has bee extremely obnoxious the entire season, cutting everyone else off and manipulating and even abusing some of the other judges. JA actually stopped AM from making a tamasha. Anu Mallik needed to be told a zillion time to NOT butt in by JA sahab. Atlast some one with guts to shut AM out.

I have even more respect for JA. Lets not call him crapy names.

I cant help but wonder how many of these 'outraged' people are bengali...