Toshi Natik's

Ok , let me just say that I for the record was not happy with Toshi being off the show...

having said that what is this Natik now with bring back Toshi....either bring everyone back or no one,

I particularily dont like the fact that they choose always someone some singer to raise this point with, today now they have made it sound like Ishmeet got a 10 because they felt everyone should get a 10...what crap... I gaurantee that Ishmeet will be gone next week as they have totally destroyed his performance by talking about Toshi and all this crap...

GARBAGE...

I understand your reasoning birdpro. But I think the reason behind the "Bring back Toshi" situation is because he was voted out SO early from the show. Not because his singing wasn't up to par with everyone else. If a person is that talented, he should be given enough chances to showcase their potential. If Toshi was voted out during the final 3-4 stage, that's reasonable because as we've seen, this competition has many talented contestants and it's hard to choose just ONE who is the most deserving.

About Ishmeet..I definitely felt bad for him. He seems like a really genuine, nice person. You can see it in his expressions that he knows he's not a great singer in comparison to others but he comes back every week with that sweet smile. But I think for every ounce of sadness I feel for him, I feel double the amount of bitterness to see the downfalls of people like Toshi and Arshpreet.

But I definitely don't think Ishmeet will leave us next week. You probably end up getting one taste of Chakravat first before getting eliminated.

thanks Shrutikav
you have really answered my question and query very nicely..
and yes I see what you are saying...

basically I am sying if we bring toshi back you can't forget arshpreet, really after listening to abhilasha today, there is NO way she is better the arshpreet...

Bring back the wild card and a criteria with a wider appeal and a view of serving music. Arshpreet , Prantika or for that matter any one not even in audition should be given proper review.

w/ever it is .. i think toshi should should be brought back

All the same!
toshi didnt get out because of his singing but because of votes and i dont think its fair!
they should bring toshi back!!

guyz pliiz sign petition ASAP on http://www.petitiononline.com/Toshi/petition-sign.html? if u want toshi back n nt signed it yet.

Wild card re-entry will be a tricky issue.If judges do it now it will be betrayal of public voting,however erratic it may be.On the other hand ,public voting for wild card may not bring back Toshi.In fact they should have anticipated such a situation and announced in the beginning that judges can bring back one or two losers.
What happened to tyhe earlier announcement that judges voting will be 50 %?

most people voted out were because of Votes not bad singing so why seperate Toshi as voted out because of poor voting.

Star and Gaj Ji will have to be fair and will be challanging for them to bringing back any one randomly.

SRIRAM was very good, he should be brought back in WILD CARD ENTRY!