Javed Saab Is perfectly right when he...

Javed saab knows film industry in and out ,he knows people's opinion on stars and all...................he knows what people talk in market.................Sonu nigam is highly respected name in music industry ..............and he saying emon will not become playback singer is actually an understatement .....the way industry works ...........................people dont even think of replacing sonu...............to sonu jaisi awwaz aur woh bhi patli si ..................common think of it guys we like emon because he is emon the cute kid ................Emon ko bahot koshish karni padegi ki woh sonu jaisa sound na kare to hi usko kaam milega...................................

JAVED sir looked to haughty when he was trying to control anu malik but yes now somebody should learn to control him too................and may be this is the way..........................

Originally posted by: lillyleens

Javed saab knows film industry in and out ,he knows people's opinion on stars and all...................he knows what people talk in market.................Sonu nigam is highly respected name in music industry ..............and he saying emon will not become playback singer is actually an understatement .....the way industry works ...........................people dont even think of replacing sonu...............to sonu jaisi awwaz aur woh bhi patli si ..................common think of it guys we like emon because he is emon the cute kid ................Emon ko bahot koshish karni padegi ki woh sonu jaisa sound na kare to hi usko kaam milega...................................

JAVED sir looked to haughty when he was trying to control anu malik but yes now somebody should learn to control him too................and may be this is the way..........................

So Emon has a thin voice. What about Shaan? He too has a thin voice but he is the one who sings the most songs nowdays. What about Karunya, he too has a thin voice but he too is getting success these days. What about Abhijeet Sawant? He too has a thin voice, but has had 2 successful albums.

So is a heavy manly voice like Udit, Kishore Kumar, Abhijeet, KK, Shankar, etc a prerequisite to become a famous playback singer? Does a singer like Shaan sound pale if he sings with the orchestra?

That was nonsense talk by Javed Akhtar. I think people are forgetting he is a lyricist not a music director. If he has such great knowledge of music and is so intelligent, why doesn't he compose music. Who knows more about music and who will make a good playback singer? A music director like Anu Malik, one of the top 5 music directors in the country and who actually makes music or Javed Akhtar, a guy who writes lyrics.

i dunno.. wht to say..
i get wht yurh trying to say..
but emon doesnt alwayss* sound like sonu ji
obviously sonu ji's better

yea emon will hav to wurk .. but thtz eveeryone these days.. yuh jus dont get wht yuh want like tht..

but at least.. he has the capability to get there.. he can sing.. he might sound a lil like sonu.. but he has sung other songs too.. which were just as gud..

all im trying to say is tht.. javed A.. didnt hav to say.. tht emon is good for nothing.. thtz wayy to harsh.. i felt it harsher than anu malik's comments somthing

he may be knowing a lot n he can certainly have his own views...the point is how can he demoralize a 18 year old kid like that??

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

So Emon has a thin voice. What about Shaan? He too has a thin voice but he is the one who sings the most songs nowdays. What about Karunya, he too has a thin voice but he too is getting success these days. What about Abhijeet Sawant? He too has a thin voice, but has had 2 successful albums.

So is a heavy manly voice like Udit, Kishore Kumar, Abhijeet, KK, Shankar, etc a prerequisite to become a famous playback singer? Does a singer like Shaan sound pale if he sings with the orchestra?

That was nonsense talk by Javed Akhtar. I think people are forgetting he is a lyricist not a music director. If he has such great knowledge of music and is so intelligent, why doesn't he compose music. Who knows more about music and who will make a good playback singer? A music director like Anu Malik, one of the top 5 music directors in the country and who actually makes music or Javed Akhtar, a guy who writes lyrics.

yu took the wordz rite outta my mouth.. i completely agree wid yu👏

javed sir is not always right.
these day's i don't know what the hell is going on in javed sir's head.



😡 😡 😡

wow! it's funny how Javed A. is the suddenly the evil, incompetent judge.

no JAVED SIR GAVE HIS OWN OBSERVATION AND HE SAID TO ANKITA TOO THAT WILL NOT BECOME A SUCCESSFUL PLAYBACK SINGER AND SAMETHING HE SAID TO EMON THAT HE WILL NOT BECOME A SUCCESSFUL PLAYBACK SINGER BUT HE NEVER SAID THAT HE WON'T.........................................

Emon has a thin voice. What about Shaan? He too has a thin voice but he is the one who sings the most songs nowdays. What about Karunya, he too has a thin voice but he too is getting success these days. What about Abhijeet Sawant? He too has a thin voice, but has had 2 successful albums

OK SHAAN HAS THIN VOICE BUT HE DOESN'T SOUND LIKE SONU ATLEAST TO HIS CREDIT HEDOESN'T SOUND LIKE ANY ONE ....................

FOR YOUR INFO WHEN VINIT WAS SAREGAMA PA 2005
HIMESH ALSO REQUESTED HIM TO BE DIFFERENT THAN SONU ........................SO HE CAN GET MORE WORK IF YOU SOUND LIKE SAME NOBODY IS GOING TO REALLY CARE CAUSE SINGERS ARE NOT SO HIGHLY PAID PEOPLE ...........................SO PRODUCER CAN STILL AFFORD A SINGER WHO HAS HIGHEST PRICE IN THE MARKET OVER THE CLONES

Please continue all discussions about JA-Anu about emon/ankita here.

https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=721581

~Topic Closed