Emon- the best today - Page 2

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

Amit sang two romantic songs. He sounded the same in both, though he did a fantastic job.

Emon sang two different type of songs and sounded different in both. He was more versatile. And if Emon sounded like Sonu in the first song, I think that's a job well done. Because the song cannot be sung in any other way other then the way Sonu sang the song. It is not enough to sound like Sonu in this song, you have get the emotions right and noone seems to find that missing. So according to me, he did a great job.

I am not saying Emon was bad, he was good. But to me Kal ho na ho was not one of his best performances.

HECK YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 👏

Originally posted by: Neelu.RoX

I am not saying Emon was bad, he was good. But to me Kal ho na ho was not one of his best performances.

Like I said earlier, this is the modern day classic song. No song of today's generation comes close to this song. There are very very very few people who might hate this song. Noone, not even any of the leading playback singers today can this song like Sonu. Emon at 18 years of age did justice to this song. It did not sound horrible or did not have the emotions missing. For me that is a job well done for this song. Of course this was not his best, but you can't expect anybody to sing this song better then Sonu or come even close to Sonu.

Emon did an excellent job and I stand by that. I really wish Sonu had heard him sing this song.

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

After watching the gala today, I have to say that I thought Emon was the best. He was the only one who showed his versatality in both songs. Kal ho na ho is a completely different song from Dil bar mere. Amit and Prashant sang both romantic songs, though Amit did a fantastic job. Ankita sang item numbers as she usually does.

Emon really is the most versatile singer in the competition and his pitching during Dil bar mere was awesome. The guy can sing Sonu to Abhijeet to Nusrat to Kailash and now Kishore Kumar. I always thought Emon is good at high pitch but never really heard him sing low notes. But after hearing him sing Kal ho na ho, I think he can make any song sound fantastic. Javed Ji said any singer can sing this song, but for me noone can come close to Sonu in singing this song. But Emon sang the song so well with such feelings. Outstanding job.

After Javed Ji's biased comments I know he will most likely be out tomorrow. But after hearing Emon today, I know that Emon will become a great playback singer and this is one decision the audience will regret in the future.

ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. I FULLY AGREE WITH YOU. BUT THE JUDGES WANT A DANCER TO MAKE AN ALBUM FOR SONY WITH ABHIJIT FOR SONY TO EARN MORE. AND YOU KNOW SOME BESURA PUBLIC ...... HOPE ALL EMON FANS VOTED ENOUGH YESTERDAY AND IF THEY HAVE NOT ..... THEN FEEL GUILTY ALL OF US.

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

Amit sang two romantic songs. He sounded the same in both, though he did a fantastic job.

Emon sang two different type of songs and sounded different in both. He was more versatile. And if Emon sounded like Sonu in the first song, I think that's a job well done. Because the song cannot be sung in any other way other then the way Sonu sang the song. It is not enough to sound like Sonu in this song, you have get the emotions right and noone seems to find that missing. So according to me, he did a great job.

Right that song could not have been sung in a different tone or way. the song is such and emon did full justice to the song. NO ONE CAN SING THIS SONG AS WELL AS EMON DID . IT HAS TO HAVE TO EMOTIONS AND FEELINGS AND THE TUNE PERFECT AS IT IS A SLOW SONG . HE DID A GREAT JOB. IT WOULD NOT HAVE SOUNDED GOOD ON AMIT'S VOICE. SO WHAT JUDGES TELLING IS WRONG.

Well i stand by opinion, so dont presure your opinion upon me. This was just my view. Just because i didnt think he was the best, i didnt say he was bad either.

Originally posted by: Neelu.RoX

Well i stamd by opinion, so dont presure your opinion upon me. This was just my view. Just because i didnt think he was the best, i didnt say he was bad either.

no...I agree with you. Amit was clearly the best.

GO EMON!!! YOU ROCK!!!!!!! 👏 👏 👏