Flaw in Point format by judges...

Is it just me or does any one else notice it too...that the judges are always tough as bells on the first 2-3 contestants...than they start softening up to the point that they give mediocre performances a straight 10...like esp ID ji u'll notice this with him like no tomarow...the first few ppl low marks afterwards "i wanna help these kids in their career 10" ermm what about the previous 2-3...

vishal and shekhar are mostly stuck in previous performances...

HR is god knows best doing what...

Bappida is sometimes or more than often with his marks you feel 😡

all and all...the marks they give are never in key when u compare all the contestants together...some are hard-doned...some win a lottery...

ur views?

ID's marking never makes any sense to me. Last friday i remember him sayin something like "i'm not gona focus on the negative things but Im gona givve u 10 for all the good things."

His job is to look at the negative/positive and give marks according to that. If he gives 10 to all of them then I don't see y we have him as a judge.
JUdges need to toughen up and tell the singers what they are doing rong n give marks accordingly.

"mind blowing" just doesnt work for me. lol I dont know much about music so I wanna know what the singers' strengths and weaknesses are.

Thats all.

These mentors are imbeciles about singing as far as I am concerned. When you give someone 10 out 10, it means that singer has extraordinary talent, cannot improve. I have not heard any one contestant there who is a perfect 10. What is wrong with these guys?Are they tuned out of singing? and just because they like the person, they give 10s like giving kids candy bars.
The whole contest now is a farce.

They give 10's like it's Christmas
I Give 9, but for all the mothers in the world, I give you one more"
VS = "You rocked this song! 10"
BL = "tumne acha gaya" he'd almost never give 10 unless if told by Guest/ Contestants mentor

in the begining gallas if i remember correctly they used to give like 7's and 8's and even lower...which kinda made sense...but if they start giving the crapiest performance of the day 10/10 and than to the best they go i wanna give more but only 10/10 than that means there really isnt no dif between good or bad...they should standardize their voting...and also sometimes what happens is the round-off pointing by the last judge...if the first two mentors gave 10's the last mentor has it in his hand to either make it or break it depending on their bias...the judges should just vote all at the same time...and than zee/aditya should announce that this judge gave this many and ask than the judges why and than the guru how he thinks...not when all the judges know what thte other judges are giving and they then manipulate the points by going high or low...

Originally posted by: wrapedup

in the begining gallas if i remember correctly they used to give like 7's and 8's and even lower...which kinda made sense...but if they start giving the crapiest performance of the day 10/10 and than to the best they go i wanna give more but only 10/10 than that means there really isnt no dif between good or bad...they should standardize their voting...and also sometimes what happens is the round-off pointing by the last judge...if the first two mentors gave 10's the last mentor has it in his hand to either make it or break it depending on their bias...the judges should just vote all at the same time...and than zee/aditya should announce that this judge gave this many and ask than the judges why and than the guru how he thinks...not when all the judges know what thte other judges are giving and they then manipulate the points by going high or low...

gallas??
Throats?
and I have no idea what you said in the end, afte bias

my bad i didnt mean gallas...what ever on earth zee calls they fri and sat shows...thats what i meant to call it...dont be so dumb founded...

Originally posted by: wrapedup

my bad i didnt mean gallas...what ever on earth zee calls they fri and sat shows...thats what i meant to call it...dont be so dumb founded...

😆😆😆
looks like your from Indian Idol section [right?]

i dont know for previous performances but i've never seen ID give less than 10 to anyone these days. correct me if im wrong.

hes changed a lot since the last season.. he was a lot stricter 😕